Monmouth County Judge James Troiano said in his opinion that the Eagle Scout charged with assaulting a 16-year-old girl at a pajama party had good test scores and was on track to attend a top college.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Monmouth County Judge James Troiano said in his opinion that the Eagle Scout charged with assaulting a 16-year-old girl at a pajama party had good test scores and was on track to attend a top college.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

‘From good family, candidate for good college’: US Judge defends teen accused of rape

Another judge asked whether a 12-year-old girl’s loss of virginity constituted serious harm.
By Associated Press | Associated Press
PUBLISHED ON JUL 04, 2019 08:35 AM IST

Two New Jersey judges have come under fire for their handling of rape cases, one for asking whether a 16-year-old Eagle Scout “from a good family” should face serious consequences over a video-recorded assault on an intoxicated teenager.

Another judge asked whether a 12-year-old girl’s loss of virginity constituted serious harm.

The comments, which follow other cases of perceived leniency toward sex offenders from privileged backgrounds, led victim advocates to question whether judges are sufficiently qualified and trained to handle sex assault cases in the #MeToo era.

“Survivors’ worst fears are coming to life. They’re fearful of victim blaming or having the crimes committed against them be minimized,” said Patricia Teffenhart, executive director of the New Jersey Coalition Against Sexual Assault.

Monmouth County Judge James Troiano said in his opinion that the Eagle Scout charged with assaulting a 16-year-old girl at a pajama party had good test scores and was on track to attend a top college.

According to an appeals court decision last month, the teenager sent friends a video of him having sexual intercourse with the girl, along with a text, saying: “(w)hen your first time having sex was rape.”

Troiano called the encounter different from “the traditional case of rape,” where “two or more males” attack someone at gunpoint. And he attributed the text to “a 16-year-old kid saying stupid crap to his friends.”

The judge wrote that the “young man comes from a good family who put him into an excellent school where he was doing extremely well. ... He is clearly a candidate for not just college but probably for a good college. His scores for college entry were very high.”

Lawyer Debra Katz said Troiano was redefining the legal standard for rape and should be removed from the bench.

Troiano, a retired judge who serves part time, did not return calls seeking comment made to his home Wednesday by The Associated Press. A message left with a court spokesman was not returned.

Troiano has drawn comparisons to Aaron Persky, the California judge who presided over a notorious rape case against a Stanford University student and who lost his job in a recall election last year. Persky had sentenced swimmer Brock Turner to six months in jail for sexually assaulting an unconscious woman near a dumpster. Turner ended up serving just three months.

“I think that what we saw clearly with Judge Persky last year is that people who come from privilege are given a pass in very serious cases of rape,” said Katz, who represented Christine Blasey Ford in her Senate testimony against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh. “What’s so remarkable in this case is ... it was a clear admission, and of course there was a videotape.”

In the other recent New Jersey case, Middlesex County Judge Marcia Silva said the alleged sexual assault of a 12-year-old girl by a 16-year-old was “not an especially heinous or cruel offense.”

According to an appeals court ruling , the judge wrote that the victim said the 16-year-old pushed her, grabbed her hands, removed her clothing and penetrated her without consent, causing her to lose her virginity. The judge continued: “However, beyond losing her virginity, the State did not claim that the victim suffered any further injuries, either physical, mental or emotional.”

Silva did not return a message left with her office Wednesday. In both cases, the judges ordered the boys tried in juvenile court, before the appeals court sent them back for reconsideration.

Teresa Younger, the president and chief executive officer of the Ms. Foundation, said cases like these show the deference often shown to defendants over victims — even when the judge, like Silva, is female.

“There’s no comment about whether she came from a good family,” Younger said of the pajama party victim. “(And) she may not get great grades because she’s carrying this trauma in her body.”

According to Teffenhart, there’s no mandatory training for New Jersey judges on sex assault cases, despite changing laws, including one this year that gave victims more time to sue.

The judges’ comments, she said, retraumatize victims and “tend to have a chilling effect on all survivors contemplating coming forward.”

Marsha Levick, co-founder of the Juvenile Law Center, called Troiano’s comments “ignorant and sexist and appalling,” but she does not necessarily think the case belongs in adult court.

She believes that rape and other serious cases can be fairly adjudicated in juvenile court if judges are properly trained. In most states, juvenile offenders can be detained or supervised until age 21, while they might face much longer terms for sexual assault in adult court.

“This case may also underscore how important it is to have judges serve in juvenile court (who are) well trained in aspects of adolescent development, and the many ways we can hold young people accountable for their crimes,” she said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
China’s leadership is worried about US sanctions cutting off access to core technologies, and wants to make the economy more dependent on innovation as traditional growth engines like urbanization are slowing.(REUTERS)
China’s leadership is worried about US sanctions cutting off access to core technologies, and wants to make the economy more dependent on innovation as traditional growth engines like urbanization are slowing.(REUTERS)

China lays out ambitious five-year targets at National People's Congress

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 09:11 AM IST
A top priority is increasing spending on research and development, which covers basic scientific research and spending by companies on the development of new products.
Close
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo speaks at the Covid-19 vaccination site at Jacob K. Javits Convention Center in New York City, US March 8, 2021.(REUTERS)
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo speaks at the Covid-19 vaccination site at Jacob K. Javits Convention Center in New York City, US March 8, 2021.(REUTERS)

Lawyers probing Cuomo have dealt political figures in high profile cases

AP, New York
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 09:07 AM IST
The allegations include asking questions about the women's love lives and discussing his own, making inappropriate comments about their appearance and, in some cases, subjecting them to unwanted kisses or too-intimate hugs.
Close
People wearing protective face masks are seen inside a movie theater, as cinemas in Argentina reopen amid an easing of new coronavirus disease (Covid-19) infections, in Buenos Aires, Argentina March 3, 2021. (Reuters)
People wearing protective face masks are seen inside a movie theater, as cinemas in Argentina reopen amid an easing of new coronavirus disease (Covid-19) infections, in Buenos Aires, Argentina March 3, 2021. (Reuters)

Fully vaccinated people can gather without masks, CDC says

AP, New York
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 06:12 AM IST
“With more and more people vaccinated each day, we are starting to turn a corner,” said CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky.
Close
Vice President Kamala Harris speaks as President Joe Biden listens during an event to mark International Women's Day, Monday, March 8, 2021, in the East Room of the White House in Washington. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)(AP)
Vice President Kamala Harris speaks as President Joe Biden listens during an event to mark International Women's Day, Monday, March 8, 2021, in the East Room of the White House in Washington. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)(AP)

Kamala Harris to make UN debut as US VP at gender equality meeting

Reuters, New York
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:56 AM IST
Harris will speak at the virtual 65th Commission on the Status of Women on March 16.
Close
Tear gas and fire extinguisher gas float around demonstrators during a protest against the military coup in Naypyitaw, Myanmar.(REUTERS)
Tear gas and fire extinguisher gas float around demonstrators during a protest against the military coup in Naypyitaw, Myanmar.(REUTERS)

Myanmar protesters defy curfew; media outlets ordered shut

AP, Yangon
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:53 AM IST
The night's street protests began after police cordoned off part of Yangon’s Sanchaung neighborhood and were believed to be conducting door-to-door searches for those who fled attacks by security forces to seek shelter in the homes of sympathetic strangers.
Close
Joe Prude, right, brother of Daniel Prude, and Daniel's nephew Armin, stand with a picture of Daniel Prude in Rochester, NY. (AP)
Joe Prude, right, brother of Daniel Prude, and Daniel's nephew Armin, stand with a picture of Daniel Prude in Rochester, NY. (AP)

Wrongful death suit filed on behalf of Daniel Prude's kids

Posted by Shivani | AP, Rochester
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:40 AM IST
  • The family claims in the lawsuit in US District Court that both the actions of the Rochester police and an “attempted cover-up” by the department and city government violated Prude's constitutional rights, attorneys for the family said.
Close
The draft “Afghanistan Peace Agreement” is the second key document related to the Biden administration’s efforts to push the peace process in Afghanistan that has leaked in recent days Bloomberg(Bloomberg)
The draft “Afghanistan Peace Agreement” is the second key document related to the Biden administration’s efforts to push the peace process in Afghanistan that has leaked in recent days Bloomberg(Bloomberg)

In draft deal for Afghan peace, US wants Taliban in interim govt

By Rezaul H Laskar, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:30 AM IST
  • The US proposal states that a “transitional peace government of Afghanistan” will be formed once the peace agreement is signed
Close
Harry and Meghan, known as the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, announced they were quitting royal duties last year. REUTERS(VIA REUTERS)
Harry and Meghan, known as the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, announced they were quitting royal duties last year. REUTERS(VIA REUTERS)

Suicide to racism: Harry, Meghan on royal mess

By Yashwant Raj, Washington
PUBLISHED ON MAR 09, 2021 05:16 AM IST
  • In a two-hour tell-all interview by Oprah Winfrey, the legendary talk show host, the former royal couple painted a deeply unflattering picture of life inside the royal household.
Close
Sahouri was among more than 125 reporters detained or arrested during the civil unrest that unfolded across the U.S. in 2020.(via AP)
Sahouri was among more than 125 reporters detained or arrested during the civil unrest that unfolded across the U.S. in 2020.(via AP)

US journalist arrested while covering protest goes on trial

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | AP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:05 PM IST
Des Moines Register news reporter Andrea Sahouri, who was pepper-sprayed and jailed while reporting on a clash between protesters and police in May, is charged with failure to disperse and interference with official acts.
Close
Britain is leading Europe with its vaccination program and aims to offer a jab to all adults by the end of July.(AP)
Britain is leading Europe with its vaccination program and aims to offer a jab to all adults by the end of July.(AP)

UK Covid-19 deaths continue to fall as over one-third population inoculated

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:00 PM IST
Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced the milestone at a news conference on Monday, the same day the government took its first major step in easing lockdown restrictions by re-opening schools.
Close
Weekly infection numbers rose by a third to more than 123,000 cases between February 24 and March 2, according to the GIMBE health think tank, the highest since early December.(via Reuters)
Weekly infection numbers rose by a third to more than 123,000 cases between February 24 and March 2, according to the GIMBE health think tank, the highest since early December.(via Reuters)

Italy's Covid-19 death toll tops 100,000

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | AFP
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:00 PM IST
Just over a year since it became the first European country to be overwhelmed by Covid-19, Italy's health ministry recorded another 318 virus-related deaths, taking the total to 100,103.
Close
US President Joe Biden (FILE PHOTO)
US President Joe Biden (FILE PHOTO)

On Women's Day, Joe Biden creates gender policy council within White House

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:59 PM IST
US President Joe Biden created the policy council as part of two executive orders he signed on Monday to mark International Women’s Day.
Close
An Air Force member closes her eyes while getting a shot of Pfizer's vaccine for COVID-19 at a military base in Lima, Peru, Monday, March 8, 2021. (AP Photo/Martin Mejia)(AP)
An Air Force member closes her eyes while getting a shot of Pfizer's vaccine for COVID-19 at a military base in Lima, Peru, Monday, March 8, 2021. (AP Photo/Martin Mejia)(AP)

Vaccinated people can visit each other mask free, says CDC

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 10:44 PM IST
The agency issued its long-awaited guidance for what fully vaccinated people can safely do, as inoculations rise but as health experts warn that the risk of the virus remains, especially with new variants.
Close
A screengrab from a video clip shared by the Chinese foreign ministry and tweeted by CGTN, which shows spokespersons using the “fist and palm” salute to extend greetings ahead of the Chinese New Year in February 2021. (SCREENGRAB/ TWITTER)
A screengrab from a video clip shared by the Chinese foreign ministry and tweeted by CGTN, which shows spokespersons using the “fist and palm” salute to extend greetings ahead of the Chinese New Year in February 2021. (SCREENGRAB/ TWITTER)

Adviser urges China govt to use ‘fist and palm’ salute in times of pandemic

By Sutirtho Patranobis
UPDATED ON MAR 08, 2021 11:55 PM IST
Han Fangming, vice chairperson of the foreign affairs committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, argued that the traditional greeting fits the changing lifestyles
Close
Canada's Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau.(File Photo / REUTERS)
Canada's Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau.(File Photo / REUTERS)

Trudeau names task force on women in the economy ahead of Budget

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON MAR 08, 2021 09:58 PM IST
Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland and Minister of Middle Class Prosperity Mona Fortier said Monday the group will harness expert voices across the country to help the government with a plan to address gender equality issues laid bare by the Covid-19 pandemic.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP