HC asks L-G Najeeb Jung to consider Delhi govt's proposals

Not granting a stay or quashing the Centre's notification clipping AAP administration's powers, the Delhi high court on Friday directed the Lt Governor to "deliberate" on the city government's proposals on appointment of senior bureaucrats to key posts.
Chief-minister-Arvind-Kejriwal-addresses-the-Delhi-assembly-at-Old-Secretariat-Sushil-Kumar-HT-Photo
Chief-minister-Arvind-Kejriwal-addresses-the-Delhi-assembly-at-Old-Secretariat-Sushil-Kumar-HT-Photo
Updated on May 29, 2015 10:20 PM IST
Copy Link
PTI | By, New Delhi

Not granting a stay or quashing the Centre's notification clipping AAP administration's powers, the Delhi high court on Friday directed the Lt Governor to "deliberate" on the city government's proposals on appointment of senior bureaucrats to key posts.

Hearing the Delhi government's plea for quashing the May 21 order of the Centre barring the anti-corruption branch from proceeding against any staff under Centre's control, the court, as an interim measure, asked the L-G to deliberate upon the AAP government's orders shifting nine bureaucrats from one post to another.

It also sought the Centre's response on AAP government's plea seeking quashing of a notification which gave the Lt Governor absolute powers to appoint bureaucrats to various posts in the national capital.

Justice Rajiv Shakdher gave the interim order after senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for the Delhi government, suggested the via media to break the "conundrum".

She said the government will send its proposal for allocating different posts to the LG, who can then follow the procedure laid down in the Transaction of Business Rules.

Jaising argued that in view of the notification the officers were not reporting for duty where they were posted and as a result running of government has come to a stand still.

"They (Centre) can't short circuit the procedure provided under the Rules and the Constitution," she said.

Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Sanjay Jain opposed the suggestion saying the city government was "inherently ineligible" for "tweaking or tinkering" with the officers allocated to it by the Centre which decides where they have to be posted.

He also said that when the city government did not have the power to give an opinion on the issue, then the question of sending the proposal to the LG does not arise.

"They are incapable of making it (proposal)," Jain said and added that any interim order would "disturb the basic fabric".

Earlier in the day, the Supreme Court asked the AAP government to reply within three weeks on the Centre's plea for a stay on an HC ruling that restored the power of the state government's anti-corruption branch (ACB) to probe central government's employees in graft cases.

The high court said if any information, like the profile of the officer concerned was required, the LG would call for it.

The court also asked the Centre about the practice in the past with respect to posting of bureaucrats and directed the MHA to give an affidavit stating what was the practice adopted in Union territories.

"What was happening in the past? Was the UT government allowed to move officers? I need an affidavit and factual data on how it was happening in all UTs," it said and directed that the affidavit be filed in six weeks and listed the matter for further hearing on August 11.

During the arguments, Jaising submitted that the entire "controversy" arose not because the city government tried to recruit officers but because of its decision to allocate them work different from what they were doing.

She said the city government has no control over the officers of the All India Services with respect to their service conditions, including taking disciplinary action against them as well as their promotion.

"Job allocation is my prerogative. That is governance. One runs a government through its officers, therefore, we need to have the power to allocate them work as per our wish" she said.

"Heart of the matter is that he (LG and Centre) wants to act as an autocrat," she claimed.

The arguments also saw heated exchanges between the ASG and Jaising after she said that he had not understood her contentions.

After the hearing the arguments the court said the aspect needs consideration.

"You (both governments) say you have the power, it needs to be determined," the court said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • According to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) report, while four of the deceased were over the age 70 with multiple comorbidities like diabetes and hypertension, one of them was a 43-year-old female (Praful Gangurde)

    City reports five Covid deaths after four months

    Mumbai After a gap of over four months, Mumbai reported five Covid deaths on Saturday, the highest since February 7, along with 1,700 fresh infections. According to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation report, while four of the deceased were over the age 70 with multiple comorbidities like diabetes and hypertension, one of them was a 43-year-old female. In June, the city saw 33 deaths and 38,059 Covid cases and currently has 12,727 active cases.

  • Jaynath Mishra said that the people of Rampur and Azamgarh, who were influenced by the policies and welfare schemes of the central government and the state government, supported the BJP in the by-elections of both the Lok Sabha seats. With the blessings of the people, the party won both seats. (FOR REPRESENTATION PURPOSE)

    Varanasi: BJP leaders celebrate party’s victory in Azamgarh, Rampur bypolls

    Kashi region's Bharatiya Janata Party Kisan Morcha workers led by regional general secretary Jaynath Mishra, on Sunday, celebrated the victory of the BJP in by-elections at Azamgarh and Rampur parliamentary seats. BJP workers including Jai Mangal, Sumit Kumar, Monu Singh, Abbas Ahmed, Rakesh Singh, Sonu Yadav and several other workers hurled Gulal at each other and distributed sweets. Mishra said that all-around development will be ensured in Azamgarh.

  • Kala-azar is characterised by irregular bouts of fever, weight loss, enlargement of the spleen and liver, and anaemia. Most cases occur in Brazil, East Africa and India: UNICEF. (FOR REPRESENTATION PURPOSE)

    BHU scientists find new way of identifying asymptomatic patients of Kala-azar

    Scientists at Banaras Hindu University have come up with a new reliable and cost-effective way of identifying asymptomatic individuals of visceral leishmaniasis (VL) or Kala-azar, said researchers in a press statement. The work was led by senior research fellow Siddharth Sankar Singh under the guidance of Prof Shyam Sundar, distinguished professor, department of medicine, Institute of Medical Sciences and Dr Rajiv Kumar, the centre of experimental medicine and surgery (CEMS) at IMS-BHU.

  • Bihar education minister Vijay Kumar Choudhary. (HT Photo)

    Minister asks varsity panel to expedite Asst Prof appointment, sets Dec deadline

    Education minister Vijay Kumar Choudhary on Saturday reviewed the ongoing appointment of assistant professors in severely understaffed state universities and asked the Bihar state university service commission(BSUSC) to complete the exercise latest by December 31, 2022, by focusing on subjects having a higher number of vacancies. The commission had become functional in 2019 with the appointment of Dr. Rajvardhan Azad as its first chairman and has completed its three-year term.

  • Sources said the impetus to PMAY( G) has come to lessen the backlog of approved houses for beneficiaries selected from economically weaker sections. (Picture for representation)

    Govt sets target of completing 10 lakh units under PMAY(G) by Aug 15

    In a bid to complete approved houses for rural poor under the Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana (Grameen) scheme, the state government has set the target of completing 10 lakh houses from its target of 2021-22 and 2020-21 of around 13 lakh houses by August 15 this year by initiating the process to disperse the second installment to selected beneficiaries, officials said.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Sunday, June 26, 2022