HT Image
HT Image

Instant Replay: Upon further review, its time has come

I've always been OK with human error. Expecting people to be perfect all the time is a recipe for dissatisfaction and unhappiness your own, not the rest of the world's.
By Tracee Hamilton (Washington Post) | None
UPDATED ON JUN 29, 2010 10:49 AM IST

I've always been OK with human error. Expecting people to be perfect all the time is a recipe for dissatisfaction and unhappiness your own, not the rest of the world's.

Human error has been a part of sports since the first caveman grooved a fastrock past the second caveman, only to hear the third caveman call it a ball. Mistakes are part of the lore and myth of sports, from Fred Merkle's boner to sending Babe Ruth to the Yankees for cash. Sometimes the error is good for your team; sometimes it's not. (Sometimes, it rains.) The idea is that these mistakes should even out over, say, a century or so.

But I've come to feel differently this summer. Jim Joyce's terrible call that ruined Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga's perfect game made me re-think my position. But the dreadful officiating in the 2010 World Cup pushed me over the edge.

We're OK with letting automobiles parallel park themselves, but God forbid we use technology to help an official make the correct call? What's wrong with us?

I may not be a diehard soccer fan, but I can feel the pain of those who are. The ineptness and inconsistency of the World Cup officiating is almost unbelievable. The US team was a victim of several questionable calls, including the goal against Slovenia that was disallowed because ... well, we don't know why. The official never would say. Are you kidding me? At least Joyce admitted his mistake and apologized.

The buzzing over bad calls and non-calls is now threatening to drown out even the vuvuzelas as the knockout round continues. A goal by England on Sunday against Germany was disallowed even though replays clearly showed the ball crossed the goal line. Would that have affected the outcome, given Germany's rout? Perhaps not, but we'll never know, will we?

In Sunday's other game, Argentina was credited for a goal against Mexico despite a clear offside by one of its players. Again, it might not have affected the outcome. But in a low-scoring game such as soccer, every goal is important.

Sports already has plenty of intangibles, from travel to health to officiating. But over the years travel has become easier, and medical advances keep players healthier. Why shouldn't officiating also be allowed to improve?

FIFA, being FIFA, has reacted decisively to calls for change by banning the use of instant replay on stadium scoreboards in South Africa. Apparently, if no one can see them, the calls won't be egregiously bad.

However, mobile live television is available, and it won't take long to spread, which means even if replay is banned in the stadium, every goober in the stands will be able to see every replay the folks at home can see. At home, you can not only see replays as shown by the networks, you can record the games and watch the same play 1,000 times if that's your idea of a good time.

Basically, the only people who can't see the play over and over are the players and the officials. How many times did we see the Galarraga play in the aftermath? It took Joyce one viewing to see his mistake. Galarraga was the victim, of course, but you had to feel for Joyce as well. He can't possibly want to get something that wrong. Don't you think he would welcome a chance to fix it? A decent official doesn't want to get it wrong. (Although after seeing some World Cup games, I'm not sure we're always dealing with decent officials.)

Replay won't solve every problem, of course, and its use needs to be limited, especially in baseball, in which the games already take too long. Maybe a challenge system similar to the NFL's would work. Say you can't challenge balls and strikes; that's a given (for now). But maybe you can challenge plays at the bases, and you get two challenges a game. Jim Leyland would surely have thrown the red hankie after Joyce's call.

Like the NFL, the NHL and NBA have managed to institute instant replay without ruining their respective sports or measurably slowing their games. FIFA, on the other hand, already allows a player to take a dramatic dive, writhe on the field in agony, then lie motionless on a stretcher until he reaches the sideline, when he pops up like a horror movie villain, alive and well again. When you let that slide, it's tough to deny a delay that could help determine "fairly" the winner of a game.

Plays such as dives can't and shouldn't be reviewed, of course. You can't mandate judgment out of an official's job, much as you might like to. But at the very least, FIFA could allow the use of electronic chip technology to determine whether a goal crossed the line. FIFA pleads cost, but every pickup game in the world needn't be wired. Start, at least, with the sport's upper tiers. If marathons can outfit entire fields with electronic chips, surely FIFA could manage a few before the 2014 Cup?

This seems a crazy topic to be debating in 2010. We have allowed technology to improve our lives in myriad ways. We have Roombas and cars that parallel park themselves and electronic nose hair clippers. And we are able to discuss all these improvements, all the time, with all of our electronic communication gadgetry proving that not all electronic advances are necessarily improvements.

All the electronic chips in the world will never eliminate human error. We are what we are: fallible, flawed and often flailing. Most days we need all the help we can get. The first step is admitting it.

In exclusive partnership with The Washington Post. For additional content please visit www. washingtonpost.com

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Mandeep Singh scored a last-minute winner for India. (Hockey India/Twitter)
Mandeep Singh scored a last-minute winner for India. (Hockey India/Twitter)

India beat Great Britain 3-2 to end Europe tour on unbeaten note

PTI, Antwerp
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:49 PM IST
India beat Great Britain 3-2 to end Europe tour on unbeaten note.
Close
File image of David James. (Getty Images)
File image of David James. (Getty Images)

Teams left in Champions League wish they don’t draw Manchester City: David James

By Rajesh Pansare, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:27 PM IST
  • Elaborating on the polarisation aspect, James cited the examples of quality goalkeepers on display in the Champions League knockouts.
Close
File image of Koneru Humpy. (FIDE-Chess)
File image of Koneru Humpy. (FIDE-Chess)

Koneru Humpy bags second BBC Indian Sports Woman Of The Year award

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:21 PM IST
  • Humpy bagged the award after receiving the highest number of votes from the fans.
Close
Sharath Kamal in action. (Getty Images)
Sharath Kamal in action. (Getty Images)

Sathiyan, Sharath and Batra enter WTT second round in Doha

PTI, Doha
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:17 PM IST
  • Achanta Sharath Kamal, Sathiyan Gnanasekaran and Manika Batra started their campaign at the WTT Star Contender Doha on a winning note.
Close
Southampton's Danny Ings receives medical attention(Pool via REUTERS)
Southampton's Danny Ings receives medical attention(Pool via REUTERS)

Saints' Danny Ings out for three weeks with muscle injury

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 07:12 PM IST
Ings went to ground early in the game at Bramall Lane and was replaced by Che Adams as manager Ralph Hasenhuettl was left frustrated by another injury to his influential striker, though the Austrian said the problem was not as bad as suspected.
Close
Novak Djokovic, Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer on stage during the ATP Heritage Celebration.(Getty Images)
Novak Djokovic, Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer on stage during the ATP Heritage Celebration.(Getty Images)

Djokovic asked to pick his greatest rival between Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 06:37 PM IST
Djokovic had only one Grand Slam title at the start of the 2011 season but ended the decade with 17. He is now just two behind Nadal and Federer’s tally.
Close
The Champions League Trophy stands on display during the UEFA Champions League football group stage draw ceremony.(Getty Images)
The Champions League Trophy stands on display during the UEFA Champions League football group stage draw ceremony.(Getty Images)

European clubs target global fans with Champions League plan

AP, Geneva
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 05:14 PM IST
  • A UEFA-led proposal to change its clubs competitions in 2024 — abolishing traditional four-team groups and adding 100 Champions League games in a 36-team format — was being presented to more than 200 European Club Association members.
Close
FILE PHOTO: Rangers manager Steven Gerrard.(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Rangers manager Steven Gerrard.(REUTERS)

Rangers still have work to do, says Gerrard after title win

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 12:18 PM IST
Rangers, with 88 points from 32 matches, sealed their 55th league title after second-placed Celtic were frustrated by Dundee United in a goalless draw.
Close
Indian wrestler Bajrang Punia.(Vipin Kumar/HT PHOTO)
Indian wrestler Bajrang Punia.(Vipin Kumar/HT PHOTO)

Bajrang takes gold and number one rank in Rome, bronze for Kaliramana

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:33 AM IST
Up against Mongolia's Tulga Tumur Ochir, Bajrang was trailing 0-2 till the final moments of the 65kg final but managed to level the scores, 30 seconds from the whistle.
Close
Team LeBron wins NBA All-Star Game 170-150(Twitter)
Team LeBron wins NBA All-Star Game 170-150(Twitter)

Still perfect: Team LeBron wins NBA All-Star Game 170-150

AP, Atlanta
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:33 AM IST
The top vote-getters in each conference have picked the teams for the last four years, a duty that James has earned every season.
Close
FILE PHOTO: Roger Federer(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Roger Federer(REUTERS)

'I was down': Federer had hard time before 2nd knee surgery

AP, Doha, Qatar
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:17 AM IST
The 39-year-old Federer's first match since the 2020 Australian Open will come Wednesday in Doha against Dan Evans or Jeremy Chardy.
Close
Coco Gauff in action.(AP)
Coco Gauff in action.(AP)

Coco Gauff saves 2 match points in 1st-round win at Dubai

AP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:19 AM IST
The 16-year-old American led 5-1 in the third set and twice had chances to serve out the match, holding four match points in the 10th game, but Alexandrova rallied to force a tiebreaker.
Close
Tottenham's Gareth Bale.(Pool via REUTERS)
Tottenham's Gareth Bale.(Pool via REUTERS)

Bale over psychological scars of past injuries: Mourinho

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:17 AM IST
Bale and Harry Kane struck two goals each on Sunday to help Spurs move into sixth spot in the Premier League on 45 points after 27 games, two points adrift of Chelsea in fourth.
Close
Barcelona's Ilaix Moriba celebrates scoring their second goal with Lionel Messi REUTERS/Vincent West(REUTERS)
Barcelona's Ilaix Moriba celebrates scoring their second goal with Lionel Messi REUTERS/Vincent West(REUTERS)

Barca has deficit to overcome to recover in Champions League

AP, Barcelona
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:15 AM IST
Even though PSG defends a big lead at Parc des Princes, there may be some nerves about facing Lionel Messi in top form once again. PSG went out after losing 6-1 in Spain in 2017 having won the home leg 4-0.
Close
FILE - Boxer Muhammad Ali looks up towards Joe Frazier, center, during a title fight at Madison Square Garden in New York, in this March 8, 1971, file photo. (AP Photo/File)(AP)
FILE - Boxer Muhammad Ali looks up towards Joe Frazier, center, during a title fight at Madison Square Garden in New York, in this March 8, 1971, file photo. (AP Photo/File)(AP)

Fifty years of the Fight: How Ali Vs Frazier changed boxing

By Somshuvra Laha, Kolkata
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:16 AM IST
The first of heavyweight boxing’s greatest trilogy, The Fight not only set up a bitter rivalry with Frazier that spanned five years and two continents but also made the world Ali’s audience, allowing him to create a unique social and political ideology that got him exiled in the first place.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP