E-Paper
The reason Guardians started Austin Hedges instead of Bo Naylor in Game 1
Hedges, batting .161 this season, starts Game 1 over Naylor as Guardians prioritize defense and leadership against Detroit’s ace.
The Cleveland Guardians surprised several fans with their lineup card on Tuesday night. When they opened their postseason Wild Card game series against the Detroit Tigers, it was not Bo Naylor behind the plate. Instead, manager Stephen Vogt deployed veteran Austin Hedges as the starting catcher, hitting ninth.
Why Hedges got the call
The decision was not about ignoring Naylor’s recent form. It came down to matchups and experience. Naylor, a left-handed hitter, would have faced a tough test against Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, one of the best lefties in baseball this season, according to The Sporting News. Vogt opted to play the percentages and went ahead with Hedges, who bats from the right side.
Beyond his handedness, the Guardians value what Hedges brings to the team in other ways. He is considered one of the team’s strongest clubhouse leaders and a steadying presence for a young pitching staff. His defensive reputation also helps, particularly in a game where run prevention matters as much as offense.
Also Read: MLB approves ball-strike challenge system for next season
Hedges’ offensive struggles
Hedges has had a difficult season at the plate, with a batting average of just .161. He is not expected to provide much in the batting order, and putting him in the lineup meant the Guardians gave up some offense in a game where runs might come at a premium.
Naylor likely to appear later
Still, Vogt left the door open for Naylor to impact the game. If the Guardians can push Skubal out, Naylor would be an option off the bench as a pinch-hitter. That late substitution could give Cleveland a better chance to generate runs against Detroit’s bullpen.
It is the classic postseason dilemma. Defense and leadership versus upside at the plate. Vogt chose the steady hand in Hedges for Game 1, with Naylor waiting in reserve. That choice may shape how the rest of the series plays out.
Also Read: Former MLB All-Star Garrett Cooper announces retirement after 8 ‘unforgettable years in Big Leagues’
FAQs
Why did the Guardians start Austin Hedges instead of Bo Naylor in Game 1?
Manager Stephen Vogt went with Hedges because of the lefty-on-lefty matchup against Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, and for Hedges’ leadership and defensive skills.
What has been Austin Hedges’ batting average this season?
Hedges has struggled at the plate, hitting .161 during the regular season.
Is Bo Naylor expected to play in the series?
Yes. Vogt could turn to Naylor as a pinch-hitter once Skubal is out of the matchup.
