Monday Musings: What would it feel like without arms and legs?

Updated on May 27, 2019 04:20 PM IST
Now that Aditya has been rendered limbless for the rest of his life, what kind of compensation should he be entitled to? How many crore rupees should he get to cover medical expenses, cost of rehabilitation, trauma, and the loss of income for the rest of his life?
Aditya Gaikwad was playing at the terrace of the building located near the transformer when he suffered severe electric shock on April 18. He was visiting his relative’s house in Ambegaon Khurd. Doctors had to amputate all limbs of the three-and-a-half-year-old-boy.(HT/PHOTO)
Aditya Gaikwad was playing at the terrace of the building located near the transformer when he suffered severe electric shock on April 18. He was visiting his relative’s house in Ambegaon Khurd. Doctors had to amputate all limbs of the three-and-a-half-year-old-boy.(HT/PHOTO)
Hindustan Times, Pune | ByAbhay Vaidya

It is now about a month that a three-and-half year old child had his arms and legs amputated for no fault of his.

Till April 18, Aditya Gaikwad, was like any other child his age; running around, playing and doing all the things that three-year-olds do. Disaster struck on April 18 when his parents took him on a visit to a relative’s house in Katraj and the child went about exploring the terrace. He was apparently playing with an iron rod which came in contact with an electric transformer belonging to the MSEDCL (Maharashtra State Electric Distribution Company Ltd), located barely three metres from the terrace wall.

So horrific was the high voltage current, that, about a week later, doctors at the Sassoon General Hospital had no choice but to amputate his arms and legs to save his life.

Aditya’s father, a tailor, has been dumbstruck with the bolt that has struck him from the blue. What kind of a future can this little boy look forward to? How are his poor parents going to fend for him for the rest of their lives? Can you imagine how helpless and meaningless life can be without arms and legs?

This extraordinarily tragic case is certainly not the first of its kind in our country, and also not the last, given the callous disregard we Indians have for safety. Just last week, 22 students lost their lives when a fire broke out in a Surat building where the top two floors had been allegedly illegally constructed.

In Aditya’s case, the process of law moved in the usual manner: After preliminary investigations cases were booked against the MSEDCL and the house owner on charges of illegal construction as the terrace wall was extremely close to the transformer.

Aditya’s father said that the MSEDCL paid him Rs 20,000 for the “initial medical expenses”. MSEDCL also blamed the entire accident on the house-owner for alleged illegal extensions.

A number of points demand close scrutiny in this case: Can the MSEDCL shrug off its responsibility by blaming the house owner for this tragedy? Is it not the responsibility of the state power distribution company to barricade its transformers for the highest level of safety, especially in densely populated areas as was the case in the present instance?

Is it not the responsibility of the MSEDCL to take immediate action against any illegal construction around its transformers which could lead to a major disaster as happened on April 18?

Now that Aditya has been rendered limbless for the rest of his life, what kind of compensation should he be entitled to? How many crore rupees should he get so that his medical expenses, cost of rehabilitation, extreme trauma, and the loss of the income for the rest of his life is covered?

Had India been a liberal democracy with strong institutions as in the West, Aditya would most certainly have been awarded compensation that would have run into millions of dollars. The power distribution company, too, would have been fined heavily for its negligence.

The sad reality is that India’s law and order mechanism - its judiciary and the police system - are woefully inadequate to do justice to the people. This is what needs to change and change on a note of urgency.

Aditya’s case needs to be taken up by a learned lawyer, knocking the doors of the Supreme Court for justice. In the least, students of law from the best law colleges in the city should take up the case and pursue it to its logical end.

abhay.vaidya@hindustantimes. com

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The village secretary posted at Charkhi Dadri’s Badhra was arrested from his residence in Kalanaur in Rohtak. Badhra DSP Desraj said they have arrested the accused from Kalanaur and produced him before a local court, which granted him three-day police remand. (HT Photo/ Representational image)

    Village secretary arrested for 99 lakh fraud in Charkhi Dadri

    The police on Wednesday arrested a village secretary posted at Charkhi Dadri's Badhra for allegedly withdrawing Rs 99 lakh from the account of 14 village panchayats of Badhra block by forging signatures. The village secretary, Mukesh, was arrested from his residence in Kalanaur in Rohtak. Badhra DSP Desraj said they have arrested the accused from Kalanaur and produced him before a local court, which granted him three-day police remand.

  • Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) leader Bikram Singh Majithia waves to the crowd as he comes out of the jail after Punjab and Haryana High Court granting bail to him in connection with a case registered against him under the NDPS Act in December 2021, in Patiala on Wednesday. (Rajesh Sachar)

    Those who conspired against me have no political standing now, says Bikram Majithia after release in drug case

    Taking a dig at former Punjab chief minister Charanjit Singh Channi, and former Shiromani Akali Dal leader Bikram Singh Majithia, state Congress president Navjot Singh Sidhu, after coming out of Patiala Jail, said that those who unleashed vendetta against him are now the “biggest losers and have no political standing”. He said, “The court order has failed all conspiracies against me by Channi, Sidhu, ADGP Harpreet Sidhu and others.”

  • Haryana Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar during the monsoon session of the Haryana Vidhan Sabha in Chandigarh on Wednesday. The SC ruling on the restoration of village common land resonated in the assembly. (Keshav Singh/ HT)

    SC ruling on restoration of village common land: Hooda presses for review plea in apex court, Khattar says examining issue

    The issue of the restoration of wrongly partitioned and alienated thousands of acres of shamilat deh (village land reserved and used for a common purpose) to gram panchayats in Haryana following a landmark April 7 Supreme Court judgment resonated in the state assembly on Wednesday with the Leader of Opposition, Bhupinder Singh Hooda demanding that the state government should file a review petition in the apex court.

  • A 30-year-old woman, a resident of Ferozepur, filed a complaint against the major, who hails from Ludhiana, in the in the court of judicial magistrate first class Balwinder Kaur Dhaliwal saying she had become acquainted with the major in 2016 when he was posted in the district. (HT PHOTO)

    Rape on pretext of marriage: Ferozepur court orders framing of charges against army major

    An army major was booked for raping a woman on pretext of marriage on the orders of a local court on Tuesday night. A 30-year-old woman, a resident of Ferozepur, filed a complaint against the major, who hails from Ludhiana, in the in the court of judicial magistrate first class Balwinder Kaur Dhaliwal saying she had become acquainted with the major in 2016 when he was posted in the district.

  • The administration has designated all government schools across the district as authorised points for the sale of national flags under the Har Ghar Tiranga campaign, and allegedly assigned them a target to sell at least 50 flags that are priced at <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>25 each (HT PHOTO)

    Sangrur govt schools directed to sell flags, teachers oppose move

    The administration has designated all government schools across the district as authorised points for the sale of national flags under the Har Ghar Tiranga campaign, and allegedly assigned them a target to sell at least 50 flags that are priced at ₹25 each. Teachers' unions have also met district education officers and demanded that the assignment be withdrawn.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now