Republic Tv Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami after being released from Taloja Central Prison in 2018 Suicide abetment case at Kharghar in Navi Mumbai.(Bachchan Kumar/ HT PHOTO)
Republic Tv Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami after being released from Taloja Central Prison in 2018 Suicide abetment case at Kharghar in Navi Mumbai.(Bachchan Kumar/ HT PHOTO)

SC grants bail to Arnab amidconcerns over prompt hearing

The court ordered the release of Goswami and two others in an abetment to suicide case dating back to May 2018, allowing the accused to be released from jail, on execution of personal bond of Rs 50,000.
By Abraham Thomas | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON NOV 12, 2020 01:37 AM IST

The Supreme Court on Wednesday ordered the release of Republic TV editor-in-chief Arnab Goswami in a judgement that sought to protect the liberty of individuals, although both the promptness with which it heard the case, and the judgement itself came in for criticism.

The court ordered the release of Goswami and two others in an abetment to suicide case dating back to May 2018, allowing the accused to be released from jail on execution of personal bond of Rs 50,000.

The order came on separate appeals filed by the three accused against a Bombay high court order of November 9 refusing them interim bail.

Watch: Arnab Goswami leaves from jail after getting bail from Supreme Court

Goswami was lodged at Taloja prison in Navi Mumbai after his arrest on November 4.

The trio are accused in an abetment to suicide case filed in May 2018 by the wife of architect Anvay Naik who died by suicide that year and left a suicide note naming Goswami, Niteesh Sarda, and Farooq Sheikh, whose companies owed him money for services rendered.

The apex bench said in its short order (following a long hearing): “We are of the view that the high court was in error of rejecting the application for grant of interim bail.”

“We accordingly order and direct that Arnab Manoranjan Goswami, Feroz Mohammad Shaikh and Neetish Sarda shall be released on interim bail, subject to each of them executing a personal bond in the amount of Rs 50,000 to be executed before the Jail Superintendent. They are, however, directed to cooperate in the investigation and shall not make any attempt to interfere with the ongoing investigation or with the witnesses,” the court said.

Senior advocate Harish Salve appearing for Goswami sought to paint a picture that his client was being targeted by the state .

The bench of justices DY Chandrachud and Indira Banerjee were of the view that a person, whosoever it be, cannot be targeted by state and that constitutional courts are duty-bound to protect the liberty of citizens.

“We are dealing with a person’s liberty. Across the country, if this court is not to interfere today, we are treading on a path of destruction of liberty....you may dislike a person’s ideology and challenge it but if this is what our States will do to nail persons, we have to put across this message to all high courts to preserve the liberty of citizens,” the bench said. The top court noted with anguish that in case after case coming before them, high courts are not exercising their jurisdiction.

However, activists and lawyers said the same benchmark isn’t being applied to other cases.

Advocate Sunil Fernandes said, “Very recently on October 29, the Supreme Court refused to grant interim bail on medical grounds to 81-year old Telugu poet and writer Varavara Rao, who is an accused in the Elgar Parishad case. Repeated bail pleas filed by him over the past 22 months have not resulted in any positive order from either the Bombay high court or the Supreme Court. Similar is the situation with regard to social activist Sudha Bhardwaj, another co-accused in the same case who is in jail since August 28, 2018.”

Congress leader Milind Deora tweeted, “Henceforth, I hope the principle that bail is the rule & jail an exception applies to media trials & all urgent pleas — regardless of the accused’s background or profile,”

Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) president Mehbooba Mufti said while she agrees with the Supreme Court’s views on right to liberty, it has been selective when it comes to Kashmiris. “Agree with SCs outrage on right to liberty. But sadly this outrage has been selective as there are hundreds of Kashmiris & journalists languishing in jails on baseless charges. Forget court ruling they didn’t even get a hearing. Why no sense of urgency for their liberty?” Mufti wrote on Twitter.

The prompt listing of the case, filed on Tuesday, also came in for criticism with Dushyant Dave, the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) president, writing to secretary general of the top court lodging a “strong protest” on “selective listing” of Goswami’s interim bail plea.

“While thousands of citizens remain in jails, languishing for long periods while their matters filed before the Supreme Court are not getting listed for weeks and months, it is, to say the least, deeply disturbing as to how and why every time Goswami approaches the Supreme Court, his matter gets listed instantly,” Dave wrote on Tuesday.

During Wednesday’s hearing, the bench also commented on the first information report (FIR) involved in the case, which, some experts said, weakens it (the FIR) .

The court said, “in a matter of this nature where some amount is already paid and the person commits suicide due to financial stress will you hold the head of the company for abetment to suicide. In most companies work orders are given out as a labour contract... Will it not be travesty of justice to deny bail to such a person when his quashing petition is pending?”

The court observed that the Bombay high court gave no findings on whether prima facie offence was made out .

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the Maharashtra government, pointed out that the investigation of the case is not before this bench, and that the Bombay high court order of November 9 allowed the accused to approach trial judge for bail which is to be heard on November 12.

Sibal said: “In 99 out of 100 cases concerning personal liberty, I am on the other side.”

Justice Chandrachud said: “All the more reason that what we do today will define what we will do in those 99 cases.”

However, Sibal also added: “A Kerala journalist was arrested by Uttar Pradesh Police when he was going to Hathras to report. We came to this court under Article 32. The court said go to lower court. Petition posted after four weeks. Such things are also happening.”

His reference was to Siddique Kappan, who was arrested on his way to Hathras to meet the family of the 19-year-old Dalit woman who died after being allegedly gang-raped in the district..The UP Police had arrested Kappan along with three others,claiming that they had links with Popular Front of India and its affiliate in Mathura.

Appearing for Maharashtra Police and the investigating officer, senior advocate Amit Desai argued that the high court could not be blamed for not granting bail as it was hearing a habeas corpus petition.

The HC noted that remedy of bail will be taken up by sessions judge on November 12 while posting the prayer for quashing FIR for consideration on December 10.

The other accused represented by senior advocates Mukul Rohatgi and Gopal Shankarnarayanan argued that the three persons named in the suicide note are unconnected and if this is the standard adopted, heads of all companies, even ministers will be in jail if employees and government servants die by suicide due to unpaid dues.

Goswami on Wednesday evening walked out the Taloja jail in adjoining Raigad district, hours after the Supreme Court granted him interim bail.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
People celebrate the gram panchayat election results in Bhiwand, on Monday, January 18, 2021. (Praful Gangurde/HT Photo)
People celebrate the gram panchayat election results in Bhiwand, on Monday, January 18, 2021. (Praful Gangurde/HT Photo)

Maharashtra gram panchayat polls: BJP, Congress, Shiv Sena, NCP claim victory

By Surendra P Gangan and Pradip Kumar Maitra, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:44 AM IST
Amid claims of victory by all four key parties in Maharashtra, partners in the ruling Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi – Shiv Sena, Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) and Congress – won 58% of the 12,711 gram panchayats that went to polls on January 15
Close
As per data shared by the education department, 50 students scoring 90% and above were admitted in the first phase that concluded last week. (HT Photo)
As per data shared by the education department, 50 students scoring 90% and above were admitted in the first phase that concluded last week. (HT Photo)

Mumbai: Over 800 students with 80% and above secure FYJC seats after five admission rounds

By Ankita Bhatkhande, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:39 AM IST
More than 800 students who secured 80% and above in their SSC board (Class 10) exams in 2020 secured admissions to junior colleges in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) under the ongoing first-come, first0served (FCFS) rounds
Close
State industry minister Dilip Walse-Patil on Monday rejected the company’s closure application. (HT FILE)
State industry minister Dilip Walse-Patil on Monday rejected the company’s closure application. (HT FILE)

Maharashtra govt rejects General Motors’ plea to close Talegaon plant

By Kanchan Chaudhari, Mumbai
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:35 AM IST
The employees’ union had contended that the Talegaon plant was sold by the company to Great Wall Motors (GWM), a Chinese auto giant, but a closure application was filed with the state government to get rid of the employees working at the plant
Close
Metro-4 work at Ghodbunder Road in Thane. (Praful Gangurde/HT Photo)
Metro-4 work at Ghodbunder Road in Thane. (Praful Gangurde/HT Photo)

Mumbai Metro-4 coaches: Bombardier lowest bidder, Chinese manufacturer ‘non-responsive’

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:31 AM IST
Canadian company Bombardier has emerged as the lowest bidder for manufacturing 234 coaches for the Metro-4 (Wadala-Thane-Kasarvadavli) and its extension line 4A (Kasarvadavli-Gaimukh)
Close
Kangana Ranaut had filed a petition seeking quashing of a sedition case filed against her and her sister by Bandra Police on an order by the magistrate. (ANI)
Kangana Ranaut had filed a petition seeking quashing of a sedition case filed against her and her sister by Bandra Police on an order by the magistrate. (ANI)

Application seeking action for contempt against Kangana Ranaut filed in Bombay HC

By HT Correspondent, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:28 AM IST
An interim application has been filed in the Bombay high court (HC), seeking initiation of contempt proceedings against actor Kangana Ranaut for lowering the dignity of the court by tweeting and posting a video of her visit to Bandra police station on January 8
Close
On January 15, the university’s Fort campus witnessed high-power drama as Ramdas Atram was not allowed to take his post by vice-chancellor Suhas Pednekar. (Hindustan Times)
On January 15, the university’s Fort campus witnessed high-power drama as Ramdas Atram was not allowed to take his post by vice-chancellor Suhas Pednekar. (Hindustan Times)

Senate member files petition against new University of Mumbai registrar

By HT Correspondent, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:25 AM IST
Days after the new registrar took charge at the University of Mumbai (MU) amidst protests from several university officials including the vice-chancellor, a senate member on Monday moved the Bombay high court (HC) against the government appointment
Close
A health worker takes a selfie while receiving the Covid-19 vaccine at KEM Hospital in Mumbai. (HT File Photo)
A health worker takes a selfie while receiving the Covid-19 vaccine at KEM Hospital in Mumbai. (HT File Photo)

Mumbai civic body to restart vaccination drive from Tuesday

By Mehul R Thakkar, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:24 AM IST
While the civic body claimed the application is now functional and they are undertaking tests by sending text messages to vaccine beneficiaries, it plans to conduct the vaccination drive only four days a week — Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday.
Close
(Representative image) The demolition drive is part of ongoing efforts to curb emissions from Kalbadevi processing unit chimneys. (Biplov Bhuyan/HT PHOTO)
(Representative image) The demolition drive is part of ongoing efforts to curb emissions from Kalbadevi processing unit chimneys. (Biplov Bhuyan/HT PHOTO)

BMC demolishes chimneys of Kalbadevi gold processing units after complaints of pollution

By Priyanka Sahoo, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:21 AM IST
Around 40 chimneys at gold processing units in Kalbadevi have been demolished by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) in the past month following complaints of pollution from residents in the area
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Mumbai EOW registers FIR against Telugu channel for causing loss to actor-producer

By Vijay Kumar Yadav, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:19 AM IST
The economic offences wing (EOW) of the Mumbai Police has registered a first information report (FIR) against a Telugu broadcaster following a complaint lodged by actor-producer Deepti Bhatnagar alleging violation of her copyrights by illegally broadcasting her show Yatra.
Close
The state has set a target of inoculating around 28,500 health workers in a day (four days a week) at 258 centres across the state, officials said.
The state has set a target of inoculating around 28,500 health workers in a day (four days a week) at 258 centres across the state, officials said.

Maharashtra vaccine drive to resume today at 258 centres

By Faisal Malik, Mumbai
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 05:31 AM IST
The announcement was made after the CM reviewed the preparations for the drive at a meeting held with state chief secretary Sanjay Kumar, CM’s principal adviser Ajoy Mehta, principal secretary to public health minister Dr Pradeep Vyas and other officials on Monday.
Close
A medic administers a dose of Covishield vaccine to a health worker at BYL Nair Hospital in Mumbai. (HT FILE)
A medic administers a dose of Covishield vaccine to a health worker at BYL Nair Hospital in Mumbai. (HT FILE)

Two mild cases of AEFI reported in Mumbai after Covid-19 vaccination

By Rupsa Chakraborty, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:15 AM IST
Two mild adverse events following immunisation (AEFI) have been reported in Mumbai after taking Covishield vaccine on Saturday, first day of the nationwide mass inoculation programme. Both the healthcare workers have been kept under observation in hospitals. As per doctors, they are stable and will soon be discharged.
Close
The Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government on January 6 formed a nine-member committee under state chief secretary Sanjay Kumar to look at alternate plots for building the car shed for Metro-3 and Metro-6. (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO)
The Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government on January 6 formed a nine-member committee under state chief secretary Sanjay Kumar to look at alternate plots for building the car shed for Metro-3 and Metro-6. (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO)

Maharashtra government-appointed panel appointed to suggest alternate Metro car shed visits Aarey and Kanjurmarg

PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:15 AM IST
The nine-member committee appointed by the Maharashtra government to take a call on the Metro-3 (Colaba-Bandra-Seepz) and Metro-6 (Swami Samarth Nagar-Vikhroli) car shed, on Monday visited the Aarey and Kanjurmarg plots to look at the proposed sites
Close
For representational purpose only. (HT FILE)
For representational purpose only. (HT FILE)

Mumbai: Oshiwara police arrests two rape accused

By HT Correspondent, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:11 AM IST
The two accused, who were absconding, were arrested from their respective villages in Haryana and Rajasthan.
Close
Aaditya Thackeray proposed the cycle track and has asked the civic administration to check the feasibility of this project. (Pratik Chorge/HT Photo)
Aaditya Thackeray proposed the cycle track and has asked the civic administration to check the feasibility of this project. (Pratik Chorge/HT Photo)

Mumbai civic body plans 5-km cycle track between Mahim fort and Bandra fort

By HT Correspondent, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:11 AM IST
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) is planning to construct a cycle track along the beach between Mahim and Bandra forts, spanning 5km
Close
The increase in fuel prices is due to an increase in the cost of crude oil throughout last week. (REUTERS)
The increase in fuel prices is due to an increase in the cost of crude oil throughout last week. (REUTERS)

Petrol rises to 91.56/L, diesel to 81.87 as fuel prices continue to soar in Mumbai

By Aroosa Ahmed, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 01:08 AM IST
Fuel prices in Mumbai reached an all-time high on Monday
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP