Online retailer, seller asked to pay Chandigarh resident 2,500 for collecting extra GST

Published on Jul 03, 2022 02:24 AM IST
Penalising a leading online retailer and Telangana-based seller for wrongly charging 49 as Goods and Service Tax (GST), the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission directed them to pay 2,500 to the complainant.
Madhu P Singh of Chandigarh had filed a complaint against Amazon Sellers Services Pvt Ltd (New Delhi and Bengaluru) and Cloudtail India Pvt. Ltd (Telangana). (Representative Image/HT File)
Madhu P Singh of Chandigarh had filed a complaint against Amazon Sellers Services Pvt Ltd (New Delhi and Bengaluru) and Cloudtail India Pvt. Ltd (Telangana). (Representative Image/HT File)
By, Chandigarh

Penalising a leading online retailer and Telangana-based seller for wrongly charging 49 as Goods and Service Tax (GST), the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission directed them to pay 2,500 to the complainant.

Madhu P Singh of Chandigarh had filed a complaint against Amazon Sellers Services Pvt Ltd (New Delhi and Bengaluru) and Cloudtail India Pvt. Ltd (Telangana).

The woman said she had bought footwear worth 2,995 (including taxes) from a British lifestyle brand at 33% discount from the online retailer.

An invoice of 1,048 was raised on June 2019, and she paid in cash for the same. However, later she realised that she had been charged an additional 49 as tax, she said.

Accusing the seller and retailer of deficiency in service and unfair trade practices, Singh moved the commission.

While the Telangana-based dealer did not appear before the consumer forum, Amazon Sellers Services submitted a written response, saying the company did not sell or offer to sell any products and neither did they advertise or endorse any product on the website or anywhere else. It said the company merely provides an online marketplace where independent third-party sellers list their products for sale.

Amazon Sellers Services, in its response, also said, “The sellers are responsible for their respective listings and products on the website.”

The online retailer also contended that the complainant never approached them, nor lodged any complaint, hence they had no knowledge of the matter. They also submitted that the discounted price of the product was exclusive of taxes and the customer had been charged correctly. However, the consumer forum said the question was whether the maximum retail price (MRP) included all taxes and whether, after discount, Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) may be charged or not?

“When MRP includes all taxes, charging extra IGST on the discounted price would certainly amount to deficiency in service and indulgence into unfair trade practice on the part of the Ops (opposition parties). Hence, they are liable to refund the excess amount of GST besides compensation for mental agony, physical pain and litigation expenses to the complainant,” the commission observed.

It directed them to refund 49, which was wrongly charged, and pay 2,500 on account of deficiency in service and litigation expenses.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Arun Singh, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national general secretary in-charge of Karnataka, on Friday said that there is no leadership change in the southern state. (HT Photo)

    CM Bommai is here to stay: BJP General Secretary Arun Singh

    Amid the 'Bommai ouster' rumours in Karnataka, BJP General Secretary and state in-charge Arun Singh on Saturday stated that Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai "is here to stay" and will lead the Bharatiya Janata Party in the upcoming Assembly election. Following this, the position of Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai, has been labelled as a "weak chief minister". This election will be fought under the leadership of Basavaraj Bommai assures Arun Singh.

  • Representational image

    Three top leaders of MVA become inmates in Mumbai's Arthur jail

    Nationalist Congress Party leaders Anil Deshmukh and Nawab Malik and Sena leader Sanjay Raut, who have been arrested in money laundering cases by the Enforcement Directorate, are now lodged in Arthur Road Jail in three different barracks. Malik, who was arrested in February in a money laundering case, is currently admitted to the Criti Care Hospital in Kurla for treatment. He is admitted to a private hospital for the last two months.

  • Officials said that all the four employees were removed from service in line in line with the recommendations of a special task force set up last year by Jammu and Kashmir lieutenant governor Manoj Sinha to scrutinise and recommend cases for removal from government service, for alleged terror links. (PTI/ Representational image)

    Bitta Karate’s wife among 4 Jammu and Kashmir employees sacked for terror links

    The Jammu and Kashmir government on Saturday terminated four employees from service, including the son of Hizbul Mujahideen chief Syed Salahuddin and wife of former militant Bitta Karate - amid probe over terror links, officials said on Saturday. Dr Muheet Ahmad Bhat, and Majid Hussain Qadiri - both of them linked to the University of Kashmir - are the two others employees who have been sacked.

  • Security personnel stand guard at a site where militants hurled a grenade towards CRPF bunker near Ali Masjid Eidgah area, in Srinagar on Saturday. (ANI)

    CRPF man injured in grenade attack in Srinagar

    Suspected militants targeted paramilitary CRPF with a grenade in Srinagar on Saturday, just a day ahead of Independence Day. A CRPF personnel was injured in the attack in the Old City, Eidgah. Srinagar police said that the CRPF personnel received minor injuries in the attack. Local reports said that the grenade was lobbed towards a CRPF bunker in Eidgah in which a sub-inspector of the CRPF was wounded.

  • Jammu and Kashmir Lt Governor Manoj Sinha on Saturday laid the foundation stone of 25 District Development Council and Block Development Council buildings in J&K. (ANI File Photo)

    Will strike last nail in coffin of terrorism in one year: Jammu and Kashmir L-G Manoj Sinha

    Jammu and Kashmir Lt Governor Manoj Sinha on Saturday said that within a year government will push the last nail in the coffin of terrorism. Sinha today laid the foundation stone of 25 District Development Council and Block Development Council buildings in J&K, besides inaugurating 1000 Amrit Sarovars across J&K UT, in a function at SKICC, Srinagar.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Sunday, August 14, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now