Nepal earthquake: Indian media faces complaints about 'insensitivity'

Updated on May 04, 2015 02:28 AM IST
Just days after India earned widespread praise for mounting the largest relief mission in earthquake-hit Nepal, the Indian media faced brickbats from the Nepalese on Sunday for its coverage of the disaster and its aftermath.
Desperate-scenes-in-Kathmandu-as-people-dig-through-rubble-looking-for-survivors-after-huge-earthquake-hits-Nepal-AFP-Photo
Desperate-scenes-in-Kathmandu-as-people-dig-through-rubble-looking-for-survivors-after-huge-earthquake-hits-Nepal-AFP-Photo
Hindustan Times | By, Kathmandu

Indian media’s alleged insensitive and biased coverage of Nepal earthquake has come in for severe criticism, with #GoHomeIndianMedia hashtag trending on Twitter through Sunday.

India was the first country to rush aid to Nepal after a 7.9-magnitude quake on April 25 left more than 7,200 people dead and a trail of destruction.

While rescue effort has been praised, media’s wall-to-wall coverage of the calamity and that of the relief operation seem to have left a bitter aftertaste among Nepalis.

People in Nepal took to social media in droves to complain about what they described as the Indian media’s “insensitive” reportage on the April 25 temblor that killed more than 7,000, devastated infrastructure across the country and left tens of thousands displaced.

More than 128,000 tweets on Sunday complained about and debated Indian press’s handling of Nepal’s worst quake in 80 years that has flattened large parts of this impoverished country and left hundreds of thousands homeless.

The development coincided with the observance of the World Press Freedom Day.

Hundreds of Indian mediapersons have been reporting about the tragedy the extent of which is still not known. The criticism on social media will not be music to the ears of them.

Many contended the Indian media was treating its coverage of the quake and its victims as a public relations exercise on behalf of the government in Delhi.

"Some Nepalis, not all, feel Indian media is a bit patronising in their attitude and that is perhaps why such sentiments are being expressed. That is how a section of Nepali media also feels," said Kunda Dixit, a veteran journalist and editor of Nepali Times.

There is a feeling among Nepalese that the Indian media is only highlighting the plight of Indians in Nepal and rescue efforts by teams from the Indian military and the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF).

Twitterati accused the Indian media of being insensitive to survivors, asking them irrelevant questions such as "How are you feeling?" and not helping those needing immediate medical aid. Many tweets reminded the Indian media that Nepal is a sovereign country and not a “satellite state”.


Dear

@narendramodi

Our Dharahara have been fallen not our sovereignty! Sincerely Nepalese

#GoHomeIndianMedia

In a blog written for CNN, Sunita Shakya, a non-resident Nepalese, thanked India from the “bottom of my heart” for the help it has provided but asked the media to be more sensitive.

“However, me being a Nepali outside from my motherland, when (I) saw your news and news reports, my heart cried and hurt more than those destruction caused by (the) earthquake. Like all the medical personnel are taught and trained for potential disasters in future, as a reporter, I hope there is some kind of training on how to report different events. Your media and media personnel are acting like they are shooting some kind of family serials. If your media person can reach to the places where the relief supplies have not reached, at this time of crisis can’t they take a first-aid kit or some food supplies with them as well?” she wrote.

Ajay Bhadra Khanal, a former editor of The Himalayan Times, said: "The Indian media's aggressive presence and the way they are highlighting only their government's role in rescue and relief efforts has affected the perception among Nepalis of the Indian government.”

Dixit noted that hordes of journalists who came to Nepal from across the world were highlighting the efforts of their own countries but not many Nepalese have an idea of their coverage since only Indian publications and TV channels are available in the country.

"For every negative tweet, there are 10 positive reactions about India's efforts in Nepal. We shouldn't read much into it," he said.

Besides rescue teams and tons of equipment, medical aid, food, water and blankets, Indian military helicopters and planes flew in 23 media personnel to Nepal.

There have been reports in the Nepali media about Indian helicopters and rescue teams not coordinating with Nepali counterparts and flying to places close to the Chinese border. The Nepal Army has clarified this was a mistake and happened because the Indian pilots were not familiar with the terrain.

On Sunday, Indian ambassador Ranjit Rae wrote a piece in Kantipur, Nepal's highest circulated daily, requesting the Nepalese not to doubt New Delhi's intentions in helping its neighbour in distress.

"India doesn't want to do politics in Nepal nor has it done anything of that sort. Such negative reactions at this time affects the morale of those who are working and it is better these rumours are not spread," he wrote.

Read:

Nepal earthquake: This 101-yr-old man survived a week by eating flour

Bodies of foreigners among 51 found in quake-hit Nepal trekking region

Public anger is growing in Kathmandu and there's a risk it will boil over

Killer earthquake exposes lingering lack of governance in Nepal

How they got it wrong with Nepal earthquake posts on social media

Full coverage: Nepal Earthquake

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Utpal is an assistant editor based in Guwahati. He covers all eight states of North-East and was previously based in Kathmandu, Dehradun and Delhi with Hindustan Times .

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Forty-two Malian soldiers were killed and 22 injured in an attack. (File Photo)

    Forty-two Malian soldiers killed in suspected Islamist attack

    Forty-two Malian soldiers were killed and 22 injured in an attack near the town of Tessit on Sunday, Mali's government said on Wednesday, blaming an Islamic State affiliate. It was one of the deadliest attacks in recent years for the Malian army, which has been battling a decade-long insurgency by militant groups that have spread across West Africa's Sahel region. Soldiers killed 37 combatants during several hours of heavy fighting, it added.

  • North Korea supremo Kim Jong Un

    Kim Jong Un had suffered fever symptoms, reveals North Korea on defeating Covid

    North Korea's Kim Jong Un declared victory in the battle against COVID-19 on Thursday, with the leader's sister revealing he had suffered from fever and vowing "deadly retaliation" against South Korea which it blames for causing the outbreak. It had instead reported daily numbers of fever patients, which totalled some 4.77 million, but has registered no new such cases since July 29.

  • Japan's minister of state for measures for declining birthrate Masanobu Ogura. (REUTERS/Issei Kato)

    Japan's male minister tried ‘pregnancy belly’ to address falling birthrate issue

    Masanobu Ogura and two other male lawmakers were to keep the 7.3 kg (16 pound) pregnancy bellies on while going about their daily routines, in order to understand the burden on the body of carrying a child, the Sankei newspaper reported at the time.

  • This satellite image provided by Planet Labs PBC shows destroyed Russian aircraft at Saki Air Base after an explosion Tuesday, August 9, 2022, in the Crimean Peninsula, the Black Sea peninsula seized from Ukraine by Russia and annexed in March 2014. (Planet Labs PBC via AP)

    Ukraine says 9 Russian warplanes destroyed in Crimea blasts

    Ukrainian officials stopped short of publicly claiming responsibility for the explosions, while mocking Russia’s explanation that a careless smoker might have caused ammunition at the Saki air base to catch fire and blow up. Analysts also said that explanation doesn’t make sense and that the Ukrainians could have used anti-ship missiles to strike the base.

  • Several Public health experts have warned that the H1N1 virus along with Covid-19 could cause a "twindemic" in the Himalayan country. (Representation purpose)

    Nepal battles 'Twindemic' as swine flu wreaks havoc amid rising Covid cases

    According to the World Health Organisation's Global Influenza Surveillance, at least 57 cases of H1N1 infection have been reported since June 6 and the infection of 55 cases of AH3 virus also known as Hong Kong flu have been also reported in the same period.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now