HT Image
HT Image

SC direction in Pathribal incident: Families guarded, human rights activist unhappy

The Supreme Court (SC) direction on Tuesday in the Pathribal fake encounter case, in which five civilians were allegedly killed by the army in south Kashmir 12 years ago, has raised a glimmer of hope among the victim families but they are guarded in claiming victory “until the personnel involved are not punished”.
By Peerzada Ashiq | Hindustan Times, Srinagar
UPDATED ON MAY 01, 2012 04:56 PM IST

The Supreme Court (SC) direction on Tuesday in the Pathribal fake encounter case, in which five civilians were allegedly killed by the army in south Kashmir 12 years ago, has raised a glimmer of hope among the victim families but they are guarded in claiming victory “until the personnel involved are not punished”.

“In the last one decade, we have suffered a lot. Finally, we can heave a sigh of relief. It was not a simple case but a well-planned cold-blooded murder of innocent civilians,” said Abdul Rasheed Khan (34), son of victim Juma Khan.

Khan also lost brother Rafiq Khan to security forces’ bullets when he was part of a protest rally demanding justice for his father near Brakpora immediately after the incident.
Most families, however, see the SC direction as the case inching towards justice. “The truth is finally coming to the fore and it was not possible without the CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) investigations. But justice in incomplete till the culprits are handed over exemplary punishment…The case need to be tried in criminal court and not in the army court,” said Shakoor Ahmad (38), son of another namesake victim Juma Khan.

Just five days after 34 Sikhs were massacred by unknown gunmen in south Kashmir’s Chattisinghpora village on March 20 in Anantnag district, the army claimed killing five Lashkar-e-Tayyeba militants at Pathribal involved in the incident. Later, it turned out the killed men were civilian from nearby villages.

The CBI argued before the SC that the killings “were cold-blooded murders and the accused officials deserve to be meted out exemplary punishment.”
“We hope the culprits will not be shielded anymore. The killings were carried out for rewards by those who tout to be protectors,” said Ahmad.
Other five families refused to talk to the media expressing indifference to the SC direction.

But the spotlight on the case, widely reported by the international media, is growing tighter with many seeing it as a testing case to lay foundation for allowing justice to take course in other similar cases in a state wracked by violence in the last two decades.

Kashmir’s leading human rights lawyer Pervaiz Imroz, however, describes the judgment as “unfortunate”. “The CBI contended before the SC that the killings were not in line with the duty, so the SC should not have given the option to seek sanction first from the Centre.

According to the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA), only in cases where an act was in line with duty, a sanction was required. Today’s judgment is legal victory for the army,” said Imroz adding, “the case should go to criminal court”.

Imroz said many other victims families of similar fake encounters “may not be encouraged to come forward by the SC direction”.
The SC on Tuesday endorsed that a prior permission of the central government is needed to prosecute army officers. It said the army will decide in eight weeks whether the officer accused of fake encounter will be court Martialled or face criminal trial.

Timeline of the case
1) March 20, 2000: On eve of former US president Bill Clinton’s visit to India in March 2000, 35 Sikhs were massacred by unknown gunmen.
2) March 25, 2000: Army claims killing seven foreign LeT militants in Pathribal involved in the incident.
3) On April 3, 2000: Security forces open firing on local protesters, killing seven at Brakpora, while demanding exhumation of the bodies and whereabouts of five missing youth from Pathribal.
4) October 31, 2000: Justice Pandian committee was asked to investigate Pathribal and Barkpora killings.
5) April 6, 2002: DNA profiling confirms the killed persons were civilians
6) In 2007, the SC stayed high court proceedings on an army plea that it can’t prosecute without permission from the Centre
7) March 2012: CBI told the SC it was a cold-blooded murder and no sanction was required to prosecute the army personnel

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Priyanka Chopra, Adarsh Gourav and Rajkummar Rao in a still from 'The White Tiger'. (SOURCED).
Priyanka Chopra, Adarsh Gourav and Rajkummar Rao in a still from 'The White Tiger'. (SOURCED).

Delhi HC refuses to stay Netflix premiere of ‘The White Tiger’

By Richa banka
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 11:43 PM IST
  • Hours before the release of the movie based on the Booker Prize winning novel of the same name written by Aravind Adiga, the court dismissed an urgent plea to injunct the makers and Netflix from premiering the movie.
Close
Bagchi doesn’t like the terms stray dogs or street dogs. Dogs living within localites are community dogs, he says.
Bagchi doesn’t like the terms stray dogs or street dogs. Dogs living within localites are community dogs, he says.

The community dogs of Dhanbad: pampered, protected, proud

By Shara Ashraf Prayag
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 11:36 PM IST
In the coal capital of India, a group of animal lovers is encouraging people to treat dogs with love and compassion
Close
The Allahabad High Court had granted bail Samajwadi Party MP Azam Khan, his wife Tazeen Fatima and son Abdullah Azam Khan in a case of alleged forgery of Abdullah's birth certificate(HT FILE PHOTO)
The Allahabad High Court had granted bail Samajwadi Party MP Azam Khan, his wife Tazeen Fatima and son Abdullah Azam Khan in a case of alleged forgery of Abdullah's birth certificate(HT FILE PHOTO)

SC upholds bail for Azam Khan, wife and son in forgery case

By Abraham Thomas
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 11:12 PM IST
  • The Supreme Court dismissed the Uttar Pradesh government's appeal as it noted that the order was limited to grant of bail.
Close
Fishermen sitting at a demonstration site during a protest against the killing of four fishermen by the Sri Lankan Navy, in Rameswaram on Thursday (ANI Photo)
Fishermen sitting at a demonstration site during a protest against the killing of four fishermen by the Sri Lankan Navy, in Rameswaram on Thursday (ANI Photo)

India lodges protest after fishermen die in crash with Sri Lankan naval craft

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:50 PM IST
  • India expressed “deep anguish at the loss of lives” and emphasised the need to deal with issues related to fishermen in a humanitarian manner.
Close
The Bengal government also appealed to people through televised advertisements to blow conch shells at 12.15 pm, the time of Bose’s birth in 1897. Both the Centre and the state have decided to organise various programmes till Bose’s 125th birthday next year. (HT FILE PHOTO).
The Bengal government also appealed to people through televised advertisements to blow conch shells at 12.15 pm, the time of Bose’s birth in 1897. Both the Centre and the state have decided to organise various programmes till Bose’s 125th birthday next year. (HT FILE PHOTO).

On eve of PM Modi’s visit, TMC, BJP face-off in Bengal over Netaji’s birthday

PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:45 PM IST
  • Despite the TMC and the Left parties’ demand that January 23 be declared a national holiday and designated after the names they had chosen, the Modi government declared on January 19 that the day will be celebrated as Parakram Diwas.
Close
WhatsApp has assured that they do not expand its ability to share user data with its parent company Facebook and is working to address the "misinformation" that was being spread about its privacy norms.(MINT_PRINT)
WhatsApp has assured that they do not expand its ability to share user data with its parent company Facebook and is working to address the "misinformation" that was being spread about its privacy norms.(MINT_PRINT)

WhatsApp thanks Parliamentary committee after meeting on data privacy

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Nilavro Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:30 PM IST
The committee met the officials of Twitter and Facebook to hear their views on safeguarding citizens’ rights and prevention of misuse of social and online news media platforms.
Close
WhatsApp had earlier this month begun asking its 2 billion users worldwide to accept an update of its privacy policy if they want to keep using the popular messaging app.(HT Photo)
WhatsApp had earlier this month begun asking its 2 billion users worldwide to accept an update of its privacy policy if they want to keep using the popular messaging app.(HT Photo)

Parliamentary panel members concerned over WhatsApp's proposed privacy policy

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:24 PM IST
WhatsApp representatives who appeared before the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology said the proposed changes are aimed at bringing in more transparency and the chat and calls on platform still remain end-to-end encrypted, some of the members said.
Close
A Twitter logo is seen outside the company headquarters in San Francisco, California, US. (Reuters Photo)(REUTERS)
A Twitter logo is seen outside the company headquarters in San Francisco, California, US. (Reuters Photo)(REUTERS)

Twitter to restart giving blue ticks from January 22: All you need to know

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:20 PM IST
In 2017, the micro-blogging platform stopped its verification programme saying it felt arbitrary and confusing to many people.
Close
VK Sasikala was tested positive for Covid-19 on Thursday(PTI FILE PHOTO)
VK Sasikala was tested positive for Covid-19 on Thursday(PTI FILE PHOTO)

Expelled AIADMK leader Sasikala tests positive for Covid-19, shifted to ICU

Written by Prashasti Singh
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:31 PM IST
"She tested positive for Covid-19 but there are no other complications and her oxygen saturation is around 98 per cent," said Dr K Ramesh Krishna, medical superintendent at Victoria Hospital.
Close
Many session sites saw an upswing in the number of vaccinations which boosted the overall percentage.(ANI)
Many session sites saw an upswing in the number of vaccinations which boosted the overall percentage.(ANI)

Vaccination percentage rises in Bihar after govt allows on-the-spot shots

PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:08 PM IST
  • The government has allowed on-the-spot administration of the vaccine from among the beneficiaries already enrolled on the Covid-19 Vaccine Intelligence Network (Co-WIN) portal, if those listed at a vaccination centre for the day did not turn up.
Close
Army chief General Naravane has said the Covid-19 pandemic had exposed the fragility of global supply chains and self-reliance was the only way to insulate the military from such disruptions. (PTI PHOTO).
Army chief General Naravane has said the Covid-19 pandemic had exposed the fragility of global supply chains and self-reliance was the only way to insulate the military from such disruptions. (PTI PHOTO).

Lagging a little in military modernisation compared to adversaries: Army Chief

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sohini Sarkar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 09:58 PM IST
  • General Naravane said dependence on imported military hardware could create vulnerabilities during a crisis, and self-reliance in the defence sector was a “strategic necessity”.
Close
Health workers wait at PMCH ahead of the Covid -19 vaccination drive, in Patna on January 16.(ANI)
Health workers wait at PMCH ahead of the Covid -19 vaccination drive, in Patna on January 16.(ANI)

Names of 800 healthcare workers go missing from Co-WIN portal in Bihar

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 09:38 PM IST
  • The NMCH administration claimed it had sent the list of nearly 800 health care workers and 1,400 hospital staff to Patna civil surgeon last December, but names of those from the in medical college were missing from the Co-Win portal
Close
On Thursday, the Jagannath Temple administration waived off the requirement of a Covid-19 negative report for devotees, but made wearing of masks mandatory for those entering the shrine. (HT FILE PHOTO).(HT File Photo)
On Thursday, the Jagannath Temple administration waived off the requirement of a Covid-19 negative report for devotees, but made wearing of masks mandatory for those entering the shrine. (HT FILE PHOTO).(HT File Photo)

Puri’s Jagannath Temple administrators seek early vaccination for priests, staff

PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 09:24 PM IST
  • Odisha on Thursday exceeded its target of Covid-19 vaccination by inoculating 44,880 frontline health workers against an aim of 37,076 as vaccinators in 20 of the 30 districts managed to surpass the target.
Close
File photo of Rajiv Gandhi(HT Photo )
File photo of Rajiv Gandhi(HT Photo )

Decision on release of Rajiv Gandhi killers in a month, Supreme Court told

By Divya Chandrababu
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 10:44 PM IST
This comes as a significant development just months ahead of Tamil Nadu’s assembly elections slated for April-May.
Close
Jayant Khobragade, an officer of the 1995 batch of the Indian Foreign Service, is currently serving as a joint secretary in the external affairs ministry. (HT FILE PHOTO).
Jayant Khobragade, an officer of the 1995 batch of the Indian Foreign Service, is currently serving as a joint secretary in the external affairs ministry. (HT FILE PHOTO).

Jayant Khobragade named India's next envoy to ASEAN secretariat

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 09:25 PM IST
  • India first posted a dedicated ambassador to ASEAN in 2014 following the elevation of ties between the two sides to a strategic partnership and in view of growing cooperation in areas ranging from security to trade.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP