Questions raised in Canada over AI bombing

Updated on May 10, 2007 02:09 PM IST
AI Flight 182, which exploded over Atlantic in 1985 was allowed to leave Canada before a bomb-sniffing dog could search the plane.
HT Image
HT Image
Reuters | By, Vancouver

The doomed Air India Flight 182, which exploded over the Atlantic in 1985, killing all 329 people on board, was allowed to leave Canada before a bomb-sniffing dog could search the plane or its luggage, a government inquiry was told on Wednesday.

The statement by a former police officer was the latest surprising testimony heard by the inquiry and raises further questions about how much Canada knew of threats against the flight, which remains history's deadliest bombing of a civilian airliner.

Serge Carignan, who served with Surete du Quebec, Quebec's provincial police force, also disputed Royal Canadian Mounted Police and Transport Canada documents that said the plane and suspected luggage had been searched in Montreal prior to takeoff.

"I never did search the passenger section of the Air India aircraft before departure," Carignan told the inquiry in Ottawa, adding that Flight 182 had already taken off and the only baggage he examined were three pieces of luggage that had been left behind.

Carignan testified he was called to Montreal's Mirabel Airport on the evening of June 22, 1985, to search an aircraft and baggage, but discovered when he arrived with his dog Arko that the plane had departed.

"I've always wondered why, if I was called to search an airplane and luggage, why did they let the airplane go before I arrived," he said.

The Boeing 747 was destroyed on June 23, 1985, over the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Ireland on a flight from Canada to India via London. Investigators later determined was caused by a suitcase bomb, believed placed on the aircraft by Vancouver-based Sikh militants.

"I believe that we would have found it ... the explosives," Carignan said.

Government claims in question

It was unclear why Carignan had been called to the airport as Canadian officials have long maintained they were unaware of any specific threats to Flight 182, which flew weekly from Canada to India.

That official claim was disputed last week by respected Canadian diplomat James Bartleman, who testified he alerted RCMP to a threat just days before Fight 182 was destroyed.

Bartleman, at that time director general of the Intelligence Analysis and Security Bureau in the Department of External Affairs, said he was told that the Mounties were already aware of the threat and he was coldly dismissed.

Other government officials have since testified they were unaware of the threat, and have suggested Bartleman's memory of events is faulty.

Relatives of the Air India victims demanded this government inquiry into efforts to prevent the bombing and the police search for the bombers, after a court in 2005 cleared two men charged with murder in the case.

Bal Gupta, president of the Air India Victims Families Association, told the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. that the recent testimony has been "very frustrating and painful for the families to know."

Carignan admitted surprised that he was never contacted by investigators after the bombing, and said it was his wife who recently contacted the inquiry's staff to say he had possible information

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres. 

    UN chief demands international access to Ukraine nuclear plant after new attack

    U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called on Monday for international inspectors to be given access to the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant after Ukraine and Russia traded accusations over the shelling of Europe's largest atomic plant at the weekend. "Any attack (on) a nuclear plant is a suicidal thing," Guterres told a news conference in Japan, where he attended the Hiroshima Peace Memorial Ceremony on Saturday to commemorate the 77th anniversary of the world's first atomic bombing.

  • US President Joe Biden answers a shouted question from a reporter while walking to Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, DC, on August 7, 2022, as he travels to Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. 

    US President Joe Biden tread out to find legacy-defining wins

    After the White House gave initial approval and then settled the final details with senators, that became the version that was shepherded into law. The president next tried to strike a deal on a social spending and climate package with Sen. Joe Manchin, going as far as inviting the West Virginia lawmaker to his home in Wilmington, Delaware, until the conservative Democrat abruptly pulled the plug on the talks in a Fox News interview.

  • Taiwan flags flutter outside the presidential palace in Taipei, Taiwan August 8, 2022. 

    Air traffic returning to normal, says Taiwan govt

    Air traffic around Taiwan is gradually returning to normal after airspace surrounding the island reopened, Taiwan's Ministry of Transportation and Communications said on Monday, although China later announced fresh military drills in the area. China last week deployed scores of planes and fired live missiles near during military exercises sparked by U.S. House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi's visit to Taiwan.

  • FILE PHOTO: Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky 

    Ukrainian forces shells bridge in Kherson, delaying its reopneing

    Ukrainian forces again shelled the Antonivskyi bridge in the Russian-controlled city of Kherson, damaging construction equipment and delaying its reopening, Interfax news agency quoted a local Russian-appointed official as saying on Monday. The bridge is one of only two crossing points for Russian forces to territory they have occupied on the western bank of the Dnipro river in southern Ukraine in what Moscow calls a "special military operation" in the country.

  • United States President Joe Biden. 

    Biden welcomes Gaza ceasefire after days of violence, 44 deaths| Top points

    US president Joe Biden has welcomed the truce between Israel and militants of Palestinian aimed at ending the deadly conflict in Gaza. Here's what you need to know: 1. Israel has said that it would “respond strongly” if the ceasefire is violated by the Palestine side. Also read: Explained: What is driving the current Israel-Gaza violence 3. Gaza officials said that 44 Palestinians, almost half of them civilians and including children, had been killed.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 08, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now