'US, India to make the N-deal happen'

Updated on May 11, 2007 11:15 AM IST
US says its civil nuclear deal with India is important to both countries and they are "determined to make it happen".
HT Image
HT Image
IANS | By, Washington

The United States says its civil nuclear deal with India is important to both countries and they are "determined to make it happen".

US President George W Bush had in a recent conversation with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh talked about working forward to conclude the deal, White House spokesman Tony Snow said on Thursday.

"They're both in support of it and-look, it's important for us, it's important for the government of India and we're determined to make it happen," he added.

Asked if Bush was aware of a letter supposedly sent by the foreign relations committee of the US House of representatives to the Prime Minister of India regarding the nuclear deal, Snow said, "He may be; I'm not".

Snow declined to confirm if Bush was going to invite Singh to the White House sometime this year or next year, saying, "I will not get into any sort of personal conversations of that nature."

Meanwhile, a US non-proliferation hawk has cautioned the Democratic controlled Congress against allowing the administration to "negotiate away" two key conditions relating to plutonium reprocessing and nuclear testing.

Months after Congress blessed the concept, negotiations have stalled on at least two major sticking points, Sharon Squassoni, a senior associate in the Nonproliferation programme at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, noted in an article in washingtonpost.com's "Think Tank Town" on Thursday.

India desires advance consent to extract plutonium from reactor fuel that would be provided by the US and other foreign suppliers and opposes any cutoff in cooperation should it test a nuclear device again, but "these are not merely technical details," Squassoni said.

"The Republican-controlled Congress of last year insisted that the plutonium reprocessing and nuclear testing conditions were necessary to maintain the integrity of US and international non-proliferation policies. It would be irresponsible for a Democratic-controlled Congress now to allow these provisions to be negotiated away," Squassoni said.

Commenting on Indian Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon's recent visit "to save the troubled US-India nuclear deal", he said, "Nonproliferation watchdogs and many countries that do not have nuclear weapons howled over this radical jettisoning of rules established to reward states that signed the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty."

"Providing long-term consent to reprocess spent fuel from reactors would undermine the current US policy of not encouraging the use of plutonium and highly enriched uranium in the civilian nuclear fuel cycle, particularly in breeder reactors (which can make more plutonium than they burn up)."

"Allowing India to test again without risking foreign nuclear cooperation would severely undermine global non-proliferation," Squassoni said.

While Congress gave President Bush the benefit of the doubt on nuclear cooperation with India, it did not give him a blank cheque, he said. Congress retained the right to stop the agreement from entering into force if it did not uphold the conditions it established last year in authorising the administration to finalise the agreement with India.

In the last two years of negotiations, the United States has given inches and India has taken miles, Squassoni suggested. From the July 2005 announcement of the initiative to President Bush's visit to India in March 2006, the United States has repeatedly missed opportunities to prevent this cooperation from eroding the global non-proliferation bulwark, Squassoni contended.

While it is too late to correct these missteps, US law still provides for some barriers to proliferation, and US negotiators should ensure that the peaceful nuclear cooperation agreement meets the letter and spirit of that law, the writer said.

The agreement should specify case-by-case approval of Indian reprocessing of US spent fuel, and explicitly require termination of cooperation and return of US materials and equipment should India test, Squassoni suggested.

"Surely, no nonproliferation benefits are served by further Indian nuclear tests and the US nuclear cooperation agreement needs to reflect that. Anything less should be rejected by Congress," Squassoni said.


    Arun Kumar is Senior Assistant Editor with Hindustan Times. He has spent two-and-half decades covering Bihar, including politics, educational and social issues.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • United States President Joe Biden. 

    Biden welcomes Gaza ceasefire after days of violence, 44 deaths| Top points

    US president Joe Biden has welcomed the truce between Israel and militants of Palestinian aimed at ending the deadly conflict in Gaza. Here's what you need to know: 1. Israel has said that it would “respond strongly” if the ceasefire is violated by the Palestine side. Also read: Explained: What is driving the current Israel-Gaza violence 3. Gaza officials said that 44 Palestinians, almost half of them civilians and including children, had been killed.

  • Bangladesh plans staggered factory holidays to ease power crunch

    Bangladesh plans staggered factory holidays to ease power crunch

    Bangladesh is considering staggered holidays for garment manufacturers to tackle a worsening power crunch caused by fuel shortages, according to a government minister. The proposal involves asking factories to choose different days off instead of all of them remaining closed only on Friday, Hamid said in an interview. “We sat down with business leaders on Sunday and they agreed to our proposal in principle,” he said.

  • Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.

    ‘No talks if Russia holds referendums’: Zelensky on Ukraine war| Top points

    With the Ukraine-Russia war in its sixth month, Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky on Sunday ruled out talks if Russia proceeded with referendums in occupied areas of the war-torn country. Read: 'Ukraine putting civilians at risk', says Amnesty report; Zelensky hits back Here are the latest developments: 1. Read: Russian-origin man marries Ukrainian girlfriend in Dharamshala 4.

  • FILE PHOTO: People watch a TV broadcasting a news report on the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak in North Korea, at a railway station in Seoul, South Korea.

    North Korean Parliament to discuss anti epidemic policy, rural development

    North Korea will convene two key meetings, including one to review the country's anti-epidemic policy, in coming weeks, state media said on Monday, as it claims no new COVID-19 cases since late July. The North Korean Supreme People's Assembly, the isolated state's rubber-stamp parliament, will meet on Sept. 7 to discuss law on rural development and organizational matters, according to the official KCNA.

  • The setting sun shines through a Black Lives Matter flag

    Over 600 kids strip searched by London police, mostly black boys: New data

    London's under-fire police force strip-searched more than 600 children over a two-year period, most of them black boys, according to new data released Monday. England's commissioner for children, Rachel de Souza, said she was "deeply shocked" by the figures after obtaining them from the Metropolitan police. The 15-year-old black schoolgirl was strip-searched by female officers in 2020 after being wrongly suspected of carrying cannabis, despite them being aware she was menstruating.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 08, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now