White House to defy impeachment probe, Democratic leaders allege obstruction of Congress

In an escalating standoff triggered by what has been called a declaration of war by the White House, the Democrats hit back saying its defiance could amount to obstruction of congress, another charge in the articles of impeachment being considered against President Donald Trump.
The Capitol in Washington is seen at dawn.(AP)
The Capitol in Washington is seen at dawn.(AP)
Updated on Oct 10, 2019 06:34 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Washington | ByYashwant Raj

The White House on Tuesday told Congressional Democratic leaders it would not cooperate with their impeachment inquiry of the president as it was “unfair”, “unprecedented” and “unconstitutional”.

In an escalating standoff triggered by what has been called a declaration of war by the White House, the Democrats hit back saying its defiance could amount to obstruction of Congress, another charge in the articles of impeachment being considered against President Donald Trump.

The White House spelt out its defiance in a scathing eight-page letter from Pat A Cipollone, counsel to the president, to Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Adam Schiff and Jerry Nadler chairmen of the House intelligence and judiciary committees that are leading the impeachment inquiry triggered in late September by a whistleblower’s complaint into President Trump’s attempts to force Ukraine to probe his political rivals.

“You have designed and implemented your inquiry in a manner that violates fundamental fairness and constitutionally mandated due process,” Cipollone wrote. “President Trump cannot permit his administration to participate in this partisan inquiry under these circumstances.”

President Trump followed up Wednesday in a stream of tweets in which he described the inquiry as a “scam by do-nothing Democrats” and called for ending it for “the good of the country”.

Speaker Pelosi responded with an equally combative statement. “The White House should be warned that continued efforts to hide the truth of the President’s abuse of power from the American people will be regarded as further evidence of obstruction,” she said, adding, “Mr. President, you are not above the law. You will be held accountable.”

White House counsel has argued citing precedence and history but not law, the House of Representatives should have taken a vote beforehand to authorize the probe as was done in the previous two instances of impeachment proceedings, against Presidents Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton.

There has been no vote indeed on the impeachment inquiry, which was simply announced at a news conference by the speaker last month. But experts have said the US constitution is largely silent on the impeachment process, and only says the House must vote to pass the article of impeachment, affirming the charges. The trial to convict and impeach the president or acquit him takes place in the senate. Nixon had resigned during the impeachment inquiry process and Clinton was acquitted by the senate, after the House had voted to impeach him.

Cipollone’s second key objection to the impeachment inquiry was that the president had been denied due process of cross-examining witnesses and examining evidence being presented against him. “No citizen-including the President-should be treated this unfairly,” he wrote.

The White House counsel has also demanded, citing precedence, “co-equal” powers for the Republicans on the committee leading the impeachment inquiry to issue subpoenas, the lack of which, he contended showed the “current proceedings are nothing more than an unconstitutional exercise in political theater”.

But the White House did not commit to extending cooperation if the Democrats did in fact met its demands. “I don’t want to try to predict now because we’ll have to see how it develops,” a senior administration official told reporters when asked on a background briefing call Tuesday.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Representational image.

    Instagram down for thousands of users: Downdetector

    Meta Platforms Inc's image-sharing platform Instagram was down for thousands of users on Thursday, according to outage-tracking website Downdetector.com. More than 6,000 users reported issues with Instagram on Downdetector, which tracks outages by collating status reports from several sources including user-submitted errors on its platform. The outage may be affecting a larger number of users. Meta did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment.

  • Peru's National Seismological Center said the quake had a magnitude of 6.9 and a depth of 240 kilometres.

    Powerful 7.2-magnitude quake rocks southern Peru

    A strong 7.2-magnitude earthquake rocked southeastern Peru on Thursday, the US Geological Survey said, with Peruvian authorities adding there were no dead or injured. The quake hit at 7:02 am local time (1202 GMT), at a depth of 218 kilometers (135 miles), according to the USGS, sending people fleeing into the streets. Peru's National Seismological Center said the quake had a magnitude of 6.9 and a depth of 240 kilometers.

  • Representative Image

    Facebook to roll out updated privacy policy from July 26

    Social media platform Meta, formerly Facebook, has started sending out notification to users about privacy policy update which it will roll out from July 26, the company said on Thursday. Meta in its post said that it has rewritten and re-designed its privacy policy to make it easier to understand and clearer about how it uses users' information.

  • The costume is estimated to have costed more than <span class='webrupee'>₹</span> 12 lakh.

    Man in Japan spends 12 lakh to look like a dog, pictures go viral

    In a bizarre incident, a man from Japan has fulfilled his lifelong dream to look alike a dog by spending a whopping amount of 12 lakh. The man didn't go for any medical procedure but commissioned a life-sized dog costume from a professional agency called Zeppet to look like a collie - dog breed. Japanese news portal news.mynavi reported that Zeppet is known for making sculptures for advertisements, movies, and amusement parks.

  • Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi speaks during a press conference in Honiara on May 26, 2022. - China has "no intention at all" to build a military base in Solomon Islands, Foreign Minister Wang Yi said on May 26, following speculation about the purpose of a recent security pact with Honiara. (Photo by AFP)

    What China said to concerns it is building a military base in the South Pacific

    China has 'no intention' of building a military base in the Solomon Islands, foreign minister Wang Yi said Thursday, dismissing speculation over the purpose of a recent security pact with the Pacific island state. The Chinese minister made the remark after he landed in Solomon Islands capital Honiara to start an eight-nation tour that has raised concerns about Beijing's rapidly expanding military and economic ambitions in the in the South Pacific region.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 26, 2022