Water from India is a poll issue in these tea gardens along the Bhutan border

Published on May 10, 2018 01:47 PM IST
For most parts of the last century these gardens paid Bhutanese authorities for their water.
Residents of Carron tea estate in Bengal’s Jalpaiguri district bring water from a well in Nainital gewog in Samtse district of Bhutan.(Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)
Residents of Carron tea estate in Bengal’s Jalpaiguri district bring water from a well in Nainital gewog in Samtse district of Bhutan.(Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)
Hindustan Times | By, Kolkata

When, in February 2018, a letter from Samtse district authorities in Bhutan reached the office of Bandapani tea garden in Alipurduar district of West Bengal, the residents of tea estate sensed trouble. Addressed to the manager of the estate, the letter demanded water rent for 2016-17.

“The Dzongkhag administration of Samtse district would like to inform that your Company has not paid the water bund rate amounting to Nu 8,000 for the fiscal year 2016-17,” said the letter dated February 8, signed by Sonam Wangyel, the dzongda (administrator) of Samtse district.

Read: Ride to the Land of Thunder Dragons: Bhutan

For most parts of the past century Bandapani garden, along with some neighbouring ones, has been getting water supply from Bhutan because there was no facility for drinking water in India. Since 2006, rent has been Nu 8,000 (the current exchange rate is 1 INR = 0.9999 Nu).

The garden is closed since 2013 and managers and other senior officials left the estate. Workers raised a fund and paid for water till 2015-16. This time, they are no longer in a position to raise this money.

The struggle to get water is a daily routine in a picturesque land. (Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)
The struggle to get water is a daily routine in a picturesque land. (Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)

Bandapani is not the only garden that is dependent on water from the neighbouring country. Lankapara (about 7,000 voters), Makrapara (2,000) and Carron (3,500) along the border of India and Bhutan suffer the same fate. While Bandapani, Lankapara and Carron gardens are closed, Makrapara is running but with irregular salaries.

Read: Kangra’s cup of tea is losing its aroma

Despite the picturesque environs of the foothills of the Himalayas all around, life in these estates is tough. Women of these estates have to trudge six to eight km every day through undulating landscape to fetch water. There are no guards along the international border that is marked by cement posts.

“We have not responded to the letter, as the workers cannot pay the rent. We hope Bhutan will not disconnect the line out of sympathy,” said Surajman Tamang, who worked as an accountant and has not left the garden.

“Down the years we have highlighted the problem, but to no avail. The Left Front government did not address and the Trinamool Congress administration dug a few handpumps that are only 30-75 feet deep. We need deep tubewells that are 250-300 feet deep,” alleged Gopal Pradhan, leader of Dooars Cha Bagan Workers Union that is affiliated to United Trade Union Congress, the labour arm of RSP, a Left Front constituent.

Read: World Bank defends treatment of tea garden labourers in India amid fears of exploitation

“Even the water from Bhutan is not safe. It has a lot of iron and dolomite leading to frequent stomach ailments among the residents of the gardens,” said Pradhan.

A water reservoir in Bhutan from where water is supplied to Bandapani tea estate in Alipurduar in Bengal. (Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)
A water reservoir in Bhutan from where water is supplied to Bandapani tea estate in Alipurduar in Bengal. (Snigdhendu Bhattacharya)

In Bandapani, the pipeline that brings water from Bhutan is attached with a cement tank on a hill at Tindharey village near Gomtu town on the other side of the border. The tank is fed by spring water from the hills of Bhutan. The mouth of the pipeline is covered with a net to work as filter.

“The water from the handpumps that the local panchayat authorities have dug is red. It has excessive iron. It’s difficult to drink and even to use for cooking,” said Ashok Toppo, vice-president of a workers’ cooperative that is trying to run the garden in the absence of an owner.

Read: How a health crisis is brewing in Assam

Water connection to Carron was snapped by the authorities in Bhutan a few years ago following a dispute with the owners. Lankapara and Makrapara estates suffered the same fate.

“In Carron, some time ago public health and engineering department has installed taps to supply water. But the pipes did not reach all parts of the garden and the supply, 30-60 mins every day, was not only insufficient, but also erratic with no supply on some days,” said Jagannath Singh, a resident of Karri-Lines village in the northern-most part of the garden.

Amid the ironies, promises flow freely.

“The Left regime did nothing but we have expedited the process of installing pipelines. Supply will be regular soon,” said Mohan Sharma, the sabhadhipati (chairperson) of the Trinamool Congress-run Alipurduar zilla parishad.

“Fresh drinking water from India is the key demand of the residents in the coming rural elections,” said Biswanath Oraon, a Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) candidate for one of the two seats from Bandapani garden at the Bandapani gram panchayat.

Munsi Munda, the Trinamool Congress candidate and Ramesh Minz, the BJP candidate, for the same seat, echoed Oraon.

“We will solve the water supply problem in these areas on a priority basis,” said Pushma Mangar, a tea garden worker contesting on a BJP ticket for a panchayat samiti seat.

“All candidates have promised that they will ensure supply of drinking water from India,” said Aruna, Singh’s wife.

Till the promises don’t materialise, women of Carron must keep travelling to a stone-built well, fed by a spring, in Nainital gewog (block) of Samtse district, about 1.5 km away, twice a day.


    Snigdhendu Bhattacharya, principal correspondent, Hindustan Times, Kolkata, has been covering politics, socio-economic and cultural affairs for over 10 years. He takes special interest in monitoring developments related to Maoist insurgency and religious extremism.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Security beefed up outside Nitish Kumar's residence in Patna on Tuesday. (Santosh Kumar/HT Photo)

    RJD-JD(U) realignment: It began cooking after Nitish’s attendance at Tejashwi’s iftaar feast

    Nitish Kumar's decision as Bihar's chief minister to agree on holding a statewide caste census, as demanded by opposition RJD, and his attendance at an iftaar party hosted by leader of opposition Tejashwi Prasad Yadav on April 22 this year were the first signs of the realignment between JD(U) and RJD, which reached its logical end on Tuesday, according to political leaders privy to the development.

  • The state capital reported 124 new Covid cases on Tuesday (Pic for representation)

    943 fresh Covid cases, 2 deaths in U.P.

    LUCKNOW: The state capital reported 124 new Covid cases on Tuesday while in Uttar Pradesh, 943 fresh cases were reported. In Lucknow, Alambagh reported 14, Chinhat 12, Indira Nagar 12, NK Road 12, Aliganj 8 and BKT 3 fresh Covid cases. At present, there are 5633 active Covid cases in the state and most of them are in home isolation.

  • JDU leader Nitish Kumar waves to his supporters after meeting Bihar governor Phagu Chauhan to form a new government in Patna, Bihar, 

    Nitish Kumar met Bihar governor twice in 2 hours: How political drama unfolded

    JD(U) chief Nitish Kumar will take oath as chief minister of Bihar for the eighth time and his new ally Tejashwi Yadav of the RJD will be made deputy CM at the Raj Bhawan in Patna at 2 pm on Wednesday, news agency PTI reported. Kumar, who dumped the BJP-led NDA earlier in the day, will be heading a coalition of seven parties which is supported by an Independent.

  • The U.P. CM also greeted the people, saying that a series of festive occasions were lined up –Independence Day, Raksha Bandhan and Krishna Janmashtami. (Pic for representation)

    Yogi launches Tiranga Yatra, says ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’a mass movement now

    LUCKNOW: Chief minister Yogi Adityanath flagged off a bike rally to mark the launch of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party's two-day Tiranga Yatra across the state on Tuesday. Yogi, who flagged the yatra along with deputy chief minister Brajesh Pathak, former ministers Ashutosh Tandon and Mahendra Singh and various other party functionaries, tasked the cadres with ensuring that each house displayed the Tricolour.

  • The ATS ADG said the accused created a fake e-mail ID and Facebook account using RSS name to target RSS volunteers (Pic for representation)

    Terror plot foiled: ATS nabs suspected ISIS operative in Azamgarh

    LUCKNOW Ahead of Independence Day, the UP Anti-Terrorism Squad on Tuesday claimed to have foiled a terror plot to target Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh workers, after the arrest of an alleged ISIS operative, Sabauddin Azmi, from UP's Azamgarh district. Sharing a press note, ATS officials claimed that Sabauddin Azmi was in touch with ISIS recruiters Abu Umar and Abu Bakar Al-Shami through phone and instant messaging applications.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, August 09, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now