Age of extremes | Latest News India - Hindustan Times
close_game
close_game

Age of extremes

Hindustan Times | By
Aug 27, 2011 10:38 PM IST

Can you disagree with a person and still admire him? In theory, you can. But in practice it creates confusion. Karan Thapar writes.

Can you disagree with a person and still admire him? In theory, you can. But in practice it creates confusion. I discovered this on Tuesday night when I sent a few friends an SMS which read “Much as I disagree with some of his views and tactics, Anna is a truly amazing man.”

HT Image
HT Image

Some agreed, a few vehemently did not but the majority responded with incomprehension, even incredulity.

Hindustan Times - your fastest source for breaking news! Read now.

“Et tu,” summed it up neatly. This was apostasy. I had become a self-declared renegade.

Perhaps I was inviting trouble assuming everyone would accept the two extremes of my views without questioning the polarity between them or understand I had not forsaken my original position. But because I still believe one can hold divergent views I intend to explain my position more fully.

I strongly disagree with Anna Hazare’s original decision to fast unto death unless Parliament passes his Jan Lokpal Bill and that, too, before the end of the present monsoon session which, at the time he made this decision, had just 18 days to run. And I certainly oppose Shanti Bhushan’s codicil that amendments can only be made with Anna’s permission. I believe Anna’s stand is tantamount to an attempt to blackmail Parliament. Bhushan’s addition is simply insulting.

At the same time, however, there’s a lot in Anna’s bill I unequivocally agree with. The PM and MPs must be brought under the ambit of the lokpal. The selection procedure needs to be independent of government influence. State lokayuktas should be set up along similar lines. And, although I have no firm position on whether the higher judiciary should come under the lokpal, if it is to be kept out an effective National Judicial Commission needs to be set up.

But agreement with much of its content is not justification for forcing the bill on Parliament. Let me explain why. In a democracy the people express themselves through Parliament. Ours carries the mandate of 1.2 billion Indians. In contrast, Anna may have massive street support but even if you hold that several million have come out in support, and more have done so silently from their homes, it’s at best a minuscule fraction of the population. This is no basis for supplanting, leave aside subverting, Parliament. And remember, if you do you will end up debilitating our democracy, denting our Constitution and damaging our stability.

If Anna has his way today he will set a precedent for Hindu fanatics to demand a theocratic State tomorrow or social conservatives to castrate homosexuals the day after. All of them can claim more genuine majority support than Anna has for his original demand for the Jan Lokpal and none other.

But all this said and done, Anna’s decision to refuse hospitalisation and even a drip, when he knows his health is fast deteriorating and he stares death in the face, is admirable. How can you not admire such commitment to a cause? How can you not be awed by such courage to knowingly court death?

I would say every single Indian supports Anna’s campaign against corruption. We’re all frustrated and anguished by it. We welcome and applaud his leadership. But only a few believe the answer is acceptance of the Jan Lokpal Bill in its entirety without discussion or debate. And an even smaller minority want to force Parliament’s hand. This is where Anna has erred.

Yet his courage and conviction remain admirable. Most of us cheat while dieting. Anna refuses treatment and risks his life!

Thank god I only ask the questions!

The views expressed by the author are personal

Unveiling Elections 2024: The Big Picture', a fresh segment in HT's talk show 'The Interview with Kumkum Chadha', where leaders across the political spectrum discuss the upcoming general elections. Watch now!

Get Current Updates on India News, Election 2024, Arvind Kejriwal Arrest Live Updates, Bihar Board 12th Result Live along with Latest News and Top Headlines from India and around the world.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Share this article
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    author-default-90x90

    Karan Thapar is a super-looking genius who’s young, friendly, chatty and great fun to be with. He’s also very enjoyable to read.

SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
OPEN APP
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, March 27, 2024
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On