Should students use trollies instead of schoolbags? This is what researchers think

Schoolbags or trollies? Scientists discuss the pros and cons of each and suggest what is best fro your children.

health and fitness Updated: Mar 07, 2017 13:06 IST
Agence france-Presse
Heavy Schoolbag,Trolly to School,Schoolchildren
New research suggests that carrying a backpack to school has a more detrimental effect on children’s health than pulling a trolley.(Istock)

The discussion on how much burden schoolchildren should carry on their shoulders has been there since a long time, with scientists coming up with newer alternatives to improve the situation. Now they’re debating if using trollies instead of schoolbags is a better option.

Previous research has already looked at the effect of carrying a heavy backpack around school all day on children’s health and comfort, with findings leading many experts to agree that a backpack should not weigh more than 10-15 % of the child’s bodyweight.

The most recent study, carried out by a team from the University of Granada (UGR), Spain, has added to the debate by focusing on whether pulling a trolley could be better for kids than carrying schoolwork around in a backpack.

A previous attempt has already been made to settle the matter, with a small-scale 2010 study looking at the effect of both on 34 German schoolchildren between 6 and 8 years of age. That study found that although children adopted asymmetric postures while both toting a backpack and pulling a trolley, a trolley was also associated with a rotation of the spine which could be an extra source of stress on children’s bodies, leading the team to advise using a backpack, as long as the weight is within recommended limits.

However the team behind the new study believe that pulling a trolley to school is better for children than carrying around a heavy backpack.

After assessing body weight and posture of 78 schoolchildren aged six to 12, results showed that 47% of schoolchildren are carrying a load in their trolley or backpack above what is recommended on a daily basis.

A backpack should not weigh more than 10-15 % of a child’s bodyweight, say experts. (Shutterstock)

Furthermore 23% of the girls are carrying a load above 20% of their body weight, far higher than what is recommended.

In addition, after surveying the children, researchers found that 97% of backpackers believe their backpack is almost always heavy, compared with 85% of trolley users, despite the results suggesting that the weight of the trolleys is greater than backpacks.

Over 85% of those using a backpack also reported often feeling tired when carrying it, compared to 71% of trolley users, while back pain was reported by 43% of backpackers, compared to only 31% of those using trolleys.

Lead author Eva Orantes suggested that a trolley is beneficial where possible, provided its load doesn’t exceed the recommended amount of between 10 and 15% of the child’s weight.

The team is continuing with their research, which should shed more light on how children should take their work to school and how much they should take.

Meanwhile, for kids that need to use a backpack, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons recommends that parents ease the load on children by choosing one that is an appropriate size for the child, is lightweight, and comes with two wide, padded shoulder straps and a waist strap for extra comfort and support.

Follow @htlifeandstyle for more

First Published: Mar 07, 2017 11:45 IST