HT Image
HT Image

We can wok it out

It's no more an India vs China story. The two nations may end up as mirror images, writes Pramit Pal Chaudhuri.
By Pramit Pal Chaudhuri | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON FEB 18, 2008 07:28 PM IST

Billions of Entrepreneurs
Tarun Khanna
Penguin Viking* RS 595 * PP 353

Tarun Khanna became a chattering class celebrity in 2003 when he co-authored 'Can India overtake China?' In the article, he defied the general view that Beijing was light years ahead of New Delhi.

His argument: India had a potentially long-term advantage in the dynamism of its private entrepreneurs. The article and its responses led him to an "intellectual odyssey" whose final product is this hefty assessment of the manner India and China are transforming themselves.

However, Khanna no longer sees it as an India vs China story In his view, the real tale is that India and China are rising in two distinctly different ways, so different that they are almost "mirror images" of each other.

More optimistically, he sees in these dis ferences the origins of a bilateral relationship in which both sides are able to match one's strength with another's weakness.

He calls this "dance mutualism", after the partnership between two dancers "with a leader and follower alternating roles and both straining to hear music that is by turns tentative and vigorous."

Khanna's description of how the Asian giants decided to take separate paths to development and their consequences is not original. However, he spends more time and care than most in trying to explain the context that led each country to choose the path that they did.

From the beginning India and China, he argues, made "very different choices" when they were young modern States "based on deeply held beliefs about appropriate societal norms".

One resulting Indian strength lies in the free flow of information. The aggressive independence of Tehelka is contrasted with the only Chinese news agency, Xinhua, where party officials provide guidelines about coverage once a week.

The fallout is that corporations in China are dependent on guanxi, networks of relationships, for the kind of basic economic information that firms in India sometimes get in newspapers. This in turn lends itself to a fmancial system in India that is in many ways superior to the State-driven version of China.

It is not merely that capital is more efficiently allocated, but also that Indian firms are forced to be more transparent and better managed as they try to access that money.

A Chinese strength is the ability to build physical infrastructure. The very strength of civil society in India makes certain types of collective activity whether it's the building highways or new cities, prohibitively difficult.

China has a compensation system for people it displaces - though Khanna does a good job narrating how haphazardly it works - but ultimately what the government decides to build gets done. The Indian contrast is the mindless opposition that nearly emasculated the plans of the German retailer Metro in Bangalore or the painfully slow process by which farmers were persuaded to se11their land and pave the way for modern Gurgaon.

On the other hand, Beijing has been miles ahead of India in tapping foreign corporations for investment, technology and money It was quicker to the benefits of tapping overseas diaspora - in part because Maoist extremism had wiped out domestic entrepreneurs.

The Indian State remains "dysfunctional" and is a key reason for the continuing discrepancy in results between the two Asian countries. The Chinese government, in comparison, is a well-oiled machine because it sees helping business essential to its own survival.

Much of this is old hat for those who monitor the cottage industry of 'Chindia' literature. Khanna's strength is the sheer variety and extent of the anecdotes, quotes and examples he provides. K anything, a more disciplined structure would have been useful just to manage the wealth of material.

Having detailed how India and China are succeeding in their own way, Khanna argues that their respective troughs and crests make them a good match. Already Indian and Chinese firms are building those bridges. For example, China sucks in so much stone from India that most foreign stone agents in India are from the Middle Kingdom.

He also reminds us how India's greatest export to China Buddhism - followed early trade links. Curiously, he chooses to showcase how the two countries have sought to project their influence in Burma. While he details this less-than great game, it is not clear why this fits in with the book's primary theme.

Khanna also misses how important Burmese help against the Naga rebellion and unimportant oil and gas were to India's decision to turn its back on Aung San Suu Kyi.

He also repeats a common myth that India believes buying overseas oil and gas reserves is crucial to its energy security New Delhi is careful to insist such purchases are driven purely by profit motives - it provides no money or other subsidies for such assets.

This is a sprawling book about why these two countries are moving in the manner that they are and an important reminder how sophomoric are claims that one country has found a better way than the other.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
A medic collects a swab sample of a passenger for the Covid-19 test at a bus stand in Bengaluru.(PTI)
A medic collects a swab sample of a passenger for the Covid-19 test at a bus stand in Bengaluru.(PTI)

Central govt should cut its tax on fuel, says Tamil Nadu govt

PTI, Chennai
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 07:03 PM IST
Panneerselvam, pointing to accusations by the main opposition DMK over the interim budget (2021-22), said a flawed view, holding the state government responsible for the petrol and diesel price rise, was being propagated.
Close
BJP national president JP Nadda. (File photo)
BJP national president JP Nadda. (File photo)

Making PM Modi's schemes flourish will be real tribute to saint Ravidas: Nadda

ANI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:51 PM IST
He further said that while imbibing the life of Saint Ravidas, people can dedicate themselves to social work through the path shown by him.
Close
Police teams are trying to track down the Innova in which the driver of the parked vehicle with explosives -- a Scorpio SUV -- was seen leaving.(ANI Photo)
Police teams are trying to track down the Innova in which the driver of the parked vehicle with explosives -- a Scorpio SUV -- was seen leaving.(ANI Photo)

Explosives scare near Ambani's house: Cops looking for other car

PTI, Mumbai
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:38 PM IST
The Crime Branch of Mumbai police has recorded the statements of 25 persons in its probe so far, he said.
Close
Congress party workers greet Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot during his visit to Bikaner on Saturday,.(PTI)
Congress party workers greet Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot during his visit to Bikaner on Saturday,.(PTI)

Ashok Gehlot and Sachin Pilot attack Centre for 'stubborn stand' on farm laws

PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:37 PM IST
  • Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot and his former deputy Sachin Pilot tried to present a united face ahead of the assembly bypolls in four seats in the state.
Close
Punjab CM Captain Amarinder Singh chairing an All Party Meeting on the issue of Central Farmer Legislations and the way forward, at Punjab Bhawan in Chandigarh on Tuesday. (ANI Photo)
Punjab CM Captain Amarinder Singh chairing an All Party Meeting on the issue of Central Farmer Legislations and the way forward, at Punjab Bhawan in Chandigarh on Tuesday. (ANI Photo)

Amarinder Singh announces 50 lakh ex-gratia for kin of Punjab solider

ANI, Ludhiana
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:35 PM IST
The Junior Commissioned officer is survived by his father, wife and two sons aged 11 and 13 years.
Close
Cockfights are banned but still common in rural areas of Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Odisha states (AP Photo/Anupam Nath)(AP)
Cockfights are banned but still common in rural areas of Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Odisha states (AP Photo/Anupam Nath)(AP)

Rooster kills owner with cockfight blade in Telangana

AFP
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:28 PM IST
The bird had a knife attached to its leg ready to take on an opponent when it inflicted serious injuries to the man's groin as it tried to escape.
Close
Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal holds a roadshow in Shalimar Bagh area ahead of byelections in five wards of North MCD and East MCD in New Delhi on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)
Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal holds a roadshow in Shalimar Bagh area ahead of byelections in five wards of North MCD and East MCD in New Delhi on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)

Delhi Police Commissioner reviews law, order situation ahead of MCD by-polls

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:21 PM IST
Shrivastava directed police personnel to keep a sharp vigil on borders in view of elections and the ongoing farmers' protest.
Close
Odisha reported 86 new Covid-19 cases in 21 districts.(HT Photo)
Odisha reported 86 new Covid-19 cases in 21 districts.(HT Photo)

Odisha modifies home isolation order, logs 86 new Covid-19 cases

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:19 PM IST
The week-long home isolation will be mandatory for the people coming by train and flight from five high risk states like Maharashtra, Kerala, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.
Close
Maharashtra continues to report the highest daily new cases at 8,333. In picture - Covid-19 testing in Mumbai.(HT Photo)
Maharashtra continues to report the highest daily new cases at 8,333. In picture - Covid-19 testing in Mumbai.(HT Photo)

Covid-19 spike: What is restricted where in Maharashtra

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:16 PM IST
As of Friday evening, Maharashtra has a caseload of 2,138,154 Covid-19 cases. The death toll stood at 52,041.
Close
Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar greets Chief Justice of India Sharad Arvind Bobde; Union Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad is also present during the inaugural function of the Shatabdi Bhawan at High Court, in Patna.(ANI)
Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar greets Chief Justice of India Sharad Arvind Bobde; Union Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad is also present during the inaugural function of the Shatabdi Bhawan at High Court, in Patna.(ANI)

Comments against judges 'disturbing new trend': Law minister Ravi Shankar Prasad

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:10 PM IST
Prasad was addressing a function here organised to mark the inauguration of a new building of the Patna High Court by Chief Justice of India S A Bobde, in presence of Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, among others.
Close
Maharashtra continues to report the highest daily new cases at 8,333. In picture - Covid-19 testing in Mumbai.(HT Photo)
Maharashtra continues to report the highest daily new cases at 8,333. In picture - Covid-19 testing in Mumbai.(HT Photo)

Six states report surge in daily new Covid-19 cases: Government

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 06:05 PM IST
India's present active caseload now stands at 1.44 percent of the country's total positive cases.
Close
A health worker collects a swab sample for a Covid-19 test.(HT Photo/ Raj K Raj)
A health worker collects a swab sample for a Covid-19 test.(HT Photo/ Raj K Raj)

This is what one dose of Covid-19 vaccine will cost in Gujarat

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 05:59 PM IST
“The price of Covid-19 vaccine in Gujarat will be 250 in private hospitals and it will be provided free of cost in govt hospital across the state,” Patel was quoted as saying by news agency ANI.
Close
Bombay high court and all subordinate courts in Maharashtra, except Pune, had resumed in-person hearings in December after a gap of eight months.
Bombay high court and all subordinate courts in Maharashtra, except Pune, had resumed in-person hearings in December after a gap of eight months.

Bombay High Court refuses to hear case after lawyer removes mask in courtroom

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 05:48 PM IST
  • A single-judge bench of Justice Prithviraj Chavan was on February 22 hearing an appeal matter during which the appellant's advocate removed his mask in the courtroom contrary to guidelines.
Close
Varanasi: Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi speaks on the occasion of Ravidas Jayanti, at Sant Ravidas temple in Varanasi, Saturday, Feb. 27, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI02_27_2021_000135B)(PTI)
Varanasi: Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi speaks on the occasion of Ravidas Jayanti, at Sant Ravidas temple in Varanasi, Saturday, Feb. 27, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI02_27_2021_000135B)(PTI)

'True religion never divides': Priyanka Gandhi at Varanasi's Ravidas temple

Posted by Prashasti Singh | PTI, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 05:36 PM IST
This is the second time in the past two years when the Congress leader has visited the birth place of Sant Shiromani Guru Ravidasji, a Congress release issued in Lucknow said.
Close
The chief minister's tweet comes after a 17-year-old boy was beaten up and stabbed for allegedly opposing three boys who were stalking his sister.(HT photo)
The chief minister's tweet comes after a 17-year-old boy was beaten up and stabbed for allegedly opposing three boys who were stalking his sister.(HT photo)

Kejriwal says Delhi's law and order situation 'in serious turmoil'

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 05:43 PM IST
Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal on Saturday said in a tweet, "Deeply concerned by the murder of a 8-yr old girl in Khichdipur & attack on a 17-yr old boy in Kalkaji.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP