HT Image
HT Image

Exiles in their own land

Democracy wall: Gujarat?s Muslims face economic and social isolation even today, writes Harsh Mander.
By Harsh Mander | None
PUBLISHED ON FEB 19, 2007 11:47 PM IST

She wept bitterly that it was her son’s first day at work. We were initially confused. Why was this an occasion for grief? "He is just 10 years old,” she explained. It was his own decision to drop out of school, and join his father’s trade as a house painter. He felt that if he worked, at least the family would be freed from the burden of providing for him. His home is a grimy single-room tenement at the edge of the garbage dump for all of Ahmedabad city. The colony is one of more than 80 that sprang up for survivors of the 2002 massacre in Gujarat, who continue, even five years later, to live in dread of returning to their original homes. They survive not just as economic refugees but as fugitives from a continuing climate of sustained hate and fear.

The Gujarat government is in complete denial about the conditions of internal displacement. In an affidavit to the Supreme Court in January 2006, it admitted that some affected persons had not returned to their homes, but maintained that this was not because of fear but because of superior economic prospects that they found in the new locations. In a recent communication to the Supreme Court commissioners in the right to food case, it stated even more categorically that all “riot-affected people have returned to their homes”.

This official falsehood was easily nailed by a visit in October 2006 by the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) to 17 such colonies, where they found appalling living conditions. This was further confirmed by a comprehensive survey of 81 relief colonies by Aman Biradari, which found around 30,000 internal refugees living with abysmal denial of public services and livelihoods.

The survey noted that not a single of the 81 colonies were established by the state government, which did not even provide the land for any of these. Instead, every single of these were built by Muslim organisations on purchased land. In only six of these was there some kind of collaboration by secular NGOs. This is a grave abdication by the State but also by international and national humanitarian organisations.

From the start, after the forced closure of relief colonies by the Gujarat government in 2002, the return of 200,000 internally displaced persons to the land of their ancestors had to be painfully negotiated with neighbours who had betrayed and attacked them. There was rarely a welcome, or expression of remorse. It was made amply clear that their homecoming was on sufferance. The first condition if they insisted on returning was that they would not give evidence against their attackers in any criminal case. As a result of their consent to this humiliating condition, thousands of criminal cases connected with the carnage collapsed at the stages of investigation or trial. They also had to accept residential segregation and boycott in employment and trade.

For those who were unwilling to accept the terms set for their return, or who could still not muster the necessary trust to come back to the land of their ancestors with their families, or those who continued to be openly intimidated, the choices before them were stark: to leave Gujarat, to buy or rent homes in Muslim ghettoes or, if they were too poor, to live in the deprivation of relief colonies. It is difficult to estimate the numbers of the first two, in a situation in which the government refuses to keep records of displacement. This minimises its own responsibility and culpability. But this survey gives an idea of the numbers of internally displaced persons in relief colonies five years later.

The colonies were established by Muslim organisations on the cheapest land available, without connecting roads and distant from economic prospects. The daily grind of finding work is compounded by the fact that people who fled from numerous villages were bunched together in colonies that were built with paramount considerations of safety in numbers rather than sustainable prospects of employment. The survey found that the majority of men travel long distances to their old places of residence to eke out work, but there they are hampered by boycott of Muslim shops, eateries, even factory and farm workers and artisans. Women have mostly had to drop out of low-end employment once available in their old homes.

Most colonies continue to be treated as ‘unauthorised’, denied public services of drinking water, drainage, street lighting, ration shops and ICDS centres. There are only five ICDS centres in the 81 colonies, and only three serve supplementary nutrition to children. The NCM noted conditions of great destitution in the colonies — only 725 of the 4,545 families had below poverty line ration cards that entitle them to subsidised foodgrain. Even in such desperate conditions of daily survival, the state government chose to return Rs 19.1 crore unutilised from the highly insufficient grant of Rs 150 crore. Yet, it maintained that all tasks of relief, rehabilitation and compensation were fully accomplished. This was observed with regret also by the NCM, “In the course of our visits to the camps, we found several people who are in need of funds under different schemes. If the state government was able to identify such people and extend the benefits of the scheme to them they would be able to utilise the entire money allotted.”

The colonies’ residents, whose existence, let alone legality, is denied by the government, live under continuous insecurity also because they are vulnerable to pressures from local religious organisations. Residents report pressures to follow the specific beliefs of particular Muslim sects, or other lesser legitimate demands of local managers, on constant threat of overnight eviction. Widows and single women are the most vulnerable.

Children, as always, are worst affected. Only two of the 81 colonies were found to have government schools and five some form of private schools. In addition, religious teaching was offered in four mosques. There were non-Muslim students in only two of these schools. By exiling Muslim children into ghettoes and relief colonies through fear and hate, children of both communities are deprived of contact and companionship with children of other faiths. They will be far more susceptible to falsehoods about the ‘other’ community.

In the colony on the garbage dump, children have cleared a space amid the mountains of refuse to play cricket, while we found it hard to bear the stench. The residents survive with spirit and courage, amid sub-human conditions and failure of the State to provide a life of security and dignity to all without discrimination.

But they also live with isolation, fear, hate, boycott, intimidation and penury as a way of daily life. For this, we all stand indicted.

Harsh Mander is the convenor of Aman Biradari, a people’s campaign for secularism, peace and justice.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Public bike-sharing facility was launched at Bandra-Kurla Complex in Mumbai last year. (HT fle)
Public bike-sharing facility was launched at Bandra-Kurla Complex in Mumbai last year. (HT fle)

Public bike-sharing cheapest mode for last-mile connectivity in Mumbai: Survey

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:04 AM IST
The analysis by World Resources Institute (WRI) India shows that while public bike-sharing costs 2 for a five km ride, the same distance costs 5 in a BEST bus and local train (second class), 50 in first class and 20 in Metro
Close
The apex court had also ordered that after the judgement of Delhi High Court, Centre should grant permanent commission to women officers.(PTI file photo)
The apex court had also ordered that after the judgement of Delhi High Court, Centre should grant permanent commission to women officers.(PTI file photo)

Indian Army organises 5-day recruitment drive for women in Lucknow

ANI, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:51 AM IST
The recruitment drive for women comes after the apex court on February 17, 2020.
Close
A health worker in PPE collects a swab sample from a person for coronavirus testing, outside New Ashok Nagar Metro station in New Delhi.(Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)
A health worker in PPE collects a swab sample from a person for coronavirus testing, outside New Ashok Nagar Metro station in New Delhi.(Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)

India’s daily Covid-19 cases drop to 10,064, recoveries surpass 10.22 million

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:49 AM IST
A total of 3,81,305 beneficiaries were vaccinated in the first three days of the Covid-19 immunisation drive.
Close
The weather office said that the coldest place in the valley on the intervening night of Monday and Tuesday was Qazigund in south Kashmir where the mercury plunged to -8.6 degrees Celsius, around 5 notches below normal. (AP)
The weather office said that the coldest place in the valley on the intervening night of Monday and Tuesday was Qazigund in south Kashmir where the mercury plunged to -8.6 degrees Celsius, around 5 notches below normal. (AP)

Kashmir: Wet spell later this week could end cold wave, says IMD

By Mir Ehsan
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:41 AM IST
From the past one week,a cold wave has gripped the Valley and the night temperature has been hovering around -8 and -7 degrees Celsius
Close
Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath. (File photo)
Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath. (File photo)

MP high court rejects bail of man arrested for sharing Yogi’s morphed picture

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sameer
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:30 AM IST
The judge reportedly said that Yogi isn’t just a chief minister but also a saint and religious sentiments were hurt when the accused ”insulted a saint”
Close
Representational image. (REUTERS)
Representational image. (REUTERS)

Covid-19 vaccines: Fact sheets warn against use in immuno-compromised

UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:23 AM IST
The health ministry’s guidance document for states on precautions and contraindications for Covid-19 vaccine was released two days before the launch of Covid-19 vaccination drive on January 16
Close
PM Modi posted a picture of his visit to Adyar cancer institute while condoling the demise of Dr V Shanta.(Twitter/@narendramodi)
PM Modi posted a picture of his visit to Adyar cancer institute while condoling the demise of Dr V Shanta.(Twitter/@narendramodi)

'Saddened by Dr V Shanta's demise': PM Modi pays tribute to senior oncologist

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:18 AM IST
Veteran oncologist Dr V Shanta was admitted to a private hospital in the city last night after she complained of chest pain.
Close
A general view of the tent city at Magh Mela. (File photo)
A general view of the tent city at Magh Mela. (File photo)

Magh mela: Organisers of dance fined for obscenity

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Sameer
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:18 AM IST
A Rs2 lakh fine has also been slapped on show organisers; Prayagraj DM has assured that such events are not repeated in the mela area
Close
Representational image. (Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)
Representational image. (Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)

UP govt lifts ban on import of poultry from other states

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:13 AM IST
The UP government had on January 10 issued a circular declaring the whole state as “controlled zone” and banning the import of all kinds of live birds till January 24
Close
Dr Shanta was the Chairman and Executive Chairman of the Cancer Institute (WIA) Chennai.(@VanathiBJP/Twitter)
Dr Shanta was the Chairman and Executive Chairman of the Cancer Institute (WIA) Chennai.(@VanathiBJP/Twitter)

Cancer Institute founder V Shanta passes away in Chennai

ANI, Chennai
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 11:12 AM IST
The veteran oncologist was admitted to a private hospital in the city last night after she complained of chest pain.
Close
Union minister for road transport and highways Nitin Gadkari. (File photo)
Union minister for road transport and highways Nitin Gadkari. (File photo)

Govt aims to reduce road accidents by 50% before 2025: Nitin Gadkari

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:10 AM IST
Inaugurating the first National Road Safety Month on Monday, the minister for road transport and highways said that social-economic losses from accident deaths amount to a shocking 3.14% of GDP every year
Close
Union Minister for Petroleum and Natural Gas Dharmendra Pradhan.((Sanket Wankhade/HT PHOTO))
Union Minister for Petroleum and Natural Gas Dharmendra Pradhan.((Sanket Wankhade/HT PHOTO))

Hike in fuel prices due to lower production amid Covid-19: Dharmendra Pradhan

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:00 AM IST
The Union Minister asserted that the government was focusing on electric vehicles (EVs), solar energy, production of ethanol etc to become self-reliant in the energy sector.
Close
The highest level of treatment was provided, but the man could not be saved.(HT Photo)
The highest level of treatment was provided, but the man could not be saved.(HT Photo)

K'taka: Health worker, who was administered Covid vaccine, dies of heart attack

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 09:55 AM IST
The deceased Nagaraju was a permanent employee of the health department who was vaccinated on January 16 around 1 pm and was normal till Monday morning.
Close
Representational Image. (File photo)
Representational Image. (File photo)

China only major economy with positive GDP growth in 2020

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 10:02 AM IST
Data released by China’s National Bureau of Statistics put its GDP growth in the December quarter at 6.5%, catapulting its annual growth figure for 2020 to 2.3%
Close
Uttar Pradesh finance minister Suresh Khanna presents the state budget 2020-21 in the UP Legislative Assembly, in Lucknow on February 18, 2020. (PTI)
Uttar Pradesh finance minister Suresh Khanna presents the state budget 2020-21 in the UP Legislative Assembly, in Lucknow on February 18, 2020. (PTI)

UP govt to take a call on budget session soon

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 09:41 AM IST
The state budget session has to be convened by the third week of February to meet the constitutional requirement
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP