Bhima-Koregaon case: Knowledge of Maoist ideology not enough grounds to keep us in jail, say activists

HT Image
HT Image
Published on Oct 05, 2019 12:34 AM IST
Copy Link
ByK A Y Dodhiya, Mumbai

The three activists accused in last year’s Bhima-Koregaon violence claimed before the Bombay high court (HC) that merely knowing or professing Marxist, Leninist, Bolshevik or Maoist ideologies could not be the basis for keeping them in jail. The Pune Police concluded its arguments opposing the bail applications of the three accused –Vernon Gonsalves, Arun Ferreira and Sudha Bharadwaj – on Friday.

The police had opposed the bail applications on the ground that the three activists were connected to organisations that were allegedly associated with the banned outfit, CPI (Maoist). However, Gonsalves, Ferreira and Bharadwaj refuting the claims of the police, said that it could not be the grounds for implicating them.

Additional public prosecutor Aruna Pai, while opposing the application of Ferreira, referred to the letter recovered from the laptop of another accused – Rona Wilson – and said that Ferreira was directly involved in building a student and women’s movement and was also entrusted with the responsibility of providing cadre through recruitment for the rural struggle.

Pai further submitted that though the three accused were not involved in any arms deals proof of which was available with regards to other accused, the fact that Gonsalves, Ferreira and Bharadwaj were tasked with inciting people to rebel, was prima facie true and hence should be denied bail.

Senior advocate Mihir Desai, who appeared for Gonsalves, rebutted Pai’s submissions, saying that the proceedings were not to decide on whether following Marxist, Bolshevik, Leninist or Maoist ideology is a crime in India.

He submitted that political outfits such as the CPI (Marxist) are recognised parties, which have even formed the government in some states. He further said that there were many offshoots of the Maoist ideology in the country of which only two were involved in terrorist activities. Gonsalves has not been affiliated to either of them and hence, should be granted bail.

Seeking bail for Ferreira, his counsel Sudeep Pasbola rebutted Pai’s claims that the lecture he delivered in the Committee for Release of Political Prisoners meeting were inflammatory and said that there was no evidence against his client. Pasbola further submitted that the Indian Association of People’s Lawyer (IAPL), with which Ferreira was connected, was neither a banned organisation nor a frontal organisation of the banned CPI (Maoist) group. He said that even if IAPL is allegedly linked with the banned group, it has a limited role, and is not promoting the ultimate goal of violence as propounded by CPI (Maoist). He also said that just because the activists oppose the government’s stand, it does not mean that they be branded as a frontal organisation.

He concluded that his client is a human rights activist and that Ferreira was a classic example of anyone with that role treads on a dangerous path. Elaborating his point further, he said that despite the fact that Ferreira acted within the ambit of the Constitution, he has been incarcerated for a year.

The court will hear Bharadwaj’s rebuttal on Monday, followed by the state’s clarification, and then pass its judgment.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Karnataka chief minister Basavaraj Bommai sent a clear message to officials that he would not tolerate any lapses in the implementation of schemes for SC/ST communities. 

    CM Bommai: won't tolerate lapses in implementation of SC/ST development plan

    The, ST Development Council meeting chaired by Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai approved theSP/ TSP action plan for the year 2022-23 on Friday, after which the CM instructed officials to spend Scheduled Castes Sub Plan grants only for those targeted communities. Bommai also instructed the officials of the State Development Council to spend the grants made for the welfare of SC/ST communities only for these sections on Friday.

  • Bangladeshi national contested 2021 assembly seat for TMC, finds Calcutta HC

    Bangladeshi national contested 2021 assembly seat for TMC, finds Calcutta HC

    Trinamool Congress candidate Alo Rani Sarkar, who unsuccessfully contested the Bongaon South assembly seat in 2021, is a Bangladeshi national, the Calcutta high court said on Friday while passing its order on Sarkar's petition that challenged the poll results. Alo Rani Sarkar filed the petition after the polls results were declared on May 2, 2021.

  • Freshly harvested cherries being packed into boxes at an orchard in Ganderbal’s Kangan. (Waseem Andrabi/Hindustan Times)

    Fruit growers in Kashmir look forward to compensate losses

    The areas which received the heavy hailstorm earlier this month is known for its cherry harvest. “I usually sell 30 to 40 boxes every day to the locals but in coming days, when all varieties will be available in market, my sales will further pick up along with good rates,” he added. Growers say though bulk of stone fruits is dispatched outside the UT, local sales too have a good potential to compensate losses.

  • National Conference vice-president Omar Abdullah addresses a party meeting in Jammu on Friday. (PTI)

    Increased tourists footfall, flights to Kashmir can’t be called normalcy: Omar

    National Conference vice-president Omar Abdullah on Friday said that the Modi government has failed to restore peace in Kashmir and the increased tourist footfall and multiple flights to the Valley cannot be called signs of normalcy. Addressing mediapersons at the party headquarters here, he said, “No one is feeling secure amid targeted killings. The state of fear is such that Pandit employees are ready to quit their jobs and run away from Kashmir.”

  • Kangra SP Khushal Chand Sharma said a departmental action has been initiated against the cops who were accompanying Prince Kapoor, a resident of Jammu and Kashmir. (Image for representational purpose)

    Undertrial escapes Kangra police custody

    An undertrial lodged in Dharamshala district jail on armed robbery charges fled from Kangra police custody while he along with other prisoners being transported back to the prison after being produced in a court in Pathankot of Punjab. The incident took place on Thursday. Kangra SP Khushal Chand Sharma said a departmental action has been initiated against the cops who were accompanying a resident of Jammu and Kashmir, Prince Kapoor.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, May 21, 2022