Manish Pandey plays a shot for Karnataka in a Ranji match against MP in Indore in this file photo.(Shankar Mourya/ HT photo)
Manish Pandey plays a shot for Karnataka in a Ranji match against MP in Indore in this file photo.(Shankar Mourya/ HT photo)

Why was talent like Manish Pandey almost lost to Indian cricket?

India needs to find proper ways to dismantle a culture that unwittingly promotes a ‘clique’ to control the selection process.
By Pradeep Magazine | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON JAN 26, 2016 01:35 AM IST

Manish Pandey’s shadow has for long been hovering over Indian cricket. He was the first Indian to score a century in the IPL. That he had talent and intent to succeed was never in doubt. His breathtaking catch on the boundary line in the Ranji Trophy final is remembered for helping Karnataka win the championship. He was a prodigy who, due to the mysterious ways of selectors, was almost lost to the world of cricket. Well, almost, had Ajinkye Rahane’s injury not forced Dhoni-Shastri to include him in the Sydney one-dayer.

While watching him play an innings of intense focus and purpose, which showed his unflappable temperament in an extremely adverse situation, one was left wondering why this man was never given a proper look-in. The Sydney innings was his third, in the four matches he has played so far. He played one against Zimbabwe, scored a half century, was shown the door, and after a couple of years’ gap recalled, played in the first two games in Australia, and then dropped again.

Whimsical approach

Given the whimsical ways in which India treats some of its players, Pandey’s international career was as good as over had fate not intervened, forcing his re-induction into the team.

Skipper Dhoni’s explanation at the post-match press conference that it is for the selectors to pick a team as they are the ones who watch domestic cricket and that he has “no clue” who is good or bad seems a bizarre justification for having ignored Pandey for so long.

Pradeep Magazine’s column: Indian bowling good for nothing, can’t defend any total

As an India captain, even if he is not playing domestic cricket much, it is his job to be in touch with ground reality and get the feedback on who is good and who is not. And even if one were to accept his justification, it does implicate the selectors for shirking their responsibility.

Power games

I want to go beyond the question of accountability from selectors and raise a bigger question here. Why is it that the balance of power in the Indian Board decides players from which zone get preference to play for the country? When N Srinivasan was at the helm, suddenly more players from the south found their way into the India team. Now that the power has shifted to the north, we suddenly find more players from that zone being credited with greater talent. Is our selection policy hostage to the power structure in the board?

Follow Pradeep Magazine’s column on the state of Indian cricket

Another question of equal significance to be raised is, do the various conflicts of interest of players, coaches and their agents too limit selection to a chosen few, no matter how talented they may or may not be?

Manish Pandey has had a few brushes with the establishment in the past and may have suffered for not belonging to a “favoured class”. India needs to seriously confront the question why a talent like Pandey was almost lost to Indian cricket. It needs to find proper ways to dismantle a culture that unwittingly promotes a “clique” to control the selection process.

(The views expressed are personal. The author tweets as @pradeepmagazine.)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
File photo of Karni Singh Shooting range(HT Photo)
File photo of Karni Singh Shooting range(HT Photo)

Seven days quarantine for Delhi World Cup-bound UK shooters

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 09:19 PM IST
A source close to the National Rifle Association of India (NRAI) said that the federation has got a positive feedback from the concerned authorities after it had requested for seven days hard quarantine for the shooters from UK.
Close
PKL generic image(ANI)
PKL generic image(ANI)

Mashal Sports issues ITT to auction Pro Kabaddi League media rights

ANI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 08:53 PM IST
  • Sports management company Mashal Sports will conduct an open market media rights auction for five Pro Kabaddi League seasons to be held during 2021 - 2025.
Close
John Stones scores his fourth goal in all competitions, more than any other defender. (Man City/Twitter)
John Stones scores his fourth goal in all competitions, more than any other defender. (Man City/Twitter)

Man City win 20th straight game to lead EPL by 13 points

AP, Manchester, England
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 08:33 PM IST
  • City produced one of their sloppiest displays in recent months but emerged with its winning run intact.
Close
File image of Bukayo Saka. (Getty Images)
File image of Bukayo Saka. (Getty Images)

In Arsenal's usual story of struggle, a teenager provides some hope

By Bhargab Sarmah, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 04:29 PM IST
  • There have been a few positives to savour for the Arsenal fans, not least in the form of English teenager Bukayo Saka.
Close
Poland's Iga Swiatek in action.(REUTERS)
Poland's Iga Swiatek in action.(REUTERS)

French Open winner Swiatek beats Bencic in Adelaide final

AP, Adelaide
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 03:39 PM IST
The 19-year-old Polish player did not drop a set in five matches and lost just 22 games all week.
Close
Aditi Ashok in action(Getty Images)
Aditi Ashok in action(Getty Images)

Aditi ensures weekend action at Gainbridge LPGA

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:52 PM IST
With rounds of 74 and 71, Aditi is now T-57 as Lydia Ko, playing at her home course club, Lake Nona Golf & Country Club continued to lead, reaching 10-under after 36 holes.
Close
Photo of Indian men's hockey team goalkeeper PR Sreejesh(The Hockey India/Twitter)
Photo of Indian men's hockey team goalkeeper PR Sreejesh(The Hockey India/Twitter)

Matches against quality teams great opportunity to test ourselves: Sreejesh

PTI, Krefeld
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 01:28 PM IST
After a year-long hiatus due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Indian men's team, ranked No. 4 in the world, will play against world No. 6 Germany in the first of their 4-match tour of Europe starting on Sunday.
Close
FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - Premier League - Everton v Manchester City - Goodison Park, Liverpool, Britain - February 17, 2021 Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola before the match Pool via REUTERS/Michael Regan(Pool via REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - Premier League - Everton v Manchester City - Goodison Park, Liverpool, Britain - February 17, 2021 Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola before the match Pool via REUTERS/Michael Regan(Pool via REUTERS)

City's Guardiola is the Heston Blumenthal of football says Moyes

Reuters, London'
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 10:13 AM IST
British celebrity chef Blumenthal is well known for his creative concoctions, which include unusual culinary delights like snail porridge and bacon and egg flavoured ice cream.
Close
Mairaj Ahmad Khan (IND) of India competes as Luigi Lodde (ITA) of Italy watches. Khan failed to qualify for the skeet final. ((REUTERS))
Mairaj Ahmad Khan (IND) of India competes as Luigi Lodde (ITA) of Italy watches. Khan failed to qualify for the skeet final. ((REUTERS))

Indian men's skeet team wins bronze in ISSF World Cup

PTI, Cairo
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 09:26 AM IST
The Indians beat the Kazakhstan team of David Pochivalov, Eduard Yechshenko and Alexandr Mukhamediyev 6-2 in the bronze medal match on the third competition day of the International Shooting Sport Federation tournament.
Close
FILE PHOTO: Tiger Woods.(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Tiger Woods.(REUTERS)

Tiger Woods in recovery after additional 'procedures'

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 08:18 AM IST
Woods' Twitter account posted Friday evening, "Tiger has moved to Cedars-Sinai Medical Center and received follow-up procedures on his injuries this morning. The procedures were successful, and he is now recovering and in good spirits.
Close
Tiger Woods, of the United States, plays his shot from the fourth tee during the second round of the US Open Golf Championship.(AP File Photo )
Tiger Woods, of the United States, plays his shot from the fourth tee during the second round of the US Open Golf Championship.(AP File Photo )

Tiger Woods recovering, in 'good spirits' after follow-up procedures

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 07:37 AM IST
Tiger Woods was being treated at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles following the crash on Tuesday, which left him with a fractured right leg and shattered ankle.
Close
Arsenal's Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang(Pool via REUTERS)
Arsenal's Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang(Pool via REUTERS)

Aubameyang getting close to his best for Arsenal says Arteta

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 10:54 PM IST
The 31-year-old Aubameyang scored twice, including a late winner, as Arsenal beat Benfica 3-2 on Thursday and 4-3 on aggregate to reach the last 16 of the Europa League.
Close
Sevilla sporting director Monchi(La Liga)
Sevilla sporting director Monchi(La Liga)

We have got a very good structure of scouting and data at Sevilla: Monchi

PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 10:39 PM IST
Engineers, mathematicians and statisticians contribute to choosing players, says one of football’s best sporting directors
Close
NorthEast United FC defeat Kerala Blasters 2-0(Twitter)
NorthEast United FC defeat Kerala Blasters 2-0(Twitter)

NorthEast United qualify for playoffs with best-ever league finish

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 10:24 PM IST
Needing just a point to qualify for their second-ever playoffs, the Highlanders showed no signs of stopping as they attacked from the first whistle.
Close
File photo of Neymar(REUTERS)
File photo of Neymar(REUTERS)

Neymar injury return on schedule, says PSG boss Pochettino

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON FEB 26, 2021 10:00 PM IST
The Brazil international has been sidelined since limping off the pitch on Feb. 10 in a French Cup game against Caen, which ruled him out of PSG's Champions League last-16 first leg against Barcelona.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP