Uttarakhand’s ailing elephant with capped toe has experts, activists divided

Veterinarians who treat the animal at the Ramnagar forest division say Lakshmi is under a lot of pain and distress, due to infection in one of her front toe nails, sustained after an injury.
The toe nail of the 55-year-old elephant has been capped to avoid further infection.(HT Photo)
The toe nail of the 55-year-old elephant has been capped to avoid further infection.(HT Photo)
Published on Mar 30, 2019 05:46 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Dehradun | By

The plight of a 55-year-old injured and aging elephant, seized by the state authorities from various private parties following a Nainital High Court order last year, has divided wildlife experts and activists on the relevance of providing extra care and attention to the suffering animal.

Veterinarians who treat the animal at the Ramnagar forest division say Lakshmi is under a lot of pain and distress, due to infection in one of her front toe nails, sustained after an injury. The pain has also made the animal aggressive in its behaviour towards mahouts and staff, say the doctors. The toe nail has been capped to avoid further infection.

Then on March 24, Lakshmi fell unconscious, requiring the staff to engage the service of a crane to get the elephant back to its feet.

Dushyant Kumar, veterinarian, Corbett Tiger Reserve, who is looking after Lakshmi said the animal might develop tumour. “There’s exposition of adipose tissue through nail cuticle. Exposition is a severe condition which may lead to tumor. Presently, it’s causing severe pain.”

Meanwhile, the divisional forest officer (DFO) wants the animal to be shifted to a private elephant care centre in Uttar Pradesh, but the idea may not feasible as the department does not have ownership rights over the animal.

“No one except me or my staff knows how much pain the elephant is going through,” said BP Singh, DFO, Ramnagar. “We do not have the requisite infrastructure to provide treatment to the animal. We have been consulting WII, IVRI, Pantnagar University, but the animal needs to be shifted to a place with high-end services for treatment,” Singh said.

“But we do not have ownership rights, we are keeping the elephant in our custody, temporarily as per the high court order,” Mounish Mullick, chief wildlife warden said.

The department spends close to Rs 8 lakh a month, on the seized elephants, by way of salaries for mahouts, security staff, and logistics.

Said Pradeep K Mallik, senior scientist, Wildlife Institute of India (WII), Dehradun “The situation is beyond the expertise of veterinarians now,” said Mallik. “There is an immediate need to invite a dedicated team of experts.” Adding on he said that Uttarakhand forest department had been forthcoming in training vets, but this situation needs a team of dedicated experts.

Wildlife activists, however, remains divided on whether or not the animal should be provided special care.

“The elephant is old. We should stop worrying about it now,” said AJT Johnsingh, a wildlife ecologist and activist. “Had it been a young elephant of 20-25 years, then it would have been worth trying to save it. But, this one is already too old to save,” said Johnsingh.

However, Gauri Maulekhi, an animal rights activist disagreed.

“The animals are where they should be and must be given the highest possible care by the Uttarakhand Forest Department. The amount spent on treatment and care of the elephants should be recovered from the accused persons from whom the elephants have been seized,” said Maulekhi. “Surprisingly, the DFO Ramnagar has not asked for any such amount from the accused till date,” she said.

K Ullas Karanth, director, Bangalore-based Centre for Wildlife Studies said, “The care provided to captive elephants in India by both government or private parties are poor. This practice of having captive elephants should be phased out,” he said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Nihi Sharma is a Principal Correspondent based in Dehradun. She has been working with Hindustan Times since 2008. Her focus areas are wildlife and environment. Besides, she also covers politics, health and education.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Basavaraj Bommai conveyed his gratitude to Prime Minister Narendra Modi for recommending a highly deserving personality like Dr Heggade for Rajya Sabha.

    Karnataka CM congratulates Dr Veerendra Heggade for nomination to Rajya Sabha

    Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Wednesday expressed his happiness at the nomination of Dharmadhikari of Sri Kshetra Dharmasthala, Dr D Veerendra Heggade, as member of Rajya Sabha. The Chief Minister also congratulated other nominees -- eminent athlete P T Usha, legendary music composer Ilaiyaraaja and renowned film screenwriter K V Vijayendra Prasad. BJP Karnataka president Nalin Kumar Kateel and other senior BJP functionaries congratulated Dr Heggade.

  • File photo of Maharashtra CM Eknath Shinde and Sena supremo Uddhav Thackeray.

    Uddhav changes Lok Sabha chief whip as Shinde camp hints at MPs jumping ship  

    The Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena replaced Bhavana Gawali as its chief whip in the Lok Sabha and nominated Rajan Vichare in her place. The information was shared by the Sena's Rajya Sabha MP and spokesperson Sanjay Raut. Raut is the Leader of the Shiv Sena Parliamentary Party. Vichare represents Thane in the Lok Sabha. Eknath Shinde is also from Thane. The Shiv Sena has 18 MPs in the Lok Sabha and three in the Rajya Sabha.

  • The MNGL has hiked the retail price of Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) for the vehicular segment in Pune city including Pimpri-Chinchwad and adjoining areas of Chakan, Talegaon and Hinjewadi with effect from midnight of Wednesday. (REPRESENTATIVE IMAGE)

    CNG price hiked by 3 per kg in Pune, Pimpri-Chinchwad

    PUNE The Maharashtra Natural Gas Limited has hiked the retail price of Compressed Natural Gas for the vehicular segment in Pune city including Pimpri-Chinchwad and adjoining areas of Chakan, Talegaon and Hinjewadi with effect from midnight of Wednesday. According to company officials, MNGL has increased the CNG rates by ₹3 per kg inclusive of taxes. The CNG retail selling price has been revised from ₹82 per kg to ₹85 per kg.

  • Anti-larvae wing of Ludhiana health department had found mosquito larvae from different areas while inspection. The dengue larvae were destroyed on the spot by spraying chemicals. (HT FILE)

    Dengue threat: Zonal entomologist conducts inspection in Ludhiana

    With rising concern over dengue and chikungunya, a team led by zonal entomologist, Patiala, Amritpal Kaur on Wednesday inspected different areas in the city where a large number of cases of these diseases were reported last year. The areas included Haibowal Khurd, Rishi Nagar Block 2, Haibowal Kalan, Durgapuri etc. The larvae were destroyed on the spot by spraying chemicals.

  • Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai.

    Karnataka CM Bommai directs officials to conduct survey of flood-prone areas

    Speaking to media persons at Mysuru airport, Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai said, some villages are inundated whenever it rains heavily. The Deputy Commissioners of the affected districts have been instructed to take up rescue and relief works immediately. The Revenue minister is heading to Madikeri to oversee the relief works. All precautionary measures have been taken. Uttara Kannada, Dakshina Kannada and Udupi districts are witnessing coastal erosion too. The Education minister would soon initiate measures in this regard.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, July 06, 2022