Adelaide:Australia's Pat Cummins, left, throws the ball in celebration after he caught and bowled India's Jasprit Bumrah, right, on the third day of their cricket test match at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide, Australia, Saturday, Dec. 19, 2020. AP/PTI Photo(AP19-12-2020_000006B)(AP)
Adelaide:Australia's Pat Cummins, left, throws the ball in celebration after he caught and bowled India's Jasprit Bumrah, right, on the third day of their cricket test match at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide, Australia, Saturday, Dec. 19, 2020. AP/PTI Photo(AP19-12-2020_000006B)(AP)

India have been incompetent playing swing bowling of late

Like most other countries, India too have an issue when the ball swings. But with all that’s going for Indian cricket in terms of wealth/finance, fan following and years at the highest level, more is expected, writes Sanjay Manjrekar.
By Sanjay Manjrekar
UPDATED ON DEC 20, 2020 07:34 AM IST

When India were 19 for 6, I didn’t have to look at our statistician in the commentary box; the number 42 has been entrenched in my mind since I was a kid. The new number is 36—India’s lowest Test score.

India have lost to Australia before, by big margins too, and even on the third day; but it’s the 36 that makes this defeat unique and the moment, albeit not celebratory, historic. It is India’s worst batting performance in their 88 years of Test cricket.

It’s important to not look at 36 in isolation but at 165, 191,242,124, 244, and then at it. These are team totals in their last three Tests (two in New Zealand) when the ball moved. This is all India could muster, and they lost all three. So, 36 as a low score may be an aberration, but of late India have been incompetent as a batting unit when the ball has swung or seamed.

Also read: No one could make any sense of it - Virat Kohli on loss

Like most other countries, India too have an issue when the ball swings. But with all that’s going for Indian cricket in terms of wealth/finance, fan following and years at the highest level, more is expected. India need to set a benchmark for excellence in all formats, like West Indies and Australia did in the past.

So, what happened on the third day afternoon in Adelaide?

First, the ball was hard and new and the pitch had quickened considerably. It wasn’t sluggish like it was on Day 1 when India batted first. To make matters worse, the matty texture of the pitch allowed the ball released from a high point to do just a little bit after it pitched, that is bounce a little more and move sideways a wee bit.

This was exploited to perfection by a quality seam attack led by Hazelwood, who amongst the three seamers had the highest release point. That’s all it takes to bring down famous batting line-ups.

Shaw was gone the day before, carrying bad form into both innings. His issue for now is his high back lift. The bat seems to be coming down late on the ball; however quick any one is bowling, when batting at the highest level the bat must be down and ready to meet the ball.

This is not happening with Shaw; also sometimes with Mayank Agarwal, who did not seem to have this problem the last time when he debuted in Australia. His back lift may have got slightly higher this time.

They need not fret though. Many a successful Test batsmen have had high back lifts. Shaw’s is exactly like Lara’s. Both openers need to work on their timing, not of hitting the ball but bringing their bats down before the ball arrives.

Pujara got a good one from Cummins; he had to play at it so you have to feel for him. His defence was looking as good as I have seen from him.

Also read: ‘Never good to see’: Gavaskar reacts to India’s lowest Test total

As for Virat, he is aware he has to be extremely careful when the line is wide of off-stump, and he was in the first innings when he kept leaving those balls. But in the second, he got sucked into playing that shot. I would call that a lapse of concentration and drop in restrain.

Cummins bowls from a wide angle, so for Virat who loves to get on the front foot the ball seems a lot closer to the stumps than it actually is. Cummins’ wide angle release must be why Virat has got out to Cummins 4 times in 5 Tests.

Rahane has become an interesting case in Indian cricket. When people see him bat in IPL they wonder about his form, but I have maintained that you can’t think of dropping Rahane because his recent Test record is good. At the same breath I have also said that post-2017 Rahane has never looked like the batsman we all loved.

He looks muddled in the mind more than anything else. The way he got out in the first innings missing a full length ball by a mile after being set was one of the many indications he has given to me of his state of mind in the last three years.

Rahane has played 66 Tests and can’t be a player at this age of his career who scores just enough to keep his place. The second innings was a perfect time for Rahane to show his worth, on his third tour of Australia, by playing a heroic innings like Virat does often and he used to pre-2017.

Also, his failure in the first Test is a lesson for those who look too much into warm-up games to gauge form and confidence.

India’s No.6 Hanuma Vihari is a batsman with limited ability but with a promising defensive game. May be India could use that ability by batting him higher.

India is not the only team to have been in such a situation in recent times. It just proves that one is only a product of the environment. Not just in Tests, the quality of defensive batting has gone down drastically, the fallout of a cricket landscape with three formats.

Considering the rewards they get from playing Tests (the toughest format to master) and the sheer number of T20s and ODIs in a year, how much time are batsmen devoting to master Test batting nuances like playing with a dead bat close to the body, watching the ball till the last fraction of a second or letting balls go outside off?

In the 1980s growing up that was the main focus of our batting practice. Now that the general needs are different, practice is different. It’s all about hitting a million balls with power now, not leaving them.

Will defensive batting get better or the ability to cope with the moving ball get better? I doubt it.

Why? Well, what’s the incentive?

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match against England in Ahmedabad(BCCI/Twitter)
Axar Patel celebrates the dismissal during day one of the 3rd Test Match against England in Ahmedabad(BCCI/Twitter)

Axar sizzles with six on home turf as India take early command

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 11:28 PM IST
India vs England: Patel and Ashwin set up the batsmen over after over with turn and variations. India ended the day on 99/3, trailing by 13 runs.
Close
File image of Mohammad Hafeez.(Getty Images)
File image of Mohammad Hafeez.(Getty Images)

Mohammad Hafeez declines PCB central contract offer

AP
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 11:10 PM IST
The allrounder “politely turned down” a contract offer in category C for 2020-21, the cricket board said Wednesday.
Close
Ben Stokes' attempted catch of Shubman Gill on Day 1 of third Test against India in Ahmedabad(Twitter/Screengrab)
Ben Stokes' attempted catch of Shubman Gill on Day 1 of third Test against India in Ahmedabad(Twitter/Screengrab)

Ben Stokes dropped catch brings soft signal rule in focus

By Rasesh Mandani
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:58 PM IST
  • The TV umpire overruled the “Out” soft signal (on-field umpires’ own call before technology adjudicates) and the incident renewed the debate whether soft signal can be an informed decision with very limited reaction time for the umpires on ground.
Close
Left-arm off-spinner Axar Patel snaps six wickets to help India bundle England for 112 on day 1 of the third India vs England Test in Ahmedabad.(BCCI)
Left-arm off-spinner Axar Patel snaps six wickets to help India bundle England for 112 on day 1 of the third India vs England Test in Ahmedabad.(BCCI)

India vs England, 3rd Test, Day 1: Action through images

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:17 PM IST
India were 99 for three in reply to England's 112 all out on the opening day of the day-night third Test here on Wednesday.
Close
Ben Stokes caught applying saliva during India vs England 3rd Test
Ben Stokes caught applying saliva during India vs England 3rd Test

Ben Stokes caught applying saliva on the ball, umpires have a word

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 09:50 PM IST
In what appeared to be an honest mistake, Stokes took the ball from Stuart Broad at the end of the 12th over in India's first innings and applied saliva to shine the ball, that too in front of on-field umpire Nitin Menon.
Close
Ben Stokes was trolled on Twitter for claiming Shubman Gil's catch
Ben Stokes was trolled on Twitter for claiming Shubman Gil's catch

Twitter comes down heavily on Ben Stokes for claiming Shubman Gill's catch

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 08:39 PM IST
Shubman Gill was adjudged not out which left bemused Ben Stokes, who started shaking his head with a smirk on his face. Stokes’ reaction despite the correct decision did not go down well the fans as they took to Twitter to vent out their anger.
Close
Stuart Broad and Joe Root have an argument with the umpire(Twitter)
Stuart Broad and Joe Root have an argument with the umpire(Twitter)

Root, Anderson, Broad indulge in heated chat with umpire after Gill survives

UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 08:17 PM IST
England captain Joe Root, Stuart Broad the bowler and James Anderson were however not amused with the third umpire’s decision. The three senior cricketers were seen having an animated chat with umpire Chaudhary.
Close
Kedar Devdhar: File Photo(BCCI)
Kedar Devdhar: File Photo(BCCI)

Baroda continue winning streak, beat Hyderabad by 110 runs

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 07:04 PM IST
This is Baroda's third win on the trot after they had defeated Goa and Tripura.
Close
Devdutt Padikkal(Twitter)
Devdutt Padikkal(Twitter)

Padikkal's career-best 152 hands Karnataka big win; Kerala consolidate lead

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:51 PM IST
The 20-year-old opener smashed five sixes and 14 fours en route to his third List A century in his 16th game to propel Karnataka to 329 for five after being invited to bat at the KSCA Ground 3 in Alur.
Close
Axar Patel celebrates with R Ashwin other Indian cricketers(BCCI)
Axar Patel celebrates with R Ashwin other Indian cricketers(BCCI)

Axar, Ashwin make pink-ball tall, India bundle out England for 112

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:31 PM IST
Axar Patel registered his career-best figures of 6 for 38 as India spinners called the shots in the first-ever day-night pink-ball Test between India and England in the world’s largest cricket stadium that has a capacity of 1 lakh 32 thousand.
Close
Shahid Afridi(Twitter)
Shahid Afridi(Twitter)

Afridi tweets to ICC expressing displeasure at umpires not holding bowlers' cap

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:54 PM IST
Shahid Afridi who is playing for Multan Sultans in the ongoing Pakistan Super League, was not happy on Tuesday night when, during their match against Peshawar Zalmi, the umpires refused to take his cap when he came on to bowl.
Close
Virat Kohli celebrates the wicket of Joe Root
Virat Kohli celebrates the wicket of Joe Root

Kohli's animated celebration after Root's wicket gets Twitter talking

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:15 PM IST
While it was a well thought out delivery from R Ashwin that got the in-form Joe Root out, it was Virat Kohli’s celebration afterwards that caught the eyes of the Twitter users. Here's how Twitter reacted to Kohli's celebration of Root's wicket.
Close
Virat Kohli expressed his concerns for the fielding team at the toss of the third Test against England.
Virat Kohli expressed his concerns for the fielding team at the toss of the third Test against England.

'Worried about lights': Kohli expresses concern for the fielding team at Motera

UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 03:55 PM IST
India captain Virat Kohli said that lights at the refurbished stadium in Ahmedabad could potentially impact visibility and added the players will need to adapt quickly.
Close
Photo of Bengal cricketer Manoj Tiwary(Twitter)
Photo of Bengal cricketer Manoj Tiwary(Twitter)

Former Bengal skipper Manoj Tiwary joins TMC ahead of Assembly elections

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 03:00 PM IST
After joining the party, Tiwary said Mamata Banerjee is trying to unite people together.
Close
India's Ishant Sharma in action.(Action Images via Reuters)
India's Ishant Sharma in action.(Action Images via Reuters)

Ishant Sharma becomes 2nd Indian pacer to play 100 Tests after Kapil Dev

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 02:23 PM IST
India vs England: Ishant Sharma was expectedly named in the playing XI for the third Test in Ahmedabad.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP