
Uttarakhand crisis: HC order adds to confusion on trust vote
The Uttarakhand high court order asking the deposed Harish Rawat government to seek a trust vote in the state assembly has left many unanswered questions.
Justice UC Dhyani — who fixed Thursday for the trust vote — allowed the nine rebel Congress MLAs disqualified by Speaker Govind Singh Kunjwal to take part in the proceedings. The HC also appointed a registrar as an observer.
The high court has not stayed the Presidential Proclamation. “There is no question of staying the effect of Proclamation under Article 356 of the Constitution of India at this stage,” Justice Dhayani said in his order.
While admitting that there was presumption of validity in favour of Presidential Proclamation and the scope for its judicial review was limited, the HC insisted it could pass an interim order in the facts and circumstances of the case.
But the court order has complicated the questions it intended to answer.
Read | Cong welcomes HC order on Uttarakhand trust vote, Centre to challenge
The imposition of President’s Rule has two immediate fallouts — the state government gets dismissed and the assembly is put under suspended animation.
By its own admission, the HC has not stayed President’s Rule. It means the assembly remains under suspended animation.
Can there be a trust vote without reviving the state assembly? The HC order does not give a clear answer to it.
Second, if President’s Rule has not been stayed, the Rawat government remains a dismissed government, which doesn’t legally exist. Then, how can a non-existent government seek a trust vote?
“The Assembly is in suspended animation. It has not been dissolved… Speaker continues to hold office. This court intends to pass an interim order without prejudice to rival contentions, but according to constitutional postulates. Floor test is the best test, as has been held by the Hon’ble Apex Court on a number of occasions…,” the HC said, adding it could not be a mute spectator till final disposal of the petition against President’s Rule.
The HC also allowed the nine rebel Congress MLAs disqualified by the Speaker to take part in the trust vote. “To give the floor test a semblance of neutrality, and without prejudice to the rival contentions, all the MLAs shall be entitled to take part in the floor test, with, without or despite their disqualification,” the HC said. It shall be subject to adjudication by a competent court, it added.
The HC has not stayed the Speaker’s order of disqualification. Technically, they continue to remain disqualified and their petition against disqualification is yet to be taken up. Can the disqualified MLAs be allowed to take part in the trust vote without the Speaker’s order being stayed?
If implemented, the HC order will create history of sorts. A dismissed government will face a trust vote in an assembly kept under suspended animation in which disqualified MLAs can take part. The order certainly calls for revision.

Cold wave claims lives of two nomad children in Kashmir
- The family of nomads had been living in a ramshackle shed covered with tarpaulin and polythene in a forest area of Devsar in Kulgam district.

Govt postpones 10th round of talks with farmers' leaders to Jan 20: Reports

Glitches in Co-WIN portal leads to drop in Covid vaccination percentage in Bihar
- Vaccination officers complained that the Co-WIN portal was slow in responding that made uploading information on it time consuming and tedious.

Stalin accuses AIADMK govt of putting on hold projects brought during DMK rule

14 people develop AEFI on second day of Covid-19 vaccination drive in Bengal
- The turnout rate dropped on Monday as Co-WIN glitches continued.

High level EC team on 3-day Assam visit to take stock of assembly polls
- The Election Commission team will hold meetings with the senior bureaucrats and police officers including state chief secretary and police chief to know about security arrangements.

Two Manipur journalists held for article, released after admitting to oversight
- The police claimed that the article openly endorsed revolutionary ideologies and activities.

Retired Odisha professor seeks to donate house for construction of police statio
- In a letter to CM's private secretary, he offered to donate his three-room newly constructed house in Balitutha village of coastal Jagatsinghpur district to Odisha police.

News updates from Hindustan Times: SC panel to begin work on farm laws on Jan 19

India, Japan sign pact to give skilled workers access to Japanese jobs
- Foreign secretary Harsh Shringla and Japan’s ambassador Satoshi Suzuki signed the memorandum of cooperation (MoC) on Monday.

Tandav makers say sorry after a torrent of criticism over web series
- The controversy around 'Tandav' has triggered demands that the government quickly enact a law to regulate content on OTT platforms such as Amazon Prime and Netflix.

SC panel on farm laws to begin work on January 19
- On January 12, after two days of deliberation, the Supreme Court had suspended the pro-reforms farm laws approved by Parliament in September.

3,81,305 beneficiaries received Covid-19 vaccine, says health ministry

Indian, French Rafale jets set to take part in war games in Rajasthan
- The exercise has been codenamed 'Desert Knight 21'.

Nitish Kumar says cabinet to be expanded soon
- Nitish Kumar had said earlier that the BJP was still to hand over the list of probable candidates to be included in the cabinet.