Info commissioner accuses chief of ‘generosity’ to Punjab officers

Updated on Jul 24, 2015 09:31 AM IST
Those safeguarding your right to information are now daggers drawn over their own rights. In a letter written to Punjab chief information commissioner Swaran Singh Channi, state information commissioner Surinder Awasthi has accused the former of “allocating most important departments to himself and being extra-generous in granting prayers of bureaucrats and police officials”.
(L-R): Swaran Singh Channi (Punjab chief information commissioner); Surinder Awasthi (state information commissioner)
(L-R): Swaran Singh Channi (Punjab chief information commissioner); Surinder Awasthi (state information commissioner)
Hindustan Times | By, Chandigarh

Those safeguarding your right to information are now daggers drawn over their own rights. In a letter written to Punjab chief information commissioner Swaran Singh Channi, state information commissioner Surinder Awasthi has accused the former of “allocating most important departments to himself and being extra-generous in granting prayers of bureaucrats and police officials”.

Channi retired as Punjab home secretary before his appointment to the information panel while Awasthi is a former journalist. The letter, a copy of which is with the HT, alleges that Channi has been “emboldening” public information officers (PIOs) and complainants to get favourable decisions by appealing for transfer of case to another bench. “The CIC being first among equals is the master of the roster and free to allocate cases under the Right to Information (RTI) Act. But sending for files for perusal while cases are under progress and are at the penultimate stage of adjudication and transferring them to other benches amounts to gross interference in the functioning of the commissioners for which the CIC has no mandate under the statute,” adds the letter.

What led to face-off

The case which has led to the face-off pertains to state commissioner Awasthi issuing a show-cause notice to SAS Nagar SSP Gurpreet Singh Bhullar (SSP cum public information officer) for “concealing” information sought by a Chandigarh resident, Krishan Kumar Singla, claiming that a false FIR was registered against him by the police in “connivance” with a builder on the basis of forged papers. Singla had knocked the doors of the commission saying the information provided in response to his application by the SAS Nagar SSP did not contain those pages.

Later, the requisite information was traced to the police files by the director, Bureau of Investigation, and given to the applicant. The response of Bhullar to the show-cause notice was taken on record on June 17 and the next date of hearing was fixed for July 14. But before the formal orders could be put on the commission’s website, Bhullar moved the CIC for transfer of the case to another bench.

His request said, “From the conversation that took place before the bench, the applicant could gauge that the bench nurses some personal bias against him and his family and he won’t get justice.”

Channi, through an order dated July 9, said the case be transferred “in the interest of justice” to another division bench and the order be placed on the commission’s website. He subsequently wrote to the deputy registrar to get the case file transferred from Awasthi. But the latter has dug in his heels claiming in his letter that the CIC had no power to transfer cases from one bench to another on the basis of “wild and concocted” allegations of bias or apprehension of injustice.

“Since your orders are unjust, there is no need to comply with them and I have not handed over the file. One is at a loss to understand the undue haste shown by the CIC in the case by throwing all conventions and precedents to the winds,” the letter states.

The letter also questions the working of the CIC. It says his regular orders are not put on the website for weeks and are sent to the parties late. “However, in this case, you have shown remarkable swiftness and said that your orders be put on the website immediately,” it says.

Awasthi, when contacted, said he had written the letter, but refused to comment further. Channi did not respond to the calls and messages sent to him.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Sukhdeep Kaur is an assistant editor with the Punjab bureau. She covers politics, social issues and special projects, including on-the-ground reporting during critical situations.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi offered condolences to renowned singer Shivamogga Subbanna who died on Thursday.

    PM Modi pays rich tribute to Shivamogga Subbanna: 'A household name'

    Prime Minister Narendra Modi offered condolences to renowned singer Shivamogga Subbanna who died on Thursday. The 83-year-old national award-winning singer died of a heart attack at Bengaluru. Shivamogga Subbanna was the first playback singer from Karnataka to win a national award for playback singing. Shivamogga Subbanna's admirers bid him final adieu at Ravindra Kalakeshtra of Bengaluru on Friday. Shivamogga Subbanna is survived by his wife, son and a daughter.

  • The Jagannath temple in Puri, Odisha. (Raj K Raj/ HT File Photo)

    After 4 years, ASI reiterates demand to open inner treasury of Jagannath temple

    More than four years after an unsuccessful attempt to inspect the 'Ratna Bhandar', or chambers containing valuables, of the Lord Jagannath temple in Puri, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has renewed its demand for the opening of the chambers for inspection. The two chambers of the Ratna Bhandar of the Jagannath temple – 'Bhitar Bhandar' (inner treasury) and 'Bahar Bhandar' (outer treasury) – reportedly has more than 800 valuables and jewellery.

  • 6 police officers awarded with medals for their swift investigation

    These 6 Karnataka cops have been awarded by centre for excellence in service

    Six police officers from Karnataka have bagged medals this year as the union home ministry on Friday announced awards nationwide for over 150 police personnel for setting an inspiring example and answering the call to duty. Karnataka Lokayukta SP K Lakshmi Ganesh - who played a major role in unearthing illegal migrant documents nexus in the state -is among those who have won accolades.

  • Searches were conducted at various premises of Yellow Tune Technologies Private Limited between August 8-10

    ED freezes assets worth 370 cr of Bengaluru firm

    The Enforcement Directorate on Friday said it has conducted searches at various premises of a private company in Bengaluru and froze assets worth Rs 370 crore. According to ED, a large amount of funds to the tune of Rs 370 crore were deposited by 23 entities including accused NBFCs and their fintech companies into the INR wallets of Yellow Tune Technologies held with crypto exchange Flipvolt Technologies Private Limited. The company's promoters went untraceable.

  • Dr K Sudhakar (ANI)

    Karnataka Minister urges people to take pledge for organ donation

    India], August 13 (ANI): Karnataka Health Minister K Sudhakar on Friday urged people to take a pledge for organ donation on the occasion of World Organ Donation Day. "During this Azadi Ki Amrit Mahotsav, pledge to donate your organs which could be "Amrit" for someone's life," Sudhakar said while addressing a press conference. The Health Minister recalled Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Mann Ki Baat address, in which he appealed to people to donate organs.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, August 13, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now