India is in dire need of a database which can tell us about the exact socio-economic status of various social groups.(HT File)
India is in dire need of a database which can tell us about the exact socio-economic status of various social groups.(HT File)

How share of jobs varies within social groups

While SC/ST workers have a disproportionate share in low-paying occupations, certain sub-castes within the group are better off than the rest.
By Roshan Kishore and Vijdan Mohammad Kawoosa | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 11, 2019 02:09 PM IST

Last month, the central government announced 10% reservation in jobs and educational institutions for economically weaker sections (EWS) among communities hitherto not entitled to such benefits.

The move aims to address economic inequality because, the logic went, the older system of reservation addressed only social inequality. The assumption behind the older system was that there was a complete correspondence between social and economic inequality.

In the absence of detailed data on employment by class and caste, it is difficult to understand this correspondence. But an HT analysis of 2011 Census data on types of jobs held by various social groups throws up three interesting take-outs on the relationship between social and economic inequality. The analysis also took into account the incomes for various kinds of jobs (so as to understand which social groups had the jobs with better incomes and which didn’t). The Census gives data on workers in accordance with the National Classification of Occupations (NCO). This has 10 broad categories: professionals; clerks; technicians and associate professionals; legislators, senior officers and managers; service workers and shop and market sales workers; plant and machine operators and assemblers; craft and related trades workers; skilled agricultural and fishery workers; elementary occupations; and workers not classified by occupations. The categories listed above are arranged in descending order of their monthly per capita consumption expenditure (MPCE, a proxy for income) taken from the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO ) data for 2011-12 (for details see https://bit.ly/2Gemivk).

So, what are the take-outs?

ONE: Social groups display a fairly heterogenous division across incomes. Sure, Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) workers have a disproportionate share in low-paying occupations in India. But these headline numbers do not tell us the entire story. Certain sub-castes within the SC/ST population are better off than the rest. For example, Jatavs, a Dalit sub-caste in Uttar Pradesh, or Minas, an ST community in Rajasthan, are much better off than other SC/ST workers in terms of their share in better-paying jobs. The chances of SC/ST workers being in a better paying occupation also depend on the state they come from. Richer states have a greater share of well-paying jobs, so this increases the likelihood of an SC/ST worker finding one as well.

TWO: The data clearly shows that SC/ST workers have a lower relative share in better paying occupations, but there are variations across regions.

The reverse holds true for low paying occupations. The opposite trend can be seen for non-SC, non-ST workers. Since the census does not have the Other Backward Class (OBC) category, the non-SC non-ST group includes both upper caste and OBCs.

See Chart: Relative share of SC-ST-Others

Relative share of a social group is its share of workers in an occupational category divided by its share in the total number of workers. This analysis excludes cultivators and agricultural workers, so we are only looking at non-farm employment.

These results are on expected lines. However, what is often not realised by many is the fact that these headline numbers hide significant sub-caste and geographical differences.

For example, the combined relative share of SC/ST workers in elementary occupations, the lowest income category, was the highest in Delhi, which is also the state where SC/ST workers had the second lowest, only after Odisha, relative share among professionals – the highest income occupational category – in 2011. This should not be inferred as SC/ST workers being worse off in Delhi than a state like Bihar, as a greater share of SC/ST workers in Delhi (14.8%) were employed in the top four occupations by MPCE than in Bihar (10.6%). In other words, an SC/ST worker in Delhi is better off than an SC-ST worker in many other parts of the country.

The relative share of SC/ST workers in better paying occupations is much higher in northeastern states than other regions, a reflection of fact that the ST population there is much better off than the rest of the SC/ST population in the country.

See Chart: State-wise breakup

The occupational break-up of workers also varies drastically among states. For example, the share of top four occupational categories by MPCE among total workers in richer states such as Delhi and Maharashtra was almost double the value in backward states such as Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Odisha. The reverse holds when it comes to share of workers in four lowest paying occupations in such states.

THREE: Even among SCs and STs, there are significant variations when it comes to representation in better and low paying occupations. For example, among SCs, Jatavs in Uttar Pradesh had a relative share of 1.1 in the top four occupations by MPCE. This number was just 0.6 for Balmikis in the state. Similarly, Minas had a relative share of 1.6 among STs in top four occupations by MPCE, which is much higher than the corresponding values for other SC/ST communities in the state. It should be noted that these relative shares represent share of a particular caste group within the SC/ST population and not the entire population. The sub-caste analysis has also looked at only top six groups in each state within the SC/ST category to exclude communities which have a miniscule share in the total population within these groups.

See chart: Summary findings from sub-caste state-wise

Sub-castes and tribes such as Jatavs in Uttar Pradesh and Minas in Rajasthan account for almost half of the SC/ST worker population in these states. This might have given them significant political clout, generating tailwinds in pursuit of upward mobility in the job market. To be sure, there are also communities such as the Malai Arayan tribe in Kerala which accounts for less than 10% of the working ST population in the state, but has the highest relative share among STs in top four occupations by MPCE in the country.

The analysis given above underlines the hazards of mechanically prioritising one basis of deprivation against another while analysing the labour market in India. It also shows that India is in dire need of a database which can tell us about the exact socio-economic status of various social groups.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
A medic administers the first dose of COVID-19 vaccine to Nutan Goel, wife of Union Health Minister Dr Harsh Vardhan during the second phase of a countrywide inoculation drive, at Delhi Heart and Lung Institute in New Delhi, (PTI)
A medic administers the first dose of COVID-19 vaccine to Nutan Goel, wife of Union Health Minister Dr Harsh Vardhan during the second phase of a countrywide inoculation drive, at Delhi Heart and Lung Institute in New Delhi, (PTI)

'There were some glitches on Co-Win but..' Harsh Vardhan explains

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 01:58 PM IST
The glitches were mainly because of the huge number of people trying to log in on the website, the minister explained and said that there were already five lakh registrations on Tuesday before 9am. On Monday, 25 lakh registrations were done.
Close
Congress leaders Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Rahul Gandhi. (File photp)
Congress leaders Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Rahul Gandhi. (File photp)

Cong’s new campaign style: Dance, push-ups and deep sea diving

UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 01:53 PM IST
On Monday, Assam and Kanyakumari, two corners of the country, saw a similar political portrait: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi in Kanyakumari and his sister party general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra in Assam, breaking into a dance with the locals
Close
Four people were crushed to death in the car crash in Andhra Pradesh.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Four people were crushed to death in the car crash in Andhra Pradesh.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

4 killed in car crash in AP's Anantapur, liquor bottle found near driver

By Srinivasa Rao Apparasu | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Hyderabad
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 01:14 PM IST
  • On receiving information from the locals, the police rushed to the spot to take up rescue operations.
Close
A health worker wearing protective gear takes a nasal swab sample of inbound travellers for Covid-19 coronavirus tests at CSMT railway station, in Mumbai. (Bhushan Koyande / HT Photo)
A health worker wearing protective gear takes a nasal swab sample of inbound travellers for Covid-19 coronavirus tests at CSMT railway station, in Mumbai. (Bhushan Koyande / HT Photo)

12,286 fresh Covid-19 cases recorded in India, infection tally crosses 11.12 mn

Written by Prashasti Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 01:17 PM IST
While the death toll increased to 157,248 with 91 new fatalities, the active caseload was recorded at 1,68,358 which accounts for 1.51 per cent of the total infections, the data stated.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses at the inauguration of Maritime India Summit 2021, through video conferencing, in New Delhi.(PTI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses at the inauguration of Maritime India Summit 2021, through video conferencing, in New Delhi.(PTI)

PM Modi inaugurates 'Maritime India Summit 2021'

ANI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:54 PM IST
Prime Minister also launched e-book of maritime vision 2030, which is aiming to make the Indian maritime industry at par with the top global benchmark in the next 10 years.
Close
Union health minister Dr Harsh Vardhan getting vaccinated at Delhi on Tuesday,
Union health minister Dr Harsh Vardhan getting vaccinated at Delhi on Tuesday,

'Hanumanji crossed country to get sanjeevani': Harsh Vardhan on Covid-19 vaccine

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 01:24 PM IST
A day after Prime Minister Narendra Modi took the first shot of Covaxin, several ministers on Tuesday got themselves inoculated.
Close
Vehicular movement to Ghaziabad from Delhi through Ghazipur border has been partially restored since Monday evening, (PTI Photo/Vijay Verma)(PTI)
Vehicular movement to Ghaziabad from Delhi through Ghazipur border has been partially restored since Monday evening, (PTI Photo/Vijay Verma)(PTI)

News updates from HT: Ghazipur border reopens partially after a month

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:52 PM IST
  • Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Most of the shops in the state were shut on the day of the strike. Representative Photo(Ravindra Joshi/HT photo/Representational)
Most of the shops in the state were shut on the day of the strike. Representative Photo(Ravindra Joshi/HT photo/Representational)

Kerala strike against rising fuel prices hits normal life

By Ramesh Babu | Edited by Abhinav Sahay
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:46 PM IST
  • The state government earlier ruled out a cut in state taxes to bring down fuel prices citing reduction in revenue.
Close
The Supreme Court of India. (File photo)
The Supreme Court of India. (File photo)

Termination of 26-week pregnancy of rape survivor? SC seeks medical board report

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:30 PM IST
An SC bench ordered the hospital to immediately set up the medical board, comprising three doctors, to examine the feasibility of termination of 14-year-old rape survivor’s pregnancy and submit a report by Friday
Close
The hash value changes at the slightest alteration of the original message, say with the insertion of even a comma or a full stop, leading to a new originator being created. (File photo)
The hash value changes at the slightest alteration of the original message, say with the insertion of even a comma or a full stop, leading to a new originator being created. (File photo)

Hash constant: Govt’s solution to tracing originator of viral messages

By Deeksha Bhardwaj
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:18 PM IST
The value changes at the slightest alteration of the original message, say with the insertion of even a comma or a full stop, leading to a new originator being created
Close
Union health minister Harsh Vardhan took the Covid-19 vaccine on Tuesday(ANI Twitter)
Union health minister Harsh Vardhan took the Covid-19 vaccine on Tuesday(ANI Twitter)

Union health minister Harsh Vardhan gets his first Covid vaccine shot in Delhi

Written by Prashasti Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:47 PM IST
India began its second phase of Covid-19 vaccination for those above 60 years of age, and people between 45 and 59 years of age with specific comorbidities.
Close
New Delhi, India - April 20, 2020: A view of the Parliament House seen as Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha secretariats resumed work from today after they were shut in the last week of March due to the COVID-19 outbreak, in New Delhi, India, on Monday, April 20, 2020. (Photo by Mohd Zakir/HT Archive) (Mohd Zakir/HT Archive)
New Delhi, India - April 20, 2020: A view of the Parliament House seen as Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha secretariats resumed work from today after they were shut in the last week of March due to the COVID-19 outbreak, in New Delhi, India, on Monday, April 20, 2020. (Photo by Mohd Zakir/HT Archive) (Mohd Zakir/HT Archive)

Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha channels merged to create new platform, Sansad TV

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 11:44 AM IST
Officials said that the Rajya Sabha TV establishment—that runs from a rented public property adjacent to the Talkatora stadium, will be merged with the LSTV’s infrastructure to create the new entity
Close
Partho Dasgupta, the former chief executive officer of BARC India is accused in the TRP manipulation scam. (HT Photo)(HT_PRINT)
Partho Dasgupta, the former chief executive officer of BARC India is accused in the TRP manipulation scam. (HT Photo)(HT_PRINT)

Bombay HC grants bail to former BARC CEO Partho Dasgupta, accused in TRP scam

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Shivani, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 12:06 PM IST
The bail was granted on a personal bond of 2lakh and two solvent sureties of the same amount.
Close
Chhattisgarh chief minister Bhupesh Baghel. (File photo)
Chhattisgarh chief minister Bhupesh Baghel. (File photo)

Baghel announces force for Chhattisgarh’s Maoist insurgency-hit Bastar

PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 11:20 AM IST
“Bastar Tigers special force will be formed in all [seven] districts of Bastar division...priority in recruitment will be given to local youths from remote villages,” Baghel said in his speech as he presented the 97,106 crore budget for 2021-22 in the state assembly on Monday
Close
BJP Gujarat State President CR Paatil during a bike rally at Dahod. (ANI Photo)
BJP Gujarat State President CR Paatil during a bike rally at Dahod. (ANI Photo)

Gujarat civic poll: BJP starts with early gains. Will AAP spring a surprise?

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 02, 2021 11:53 AM IST
The revolution which started in urban Gujarat continues in the rural polls, Aam Aadmi Party tweeted.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP