Jurisdiction rights: NHRC, J&K govt at loggerheads

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and Jammu and Kashmir Government are at loggerheads over the right's body's jurisdiction in the trouble-torn state.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Jan 26, 2011 11:07 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | BySatya Prakash, New Delhi

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and Jammu and Kashmir Government are at loggerheads over the right's body's jurisdiction in the trouble-torn state.

Putting aside the J&K's contention that the NHRC does not have jurisdiction to issue recommendations in a case of death due to police atrocities in the state, the rights body has asserted that it does have powers to deal with such cases as its "recommendations do not interfere with any of the heads of legislation."

The controversy related to the commission's August 19, 2009 direction to the state to pay Rs5 lakh to the kin of a rickshaw puller, Mohan Lal, a victim of police atrocity. Suspected of burglaries in Jammu, Lal was picked up on June 21, 2003 by Jammu Police from Amritsar and taken to Jammu for interrogation and died after 11 days.

According to the NHRC, there was evidence to indicate that he was subjected to third degree torture during interrogation leading to his death.

Asian Centre for Human Rights Director Suhas Chakma had brought the incident to the notice of the NHRC and the commission had then asked J&K to pay compensation.

The state instead contended that the commission had failed to realise the statutory limitation in exercising its jurisdiction as Section (2) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 specifically excluded the operation of the Act to J&K in so far as it pertained to matters relatable to the entries enumerated in List II (state list) of the VII Schedule (in the instant case public law and order) of the Constitution of India.

But, the commission rejected J&K's contention on the ground that the List II contained the heads of legislation in respect of which a state legislature can make laws. It asked the state to comply with its directions by the end of February.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • KPCC President DK Shivakumar in Bengaluru. (ANI Photo/ ANI Pic Service)

    Not aware of ED chargesheet's contents, says Karnataka Cong chief DK Shivakumar

    Karnataka Congress president D K Shivakumar, who is slated to appear before a Delhi court later this week in connection with a money laundering case, on Tuesday said Shivakumar is not aware about the contents of Enforcement Directorate's charge sheet against him and is yet to receive a copy of it. A Delhi court last month summoned him and others in a money laundering case registered against him in 2018.

  • Karnataka saw over 900 new cases of COVID-19 within 24 hours and also recorded one death on Tuesday. (Representative image)

    Bengaluru logs 887 Covid cases; health dept says positives include backlog cases

    Bengaluru logged 887 of Karnataka's 968 new Covid-19 infections on Tuesday, compared to 592 (of 617 in the state) the day before. The health department said Tuesday's positives included backlog cases which could not be ported from Indian Council for Medical Research database due to a technical glitch. Data indicated that 337 people were declared to have recovered from Covid in the state, of whom 293 were from Bengaluru.

  • A screengrab from the video uploaded by ANI.

    Deserted streets, downed shutters as Udaipur remains on edge | Watch

    Streets wore a deserted look and shops remained closed amid eerie calm in Udaipur on Wednesday, the first morning after a man was beheaded for supporting former BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma, who was suspended from the party earlier this month for her controversial remarks on Prophet Mohammad.

  • Preliminary findings by police stated that the crane used to ferry construction materials malfunctioned. (Representative image)

    Four killed after tower crane collapse in Navi Mumbai, 2 others critical

    In a tragic incident, four persons including two labourers, one crane operator and a car driver, died due to a crane accident Navi Mumbai on Tuesday evening. They working at an under construction site of City and Industrial Development Corporation's Taloja phase 2 project in Navi Mumbai The accident occurred after the tower crane used to transport construction materials atop Taloja collapsed from the 14th floor and landed on them.

  • NIA spokesman in a statement said that on Monday the NIA arrested two accused Tanveer Ahmad Wani of Achagoza, Rajpora, Pulwama and Peer Arshad Iqbal, alias Ashu of Khwaja Bagh, Baramulla in Jammu and Kashmir. (HT Photo/ Representational image)

    NIA arrests two from Jammu and Kashmir for cross-LoC trade, terror funding

    The NIA has arrested two accused in Jammu & Kashmir in the cross-LoC trade and terror funding case. Earlier, the NIA had conducted multiple raids across the Valley in the terror-funding case. NIA spokesman in a statement said that on Monday the NIA arrested two accused Tanveer Ahmad Wani of Achagoza, Rajpora, Pulwama and Peer Arshad Iqbal, alias Ashu of Khwaja Bagh, Baramulla.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, June 29, 2022