High court quashes teacher's appointment in Punjabi University

Raising serious questions over the selection criteria of Punjabi University, the Punjab and Haryana high court has quashed the appointment of an assistant professor in physical education department in June 2011 on the grounds of arbitrariness on the part of selection committee.
Punjab-and-Haryana-High-court-HT-Photo
Punjab-and-Haryana-High-court-HT-Photo
Updated on May 20, 2015 08:29 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, Patiala

Raising serious questions over the selection criteria of Punjabi University, the Punjab and Haryana high court has quashed the appointment of an assistant professor in physical education department in June 2011 on the grounds of arbitrariness on the part of selection committee.

Terming the appointment as 'illegal and unjustified', the court has also directed the university management to make a fresh selection after interviewing the shortlisted candidates.

In its May 15 order, the court also pulled up the varsity authorities for not having proper criteria for selection of candidates for academic posts.

In this case, one of the applicants Jaskiran Singh Sidhu had challenged the appointment of Amarpreet Singh as an assistant professor in the physical education department, alleging that his claim to the post was ignored in spite of his merit and higher marks.

According to Sidhu's petition, Amarpreet was appointed to the post even as he had scored 53.47 marks and was ranked 5th on the merit list, against his score of 73.821 marks and his number 1 rank on the merit list.

It was also alleged that the selection committee recommended Amarpreet's appointment on the basis of his interview, notwithstanding the fact that the committee had not laid down any criteria to test the ability of the candidates in the interview.

This is not for the first time that the appointments made by university have been questioned. Previously too, several eligible candidates whose merit was ignored during recruitment have approached court from time to time to
get justice.

Court's observations

In its judgment on May 15, the court stated that the petitioner Jaskiran Singh Sidhu is PhD against the MPhil qualification of Amarpreet Singh.

The court set aside the selection on the ground that the selection committee failed to adopt any criteria for assessing the respective merits of the candidates.

The court added that the petitioner had various publications and research papers to his credit and as a result at the time of short-listing of candidates, he was given 73.81 marks on 100, while Amarpreet was given only 53.47 marks.

"Nothing has been brought on record as to how many marks were awarded to the petitioner and to Amarpreet in the interview, as no criteria was admittedly laid down at the time of personality test," the court said.

It also questioned the fact that if neither grades nor criteria to assess the performance of the candidates were laid down by the interview board, then how were the candidates rated and also how was a candidate with an excellent academic and research
record found to have been weak.

It has also directed the university to make a fresh selection after interviewing all shortlisted candidates after laying down transparent and relevant criteria within two months of the order.

University registrar Devinder Singh said "We are yet to get the court orders. Appropriate action will be taken after we receive the orders."

Criteria laid down by the University Grants Commission

In appointments made by varsities to a teaching post, this is the ratio in which various achievements and skills are granted weights and awarded marks.

30% Based on the Assessment of Domain Knowledge and Teaching Skills

20% Postgraduate qualification

20% Interview performance.

15% Undergraduate qualification

10% Research work and papers published

5% For NET/PhD

Nothing has been brought on record as to how many marks were awarded to the petitioner and to the selected candidate in the interview, as no criteria were admittedly laid down.

HC observation

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Navrajdeep Singh is a senior staff correspondent. He covers agriculture, crime, local bodies, health and education in the Patiala district of Punjab.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The festival was one of the ambitious projects proposed in the Rozgaar Budget 2022-23. (File image)

    Delhi to host India’s biggest shopping festival in 2023: CM Arvind Kejriwal

    Delhi will host its first ever government-backed shopping festival from January 28 to February 26 next year, chief minister Arvind Kejriwal announced on Wednesday. The festival will have 200 concerts for entertainment, food walks and will also offer huge discounts on products. Kejriwal said the festival will boost employment and the city's economy. The chief minister said people will also get a glimpse of Delhi's art and culture in the shopping festival.

  • YSRCP MLA from Nellore, Kotamreddy Sridhar Reddy sitting beside an overflowing drain in Umma Reddy Gunta.

    Andhra Pradesh MLA enters overflowing drain as mark of protest. Watch

    This time, an Andhra Pradesh legislator sat beside an overflowing drain in Nellore with YSR Congress MLA from Nellore Rural constituency, Kotamreddy Sridhar Reddy's legged dipped in it as a mark of protest against the authorities alleging they ignored the repeated request to clean the drain. The legislator also warned that he will come again and sit in the drain in the Umma Reddy Gunta area if the authorities fail to clean it.

  • A screengrab of the viral video. (ANI)

    Eknath Shinde's wife plays drums to welcome the new Maharashtra CM | Watch

    A video of his wife, Lata Shinde, who welcomed back by playing drums playing the drums is going viral on social media. Read Didn't betray, revolted against injustice, Shinde andBJP's Devendra Fadnavis in Maha Assembly On June 30, saysMaharashtra chief minister Eknath Shindee, who was made the deputy CM in the new governmentr – were sworn in. The 'dissident' Shiv Sena faction has as many as 40 MLAs, which means that it can claim to be the 'real' Shiv Sena.

  • As Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has prohibited eateries from automatically or by default levying service charges on food bills, restaurateurs feel this isn’t in the welfare of their staff. (Photo: Sanchit Khanna/HT)

    Staff will suffer, feels restauranteurs; customers happy

    On Monday, the Central Consumer Protection Authority prohibited eateries from automatically or by default levying service charges on food bills. This decision has left restaurateurs feeling anxious as they think this isn't in the welfare of their staff. Prabhat Verma, who runs a food group, DRAG, says he's happy and excited with this change. Another foodie, Priyanka Talreja, says as a customer and frequent visitor to restaurants, it was a much-needed move.

  • Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal (right) with deputy CM Manish Sisodia in the state assembly on Tuesday. (HT Photo)

    ‘Biggest proof of honesty’: Kejriwal, Sisodia hail CAG report on surplus revenue

    A day after the Comptroller and Auditor General of India said in an audit report that Delhi has been recording a revenue surplus since 2015, chief minister Arvind Kejriwal on Wednesday said the numbers are the “biggest proof” of the Aam Aadmi Party's “honesty”. Deputy chief minister Manish Sisodia presented the 2021 CAG report on state finances, for the financial year ending March 2020, in the Delhi assembly on Tuesday.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, July 06, 2022