An expert on sedition
As a senior editor, it’s my job to pontificate…er...I mean comment on everything under the sun, Manas Chakravarty writes.columns Updated: Sep 15, 2012 22:13 IST
TV Reporter: Would you like to comment on the recent muzzling of the freedom of expression?
Me: As a senior editor, it’s my job to pontificate…er...I mean comment on everything under the sun.
Reporter: What do you think of the sedition imbroglio?
Me: What? Oh, I think it’s a lost art. Given the right technique, you can achieve the results you want.
Reporter: I get your point about the art of cartooning. But should people get into trouble because of it?
Me: Look at Casanova, Don Juan, Mata Hari or Bill Clinton.
Reporter: They got into trouble over sedition?
Me: Of course. I don’t think cartoons will work. What you need is a romantic environment — light music, wine, good food, perhaps candlelight. That creates the right atmosphere for seduction.
Reporter: Seduction? I was asking about sedition.
Me: Eh? Oh.
Reporter: So what do you think of sedition?
Me: I….ummm….don’t mind it, if you have a bit extra to spare.
Reporter: Sedition, in case you didn’t know, is saying or writing nasty things about the State.
Me: Oh that sedition. Of course you have to respect the State. Take the police — people pay them their hafta regularly, right? That’s respect.
Reporter: Are you saying you agree with Hegel that the State is heaven on earth, dialectically speaking?
Me: You mean Higgins, not Hegel. Henry Higgins was the professor in My Fair Lady. He was the one who knew all about dialects.
Reporter: Hegel was all for the State. He was the guy Marx stood upon his head.
Me: Yes, Marx is quite the yoga guru. Sirsasana, he called it. He’s Bengali, you know.
Reporter: He was German.
Me: That’s typical disinformation spread by the Trinamool Congress. Believe me, Marx is alive and well in Kolkata.
Reporter: We have strayed far from the topic. What’s your view about the insult to national symbols?
Me: Whaaat? Which idiot has dared to insult Bollywood?
Reporter: Not Bollywood, sir.
Me: Oh, somebody insulted Tendulkar?
Reporter: No, no.
Me: Then what? Butter chicken?
Reporter: Nobody has said anything against butter chicken.
Me: I get it. You mean the Victoria Memorial. Or Gateway of India?
Reporter: Those are British symbols. I mean Parliament, the flag, the rupee.
Me: See, if you have a problem with them, you could protest by sitting in the nearest river, or in the sea. It’s the rage these days.
Reporter: And what do you think about disrespecting the Constitution?
Me: Somebody dared to do that? Did he have the temerity to say that half the country’s kids are malnourished, 65 years after Independence?
Reporter: That’s true, isn’t it?
Me: So what? It’s a slur on the Constitution.
Reporter: I’m afraid we’ve run completely out of time. Any profound parting thoughts?
Me: I had written down a quote for this interview. Here’s what the great French writer Gustave Flaubert warned about the constitution: “Happiness is like smallpox: if you catch it too soon, it can completely ruin your constitution.”
Manas Chakravarty is Consulting Editor, Mint
Views expressed by the author are personal
First Published: Sep 15, 2012 22:10 IST