Long-term sexual relation based on promise of marriage can’t be involuntary, says Delhi HC

Justice Vibhu Bakhru said it is difficult to accept that continuing with an intimate relationship, which also involves engaging in sexual activity over a significant period of time, can be construed as involuntary.
The single judge bench was hearing the appeal of a woman who had challenged the acquittal of a man who she claimed had raped her on the pretext of marriage and later deserted her.(HT Archive)
The single judge bench was hearing the appeal of a woman who had challenged the acquittal of a man who she claimed had raped her on the pretext of marriage and later deserted her.(HT Archive)
Updated on Dec 17, 2020 09:40 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, New Delhi | ByRicha Banka

“A promise of marriage cannot be held as an inducement for engaging in sex over a protracted and indefinite period of time”, the Delhi high court said, while dismissing the appeal of a woman who had challenged the acquittal of man who she had accused of raping on the pretext of marriage.

Justice Vibhu Bakhru said it is difficult to accept that continuing with an intimate relationship, which also involves engaging in sexual activity over a significant period of time, can be construed as involuntary.

“Inducement to have a physical relationship by promising marriage and the victim falling prey to such an inducement may be understandable in the context of the moment. A promise of marriage cannot be held as an inducement for engaging in sex over a protracted and indefinite period of time,” the court said in its judgment passed on December 15.

The single judge bench was hearing the appeal of a woman who had challenged the acquittal of a man who she claimed had raped her on the pretext of marriage and later deserted her.

On August 15, 2015, the woman had filed a complaint at the police station in Malviya Nagar alleging rape following which an FIR was registered under IPC sections 376 (rape) and 415 (cheating) against the accused. In her complaint, the woman had alleged that she was working as a domestic help in Greater Kailash and she knew the accused since 2008.

She claimed that he promised to marry her and made her elope with him. He later took her to his house and kept her with him as his bride, she said. During that period, she became pregnant but he allegedly forced her to terminate the pregnancy.

Till 2013, they stayed together. Then the accused left for his village in Punjab and later she got to know that he had married a woman there.

In 2014, she continued to be in touch with the accused over phone, and also stayed with him in a rented house in Faridabad for almost six months. Later, he got married to another woman following which she registered the complaint.

The court said it is apparent that there is no dispute between the woman and the accused and the relationship between them was consensual. It also said the allegation that the accused had given her a promise of marriage is not sustainable.

The judge said in certain cases, a promise to marry may induce a party to agree to establish sexual relations, even though such a party does not desire to consent to the same. In such cases, a false promise to marry with the intention to exploit the other party may vitiate consent and thus, constitute rape, the court said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Complaints against service charge being added mandatorily in food bills, by restaurants, has led the central government call a meeting with the National Restaurants Association of India (NRAI). (Photo: Sanchit Khanna/HT (For representational purposes only))

    Delhiites seek service charge-free food, restaurateurs reason out

    Appreciating the effort of a server when dining out, and extending monetary reward/tipping is a universally accepted practice. However, the levying mandatory service charges was ordered to be stopped, by the government. Still, many eateries have continued to add service charge in the issued bills, and some have even written it in their menu about not wanting to lay off this charge under any circumstance.

  • The arrest count in the case has now surpassed 50. (HT File)

    Police recruitment case: Key conspirator's close aide held in Karnataka - report

    The Criminal Investigation Department probing the police sub-inspector recruitment scam has arrested one more person from Afzalpur in Kalaburagi district, sources in the CID said. The arrested person is said to be a close aide of one of the key conspirators Rudragouda D Patil. The accused had reportedly provided a bluetooth device to a candidate. He was also a link between Patil and the candidates who passed the exam through unfair means.

  • How is one identified as a Hindu according to RSS, is it enough to be born to Hindu parents or should one be a member of the BJP, Siddaramaiah asked. (HT PHOTO.)

    Siddaramaiah continues to call RSS 'Aryan', asks it to come clean on loyalty

    Continuing his attack against the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, calling it a "Aryan" organisation, senior Congress leader Siddaramaiah on Saturday urged its leaders to come clean about their loyalty, whether it was for tricolour or saffron flag, constitution or Manu Smriti and Mahatma Gandhiji or Nathuram Godse.

  • Ludhiana’s Tibba police busted a honey-trap racket and arrested four persons, including two women, on Saturday. (Image for representational purpose)

    Ludhiana: Honey-trap gang busted, two women among four held

    Tibba police busted a honey-trap racket and arrested four persons, including two women, on Saturday. One of the members of the gang has yet to be caught, the police said. The FIR against them has been registered on the complaint of Nagendra Yadav of New Vijay Nagar. A fabric manufacturer, Yadav, told the police that he runs a factory near Puneet Nagar. On Friday evening, he was going to his factory on a scooter.

  • Two women caught amid strong winds witnessed in Ludhiana on Saturday. (HT Photo)

    Ludhiana witnesses a pleasant turn of weather

    Bringing relief from the scorching heat, the thunderstorm witnessed in the city on Saturday evening turned the weather pleasant. Partly cloudy weather prevailed in the city since morning and rains, along with strong winds, brought down the mercury levels in the evening. As per the meteorological department, Chandigarh, the maximum temperature in the city was recorded at 40 degrees Celsius while the minimum was 27 degrees.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Sunday, May 29, 2022