HT Image
HT Image

No news is bad news

A news channel loses the right to be regarded as a news channel when it starts presenting genuine stories in a sensational and trivial manner, writes Vir Sanghvi.
By Vir Sanghvi | None
UPDATED ON JUL 29, 2007 08:54 AM IST

On Thursday, the Supreme Court finally took a stand on the contentious and controversial issue of television sting operations. The judges asked for an unconditional apology from a Zee News reporter who had conducted a sting operation seeking to reveal corruption in the lower judiciary. Asked the Chief Justice of India, “What public good has the reporter done? Prime facie, he has committed a serious crime.”

I do not want to go into the rights and wrongs of that particular case. And certainly, despite the tenor of the judgment, there is some merit in the argument offered by Arun Jaitley, counsel for Zee News, that the channel had first submitted the tapes of the sting operation to the judiciary and only then broadcast them. Jaitley argued that Zee News had behaved with responsibility and that the intention had not been to denigrate the judicial system.

No matter who you agree with — Jaitley or the Chief Justice — there is little doubt that the case will once again focus attention on the ethics of news television. Moreover, the judgment comes at a time when the Information and Broadcasting Ministry is circulating a draft Broadcasting Bill that many media professionals regard as going against the spirit of a free press.

The I&B minister has often asked for a debate on the role of the press and the limits to its freedom. But despite many rounds of discussions with broadcasters, no serious debate has taken place and no ethical guidelines have emerged.

As a journalist, I am bitterly opposed to any kind of governmental control on the media. I have written in this column about how disturbing it is that the I&B Ministry can simply ban TV channels if they transgress some bureaucrat’s sense of ‘decency’. And I have called for a regulator who maintains an arm’s length relationship from the political establishment and retains the respect of the media.

But I do believe that a genuine and robust debate is long overdue. There are many issues that need to be considered but, taking the Supreme Court judgment as a starting point, let’s focus on just two of them this Sunday.

The first is: when does a news channel lose the right to be regarded as a news channel? Anybody who has watched the staggering decline in quality on the Hindi news channels will know what I am talking about. So far, English news channels have not followed suit, but the trend is dangerous.

It began with the tabloid-isation of real news: genuine stories were presented in a sensational and trivial manner. Then, it went on to include an overturning of normal news priorities. If Rakhi Sawant alleges that a man has kissed her without permission, then this is a bigger story than, say, the nuclear deal, the presidential election or the death of hundreds of people in a natural disaster.

But now, it has gone even further. The Hindi news channels now cover ‘stories’ that would not normally be defined as news. Many of them run comedy programmes featuring stand-up comics who do not even bother to satirise the news (as, say, Poll Khol on Star News or Gustakhi Maaf on NDTV India do). Some even run largely fictional serials that would not be out of place on entertainment channels.

What news there is tends to be manufactured. Is there an outcry about bar girls? Great! That’s a perfect excuse for the channels to run a half-hour programme which consists of a bar girl dancing. Is a man’s wife objecting to his mistress? Terrific, let’s get them in the studio to fight for two hours.

Each time the issue is debated, the Hindi channels offer the same defence: it works. And that’s true. The ratings demonstrate that news channels that carry little or no news do significantly better than those that steer clear of entertainment.

Each time this argument is trotted out, most of us shake our heads sadly and say things like “It’s a business — these channels have to make money” or “What can the channels do if this is what viewers want?”

I have two responses to this. The first is that in a competitive market, the viewer will always call the shots. And so, if the channels are attracting viewers, then good for them. Except — and this is an important distinction — TRP figures alone do not give them the right to be regarded as news channels. To be considered a news channel, you need, self-evidently, to carry news programming.

Secondly, once you stop treating them as news channels, then their TRP figures are not terribly impressive. Star News may have as little to do with news as Star Plus, but Star Plus has millions more viewers. Treat the Hindi news channels as entertainment channels, then all they are is low-budget, reality-based versions of Sony, Star Plus and Zee TV — with ratings that aren’t even in the same league.

Why is the distinction significant? Well, because entertainment channels are not entitled to the freedoms traditionally guaranteed to the news media. Nobody at Star Plus talks about freedom of the press. But all news channels treat themselves as deserving of special consideration because they are journalistic enterprises.

The question that we in the media have to answer is this: why should we regard these reality-based, low-cost entertainment channels as being part of the news business? Ban AXN or Fashion TV and somebody like me may write one or two outraged articles, but most journalists don’t give a damn. But if the government tries to ban a news channel, just imagine how much of an uproar there would be about infringement of freedom of the press.

And yet, the arguments for the ban would be roughly the same. AXN and Fashion TV had violated public standards by running risqué material. Many news channels have violated the standards of our society by showing titillating programming, violent crimes and by encouraging primitive superstition because of their bizarre obsession with ghosts.

It is not my case that any news channel should be banned. I opposed the bans on AXN and Fashion TV, so I am not in favour of any bans. But my point is: are we prepared to let entertainment channels use the freedoms available to news media when they carry no real news?

Intertwined with the ethics of the Hindi news channels, is this whole business of sting operations. I confess to being confused about the rights and wrongs of stings. I am uneasy about hidden cameras and false moustaches. But I also take the point that, often, there are stories that can only be brought to light by using such methods.

Nevertheless, given how all-pervasive TV stings are, I think we now need to have some standards for the whole industry. I am not sure what these should be but here are some suggestions:

I think content is important. If a hidden camera reveals that lawyers are trying to bribe a witness, then this may well be in the public interest. But if the camera shows us that Shakti Kapoor is making a pass at a woman, then this is not necessarily in the public interest, no matter how much it interests the public.
Entrapment is a dangerous area. I am uncomfortable with channels that encourage people to break the law or to do things that they would not normally have done only so that the channel gets a story.
All journalists function on the basis of an on-the-record/off-the-record distinction. If sources are worried that what they say will be secretly taped or filmed, they will stop giving information to journalists. The Watergate scandal was broken because an FBI official leaked information to

The Washington Post

. If Deep Throat had believed that Bob Woodward was secretly filming him, he would never have spilt the beans, and Richard Nixon would have served out his full term.
There is a larger issue of individual privacy versus press freedom. We are willing to compromise on an individual’s right to privacy if we feel that it advances the public interest. But many stings are clearly not in the public interest or, even, within the domain of journalism as we know it. Why should ‘news’ channels be allowed to trample on individual privacy only because they misuse the principles of freedom of the press?

These are complicated issues, and none of us has all the answers. But it is imperative that journalists evolve some guidelines for ourselves.

The Broadcasting Bill acquires a certain bogus legitimacy because the government is within its rights to say that if the media do not have any standards, then somebody else should make the rules. Similarly, Zee News would have been on much stronger grounds if it had been able to tell the Supreme Court that there was a journalistic code of conduct and its behaviour fell within its limits.

Sooner or later, we in the media will find that governmental bodies will step in. And because we have done nothing about setting our own guidelines, we will be obliged to accept somebody else’s.

And if we do not regulate ourselves, then as the events of the last fortnight demonstrate, the government and the courts will do it for us.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Allegations of leaking of question paper and proxies writing examination in test to recruit agriculture officers in MP have surfaced, reminding people of the Vyapam scam.(Representative photo)
Allegations of leaking of question paper and proxies writing examination in test to recruit agriculture officers in MP have surfaced, reminding people of the Vyapam scam.(Representative photo)

‘Another Vyapam’: Agriculture officers recruitment exam candidates allege fixing

By Shruti Tomar, Bhopal
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:29 PM IST
  • A candidate questioned by MPPEB allowed a tainted company to conduct the exam. The same company was blacklisted by UP after a question paper of recruitment exam for sub-inspectors got leaked in 2017, he alleged.
Close
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi (ANI)
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi (ANI)

'Not enough': BJP's Anil Vij on Rahul Gandhi 'accepting' Emergency was a mistake

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:28 PM IST
"Today he is also leading the same party. If Rahul Gandhi has to atone for the imposition of emergency, then he should leave the dictatorial Congress party," Haryana home minister Anil Vij tweeted.
Close
The Bombay High Court directed OTT platform Amazon to take down the movie within 24 hours until the said scene is deleted.(HT Photo)
The Bombay High Court directed OTT platform Amazon to take down the movie within 24 hours until the said scene is deleted.(HT Photo)

Bombay HC asks Amazon to take down film over actor's defamation case

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:18 PM IST
  • Justice Gautam Patel on Tuesday heard a defamation suit filed by model and actor Sakshi Malik against Venkateshwara Creations Pvt Ltd for allegedly using her photograph without permission in their movie.
Close
On the occasion of World Wildlife Day, various ministers took to Twitter to raise awareness around various issues concerned with wildlife and its conservation.(ANI Photo)
On the occasion of World Wildlife Day, various ministers took to Twitter to raise awareness around various issues concerned with wildlife and its conservation.(ANI Photo)

World Wildlife Day 2021: India seeing steady rise in animal population

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:14 PM IST
The theme of World Wildlife Day 2021 — Forests and Livelihoods: Sustaining People and Planet — is set in alignment with the UN Sustainable Development Goals.
Close
Karnataka water resources minister Ramesh Jarkiholi resigned from the Cabinet on Wednesday.(Twitter/@BYRBJP)
Karnataka water resources minister Ramesh Jarkiholi resigned from the Cabinet on Wednesday.(Twitter/@BYRBJP)

'Even though I am innocent': Karnataka minister resigns over alleged sex tape

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:35 PM IST
'Allegation against me is far from the truth,' the minister wrote in his resignation letter, which has been accepted by the chief minister.
Close
Mumbai: A health worker takes swab sample of a resident for COVID-19 testing in a housing society, amid a surge in coronavirus cases, at Nehru Nagar in Mumbai, Thursday, Feb. 18, 2021. (PTI Photo/Kunal Patil)(PTI02_18_2021_000073B)(PTI)
Mumbai: A health worker takes swab sample of a resident for COVID-19 testing in a housing society, amid a surge in coronavirus cases, at Nehru Nagar in Mumbai, Thursday, Feb. 18, 2021. (PTI Photo/Kunal Patil)(PTI02_18_2021_000073B)(PTI)

No new deaths in 24 States/UTs including MP, Telangana: Health ministry

ANI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:04 PM IST
The 24 States and UTs include Madhya Pradesh, Telangana, Jammu and Kashmir, Uttarakhand, Jharkhand, Goa, Bihar, Puducherry, Himachal Pradesh, Assam, Lakshadweep, Manipur, Meghalaya, Sikkim, Daman and Diu & Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh, Ladakh, Tripura, Nagaland, and Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
Close
President Ram Nath Kovind got inoculated against Covid-19 at Delhi’s RR Hospital on Wednesday(ANI)
President Ram Nath Kovind got inoculated against Covid-19 at Delhi’s RR Hospital on Wednesday(ANI)

President Kovind receives first dose of Covid-19 vaccine at Delhi’s RR hospital

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Ayshee Bhaduri, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 01:40 PM IST
  • With today’s vaccination, the President joins the ranks of statesmen and politicians who have gotten vaccinated since the second phase of vaccination started on March 1.
Close
Every type of crime is at its peak in Uttar Pradesh and there is a very bad state of crime control, Mayawati charged.(ANI File Photo)
Every type of crime is at its peak in Uttar Pradesh and there is a very bad state of crime control, Mayawati charged.(ANI File Photo)

Mayawati slams Uttar Pradesh govt over law and order situation in state

PTI, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 01:36 PM IST
Mayawati also targeted the BJP government at the Centre over the issue of Dalit rights.
Close
**EDS: TWITTER IMAGE POSTED BY @PIBTvpm ON WEDNESDAY, MARCH 3, 2021** Thiruvananthapuram: Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan receives the first dose of COVID vaccine in Thiruvananthapuram. (PTI Photo)(PTI03_03_2021_000031B)(PTI)
**EDS: TWITTER IMAGE POSTED BY @PIBTvpm ON WEDNESDAY, MARCH 3, 2021** Thiruvananthapuram: Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan receives the first dose of COVID vaccine in Thiruvananthapuram. (PTI Photo)(PTI03_03_2021_000031B)(PTI)

Kerala CM takes first shot of Covid-19 vaccine

ANI, Thiruvananthapuram
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 01:31 PM IST
  • The Chief Minister appealed to all eligible people to come forward and get themselves vaccinated.
Close
Open cast coal mines at Jharia in Dhanbad.(Representative Photo/HT)
Open cast coal mines at Jharia in Dhanbad.(Representative Photo/HT)

Centre proposes to take over mine auction, some states oppose

By Gerard de Souza, Chetan Chauhan, New Delhi/goa
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 01:17 PM IST
  • The amendment also empowers the Central government to auction mines, which the states have failed to auction. Of the 143 such mines listed for auctioning, states have auctioned only 7 since 2015, the amendment said.
Close
Anurag Kashyap, Vikramaditya Motwane, producer Madhu Mantena, and Vikas Bahl came together to found film production company, Phantom Films, in Mumbai in 2011
Anurag Kashyap, Vikramaditya Motwane, producer Madhu Mantena, and Vikas Bahl came together to found film production company, Phantom Films, in Mumbai in 2011

I-T raids at properties of Anurag Kashyap, Vikas Bahl, Taapsee Pannu in Mumbai

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 02:06 PM IST
Commenting on the ongoing raids, Union minister Prakash Javadekar said the agencies only go after those against whom they have credible information.
Close
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)
The Supreme Court. (HT archive)

News updates from HT | 'Not sedition': SC rejects plea against Farooq Abdullah

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 12:45 PM IST
  • Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Serum Institute of India's executive director Natasha Poonawalla took her first dose of Covishield on Tuesday.
Serum Institute of India's executive director Natasha Poonawalla took her first dose of Covishield on Tuesday.

'Proud': Adar Poonawalla's wife Natasha's message after taking Covid-19 vaccine

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 12:41 PM IST
Only after thorough rounds of local and international clinical trials, Covishield vaccines were deemed safe and effective, Natasha wrote.
Close
The world’s No. 3 oil importer and consumer expects strong demand for transport and industrial fuels to drive next year’s rebound. Consumption of diesel an economic barometer and the country’s most-used fuel will grow by more than 13%, as will demand for gasoline.(PTI)
The world’s No. 3 oil importer and consumer expects strong demand for transport and industrial fuels to drive next year’s rebound. Consumption of diesel an economic barometer and the country’s most-used fuel will grow by more than 13%, as will demand for gasoline.(PTI)

Demand for gasoline, diesel in India will reach record 215.24 mln in 1 yr: PPAC

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 12:20 PM IST
Demand for gasoline, diesel and other fuels will reach a record 215.24 million tons in the 12 months through March 2022, according to estimates by the Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell of India’s oil ministry.
Close
Jammu and Kashmir National Conference president Farooq Abdullah(AFP file)
Jammu and Kashmir National Conference president Farooq Abdullah(AFP file)

'Not sedition to have views different from govt': SC junks plea against Abdullah

Written by Prashasti Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 03, 2021 12:26 PM IST
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Hemant Gupta said that expressing views which are different from the opinion of the government will not be seditious.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP