Manto, the samurai, and other wordsmiths | books | Hindustan Times
Today in New Delhi, India
Aug 16, 2018-Thursday
New Delhi
  • Humidity
  • Wind

Manto, the samurai, and other wordsmiths

Saadat Hasan Manto, Rajinder Singh Bedi, Mohan Rakesh and Kamleshwar get on stage together. A dramatic story-telling treat of two generations of Hindustani writers

books Updated: Jul 23, 2016 14:45 IST
Paramita Ghosh
Paramita Ghosh
Hindustan Times
Manto short stories,Jashn-e-Qalam,Kamleshwar
Manto with wife Safia (extreme left), his sister-in-law Zakia, and his daughter Nighat in Bombay 1947(Photo: The Pity of Partition by Ayesha Jalal / HarperCollins )

One evening in the ’40s, writer Saadat Hasan Manto landed in Delhi with a job with the All India Radio and met fellow writer Krishan Chander. Manto had just quit editing a film journal in Bombay and the two friends chatted through the night. The next morning, he asked Chander for whisky to eliminate the taste of the night’s alcohol and took out a short story from his bag. In the Pity of Partition, Manto’s niece and academic Ayesha Jalal, writes of the his Delhi stint and the nature of his friendships with India’s first progressives in Urdu and Hindi literature -- Upendranath Ashk, Rajinder Singh Bedi, Chirag Hasan Hasrat and Rafi Pir -- relationships built on jibes, jest, a merciless critique of each other’s work but immense support for their shared day-to-day struggles.

Literary friendships, then, were about literature certainly, but they were also about creating a community, a milieu.

Read: The love story of Anita and Mohan Rakesh

Mohan Rakesh and Kamleshwar belonged to the post-Independence literary wave in Hindi literature -- the Nayi Kahani movement. KC Shankar, actor and co-founder of the Jashn-e-Qalam initiative that is bringing to Delhi four solo performances of short stories from both generations, says Mohan Rakesh was a novelist of the new neuroses and obsessions of the middle class. “Kamleshwar, unlike writers of the earlier generation like Manto, Chughtai and Bedi, focussed on character psychology rather than seeing the character through the prism of history.

Kamleshwar’s Apne Desh Ke Log is enacted by actor KC Shankar. “Written in the sixties, it could well have been written for our times. After smartphones and smart cities, it’s time to ensure the workforce is made smart too,” says the actor. (Photo courtesy: Jashn-e-Qalam)
Rajinder Singh Bedi’s story, Chechak Ke Daag, is enacted by actor Shashwita Sharma. (Photo courtesy: Jash-e-Qalam)

...If Manto was a Samurai whose words were direct and went straight to the heart, Bedi was poetic in prose. Bedi used brush strokes, illusions, metaphors. . It was just a different way of thinking.”

Manjeet Mahipal enacts the Manto story Padhiye Kalima. Mahipal has worked with well-known theatre directors such as Nadira Babbar, Salim Ghouse & Anita Salim. (Photo courtesy: Jashn-e-Qalam)
Vicky Ahuja will enact Mohan Rakesh’s story, Parmatma Ka Kutta (Photo courtesy: Jashn-e-Qalam)

Mirroring reality

The Ek Baar Ki Baat performance opens with Manto’s Padhiye Kalma; followed by Bedi’s Chechak Ke Daag’. In Manto’s story (enacted by Manjeet Mahipal), a Muslim is caught stabbing a Hindu to death. The police consider it an open-and-shut case: one man killed another because of communal reasons. “The story is a critique of this mindset. It was actually a crime of passion. The man was willing to confess to this but no one listens to him,” says Shankar. “Manto knew that it is only in art that a convict will get a fair hearing. We have similar cases in today’s times. Who listens to the convict’s side of the story?”

Read: Why writer Uday Prakash returned his Sahitya Akademi award

A woman is tested on her wedding night when she discovers her husband has pock marks all over his face. This Bedi story is enacted by Shashwita Sharma. “Although written in 1952 the story is very contemporary,” says Sharma. “We have set standards of beauty but there are inner complexes that need to be sorted out first.”

Kamleshwar’s Apne Desh Ke Log (enacted by Shankar), written in the 1960s, could well have been written for our times. “After smartphones and smart cities, it’s time to ensure the workforce is made smart too,” says the Jashn-e-Qalam collective.

Hindi writer Kamleshwar. His short story, Apne Desh ke Log, is to be enacted by KC Shankar (Photo: Ajit Kumar / HT Photo)

“Set in an office, it encourages its citizen-workers to adopt discipline as the route to development. When someone has an operation, the image of his office is transplanted in his eyes, his official files are put in his head…” Mohan Rakesh’s story, Parmatma Ka Kutta, another take on the office, is about battling bureaucracy and red-tape. Vicky Ahuja enacts this story.

All the performances are prop-free and end with audience discussion. That certainly should be a different experience in the age of internet where one can ‘play’ or ‘pause’ a work of art mid-way and where the preferred way of viewing is in isolation. “’Did I see what you saw?’ ‘What visual did I enjoy?’ A discussion helps us, it helps the audience,” says Shankar. “We see the same things but it’s a different play going on in all our heads. Let’s talk about it.”

What: Ek Baar Ki Baat

When: July 23, 7 pm; July 24, 12 pm

Where: Greenr Café, 416 Shahpur Jat, Siri Fort

First Published: Jul 23, 2016 08:28 IST