How much is a life worth?

Updated on Feb 22, 2008 02:35 AM IST

The Delhi High Court ridiculed the legal provision of a mere Rs 50,000 as interim compensation for the kin of those who get killed in road accidents, reports Harish V Nair.

HT Image
HT Image
Hindustan Times | ByHarish V Nair, New Delhi

The Delhi High Court on Thursday ridiculed the legal provision of a mere Rs 50,000 as interim compensation for the kin of those who get killed in road accidents. The court, which for the first time in a judgment described the Bluelines as “killer buses”, sought to remind the Centre, which was yet to amend the Motor Vehicles Act hiking the amount, and the insurance companies that a person's life is not cheaper than the Nano, the lowest-priced car set to hit the road.

“In any event, it is to be remembered that life of a human being is not cheaper than a Nano car,” wrote Justice Kailash Gambhir, awarding a compensation of Rs 4.6 lakh to the parents of a 21-year-old who was crushed under the wheels of a bus nine years ago.

The proposed amendment in the Motor Vehicles Act to increase the amount to Rs one lakh has been passed by the Lok Sabha and is pending before the Rajya Sabha. As an interim measure, a Division Bench of the High Court headed by Justice Mukul Mudgal is levying Rs 1 lakh on owners for the release of buses involved in fatal accidents and Rs 50,000 on those causing grievous hurt. It also plans to release the amount to victims.

Stressing that the meagre amount fixed 14 years had to be hiked, Justice Gambhir said, "Massive progress in urbanisation and industrialisation led to faster way of life and faster vehicular traffic. This was a boon to many and a bane to some. With the escalation in automobile traffic, there has been a corresponding increase in the road accidents."

Noting that the Blueline buses have turned out to be the "major killers" as far as Delhi is concerned, the court said, "Death of any person in the family torments and shatters the entire family more particularly when it is the death of the sole bread winner."

Justice Gambhir squarely blamed the insurance companies for delaying compensation to victims saying they are prompt in settling the claims relating to damaged vehicles by promptly appointing investigator/surveyor and photographers but create obstructions in settling claims of victims of accidents forcing them to knock the doors of courts.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Rohtas Police said they are yet to identify the Bihar girl who was presumed to have been abducted by the two men on the motorcycle (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

    Bihar teen abducted on bike tries to escape, crushed by truck behind them

    The incident took place in Dehri-on-Sone, an industrial township in western Bihar's Rohtas district. Police said they were yet to identify the girl. Witnesses said they saw two men on the bike with the young girl. She landed in front of a container truck that was behind the motorcycle and was crushed to death. The two men on the bike escaped. Dehri station house officer Rajiv Kumar said they were trying to identify the girl and the two men.

  • A team of biologists working along a stretch of a beach in East Midnapore found the carcasses. (File image)

    Porpoises with fins allegedly chopped off found in West Bengal; probe ordered

    Carcasses of at least four Indo-Pacific Finless Porpoises with fins allegedly chopped off were found in the coastal district of East Midnapore in West Bengal on Friday. A team of biologists working along a stretch of a beach in East Midnapore found the carcasses. The most distinct feature of the finless porpoise is that it lacks a dorsal fin. Instead, it has large flippers on their sides.

  • Krishna Janmashtami celebrations in Bengaluru. (Putthige Mutt/Twitter)

    Janmashtami celebrations in Bengaluru | In pics

    This year's Krishna Janmashtami was celebrated with great fervour across Bengaluru, with many sharing photos and videos of the decorations and the pooja online. The Radio City Twitter handle also shared a video of the Iskcon's Akshaya Patra sewa, writing, “Iskcon's Akshaya Patra Taste of Bengaluru Check out this video as RJ Rajas introduces you to Iskcon's Akshaya Patra- Megha Kitchen, On this Krishna Janmashtami the temple makes it really special.”

  • Satbir Singh Gosal, 67, was appointed vice-chancellor of Punjab Agricultural University (PAU), Ludhiana, by the state government on Friday. (HT Photo)

    Satbir Singh Gosal is vice-chancellor of Punjab Agricultural University

    Satbir Singh Gosal, 67, has been appointed vice-chancellor of Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana. The Punjab government made an announcement to this effect on Friday. Also read: Punjab VB unearths vehicle fitness certificate scam at Sangrur RTA office Gosal was among 57 applicants and finally selected from among a panel of three. He was the director, research, at the university before he retired seven years ago.

  • Mithali Raj (in pic) made her international debut in 1999 against Ireland, along with Reshma Gandhi. Both hit a century on debut. (Getty Images)

    Global Village Idiot: Glory, performance, retirement, inspiration, glory

    June was a sad month for me because one of India's all-time great cricketers, Mithali Raj, retired from all forms of international cricket. In 1984, I was at an all-time low as a high school athlete. I was in Delhi at the time, and classmates dragged me to an international film festival where I watched “Chariots of Fire”, based on the life of British athletes Eric Lidell and Harold Abrahams.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, August 19, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now