How Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube are struggling to keep Taliban at bay

Although Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube are reportedly taking a no-consideration policy when it comes to Taliban-related content on their respective platforms, some confusion has been reported among the companies on how to handle the insurgents.
A Taliban fighter holding an M16 assault rifle stands outside the Interior Ministry in Kabul, Afghanistan, on August 16, 2021. (File Photo)
A Taliban fighter holding an M16 assault rifle stands outside the Interior Ministry in Kabul, Afghanistan, on August 16, 2021. (File Photo)
Updated on Aug 19, 2021 07:37 AM IST
Copy Link
Written by Joydeep Bose | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi

Silicon Valley has a tough job at hand. For the first time in over two decades, social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube have to come up with ways to balance a response against the Taliban, a conservative terrorist-affiliated group now in control of the state apparatus in Afghanistan. With the terrorist-affiliated group now on the way to govern an entire country, the social media companies grapple with a set of tough questions - should they maintain their user policies to reflect a strict stance against the insurgents, or enable the Taliban regime to operate on social media as any other internationally-recognised government?

For the most part, the social media platforms seem to be taking the no-consideration policy. So far, Facebook and YouTube have said that the Taliban are banned from their platforms, according to US sanctions policies. On the other hand, Twitter has not banned the Taliban yet but is reportedly cracking down on individual pieces of violent content.

YouTube, the online video-sharing and social media platform owned by Google, also said that it will terminate Taliban accounts.

However, some confusion has been reported among the social media platforms on how to handle the Taliban. Although Facebook claims that its ban on the Taliban has been in place "for years" under its "dangerous organisations" policy, it appears that the social media giant only deactivated certain Taliban accounts after facing a set of questions from the New York Times, according to a tweet by Sheera Frenkel, a reporter for the news organisation.

Moreover, Facebook's purported action against Taliban accounts does not seem to have translated across other platforms owned by the company. Facebook-owned instant messaging service WhatsApp said that it will take action against sanctioned people or organisations using the app, but that would involve identifying who uses the app in the first place. A statement by a company spokesperson indicated that WhatsApp has not taken any action against some accounts spreading Taliban propaganda since the platform uses end-to-end encryption for its messages.

However, Facebook later said that it would be blocking Taliban accounts on WhatsApp eventually, since it considers the group to be a terrorist organisation. For this purpose, the platform will be taking the help of Afghanistan experts, native Dari, and Pashto speakers with knowledge of the local context, to help guide policy.

According to a news report by Politico, the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism -- an industry group launched by Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Microsoft to “to prevent terrorists and violent extremists from exploiting digital platforms” -- has not taken an official position on how to address the Taliban regime's communications on social media, leaving the decision to the individual platforms instead.

"They (the companies) are struggling a bit," the political journalism company quotes an official at Access Now, a global digital rights advocacy group, as saying. "I don't think people were fully ready for this to happen in Afghanistan. So what's happening is that much more work is having to be done every hour on this.”

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Community members gather to look at a tree that was destroyed during a major storm in Ottawa, Canada.

    Thunderstorm in Canada leaves eight people dead, utilities face power outages

    Quebec and Ontario power utilities are working to restore services to around 900,000 customers facing outages after thunderstorms caused severe damage and left eight people dead. A very strong line of thunderstorms developed near Sarnia, close to the border with Port Huron, Michigan, late Saturday morning and tracked northeastward over Southern Ontario. The dead toll rose to eight, the CTV News television channel said on its website Sunday citing police reports.

  • Anthony Albanese (Reuters)

    Australia swears in new Labor PM ahead of Quad meeting

    Australia's Labor Party leader Anthony Albanese will be sworn in as the country's new prime minister on Monday as he promised a "journey of change" vowing to tackle climate change and rising living costs. Albanese and Penny Wong in foreign affairs then head to Japan later on Monday to attend a key meeting of the "Quad" security grouping in Tokyo. Some predicted Labor might get enough seats to govern on their own.

  • Severed head of missing Nigerian lawmaker found in park: Police (Representational image)

    Severed head of missing Nigerian lawmaker found in park: Police

    Police in Nigeria have discovered the severed head of a state legislator who went missing last week in the southeastern state of Anambra, where the government accuses separatists of carrying out a spate of killings and kidnappings, police said on Sunday. The southeast, homeland of the Igbo ethnic group, is agitating to secede from the rest of Nigeria and the banned Indigenous People of Biafra group has been leading those calls.

  • Canadian Pacific freight train derails in Alberta, no injuries reported | Representational image

    Canadian Pacific freight train derails in Alberta, no injuries reported

    A Canadian Pacific Railway freight train carrying potash derailed east of Fort Macleod in southern Alberta on Sunday morning, the company said. There were no injuries reported and there are no public safety concerns, CP Rail said. The cause of the derailment in the western Canadian province is under investigation, the company said. "CP personnel have responded to the scene and recovery operations are under way," the company said in a statement.

  • Ukraine parliament (Ukrainian Presidential Press Office via AP)

    Ukraine parliament bans Russian war symbols

    Ukraine's parliament on Sunday banned the symbols "Z" and "V", used by Russia's military to promote its war in Ukraine but agreed to President Volodymyr Zelenskiy's call to allow their use for educational or historic purposes. An opposition member, Yaroslav Zheleznyak, announced the decision on the Telegram messaging app, saying 313 deputies had voted in favour in the 423-member Verkhovna Rada assembly.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, May 23, 2022