The Ivy League imprint on US judiciary, cabinet | Number Theory

.

Donald Trump and America’s richest and perhaps most prestigious university are fighting right now. After Harvard University refused to accept the Trump administration’s demands, essentially an accommodation of Trump’s political agenda in Harvard’s policies, it has seen its grants being frozen and faced threats that include the withdrawal of its tax-exempt status and a ban on taking foreign students.

The Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, US. (REUTERS)

The culmination of this battle will likely take place in the US Supreme Court given the different interpretations each party has on the constitutional validity of Trump’s actions. As and when this happens, the justices in the US Supreme Court will have to deal with more than just a dispassionate question of law. This is because an overwhelming majority of the US Supreme Court justices belong to just two elite universities (Harvard and Yale) unlike Trump’s cabinet, which has the lowest share of people from elite institutions in the recent past.

The Ivy League imprint on US judiciary, cabinet

• 
  Four out of nine US Supreme Court judges, including Chief Justice John Roberts are Harvard law graduates

  Among nine current justices, eight hold law degrees from either Harvard or Yale. Justice Amy Coney Barrett is the sole exception, having studied at Notre Dame Law School. Yale Law School counts among its alumni Justices Brett Kavanaugh, Sonia Sotomayor, Clarence Thomas, and Samuel Alito. Meanwhile, Justices Neil Gorsuch, Elena Kagan, Ketanji Brown Jackson, and Chief Justice John Roberts earned their law degrees from Harvard. Data shows that although Supreme Court justices in the past came from a relatively diverse range of legal educational backgrounds, recent history has seen a fall in this diversity. From 1970 till 2022—no change in composition of US Supreme Court justices has taken place since 2022 —Harvard alone accounted for 40.4% of all US Supreme Court justices. Harvard was followed by Yale at 23.4%. The dominance of these two institutes in the US Supreme Court has only grown with time, with their combined share going up from 44.4% in 1970 to 88.9% in 2022. Notably, since 1902 onwards, the US Supreme Court has had at least one Harvard graduate as a justice at all times.
• 
  Only two out of 24 in Trump’s cabinet are Harvard graduates

  Unlike the sitting US Supreme Court justices, people from Ivy League universities (an athletic group of eight private US universities that includes Harvard and Yale) are a minority in the Trump administration. Just two people in the current cabinet; secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth and secretary of health Robert F. Kennedy Jr. are Harvard graduates. Donald Trump himself included, he took undergraduate classes at University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business, only five of 24 members of the administration have attended one of the eight Ivy League institutes. This includes J D Vance, the vice president who is a Yale law graduate. If the norms are relaxed to also include other ‘elite’ institutes (a list of 34 elite universities, including the eight Ivy League institutes, was used from a 2024 Nature paper that studied elite educational backgrounds of influential Americans), this number goes up to reach nine or 37.5%.
• 
  The second Trump administration has fewer elite school graduates than its predecessors

  HT examined the educational backgrounds of U.S. Cabinet members across six presidencies since the 1990s, from Bill Clinton to Donald Trump’s second term. The analysis shows that the current administration has the lowest representation of Ivy League and other elite institutions—only 20.8% of members attended an Ivy League university, and just 37.5% graduated from one of the 34 top-tier institutions overall, as discussed above. The first Trump administration had the second-lowest share, with 25.6% from Ivy League universities and 48.7% from elite institutions. The George W. Bush presidency, the only other Republican administration during this period, ranked next, with 39.1% of Cabinet members from Ivy League universities and 52.2% from elite institutions. In contrast, the Barack Obama administration had the highest representation, with 59.2% from Ivy League universities and 77.6% from elite institutions. To be sure, it is also worth underlining that a much lower proportion of US adults have received similar levels of education. The Nature paper cited a 2015 survey to show that only around 32.5% of the adult US population held a bachelor’s degree or higher. Of this group, just 1.9% have graduated from a so-called elite university, approximately 0.6% from one of the eight Ivy League schools, and a mere 0.2% from Harvard University.