India may pass an anti-torture law, finally

Updated on Feb 11, 2008 12:46 PM IST

Eleven years after signing an UN international treaty against torture, India may finally introduce domestic legislation to conform to some of the provisions - a critical step to ratifying the treaty.

HT Image
HT Image
IANS | ByDevirupa Mitra, New Delhi

Eleven years after signing an UN international treaty against torture, India may finally introduce domestic legislation to conform to some of the provisions - a critical step to ratifying the treaty.

An inter-ministerial meeting held by the law ministry in the last week of January took the decision to start drafting an "umbrella law" against torture, which will be made ready "soon".

The United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1984 and came into force in 1987 after 20 countries ratified it.

India put its initials to this international human rights instrument on October 14, 1997, but has still not ratified the treaty.

But India's interest in ratifying was rekindled after it won a seat for a period of three years at the newly constituted UN Human Rights Council in May 2007. India got more votes than any other country in the race.

"At the time of (the UN council) elections, we were reviewing what international treaties India has not yet signed. We found that while the torture convention had been signed, we had yet to ratify it," said a government official.

The lack of ratification is a bit of an embarrassment as already 145 countries are party to the treaty, while India keeps company with eight other nations in the non-ratified column - Sudan, Comoros, Congo, Dominican Republic, Sao Tome and Principe, Gambia, Nauru and Guinea-Bissau.

However, some of the 145 countries have also declared that they will not adhere to certain sections of the convention if it conflicts with their domestic legislation or constitution.

According to government officials, the key reason for India's reticence has been objections raised by the Ministry of Home Affairs on certain provisions in the convention.

The major contention was over the definition of torture in the convention, which included both physical and mental acts. Indian codes of criminal law and procedure do not extend the classification of torture to mental acts, though there have been court judgements that have provided a more broad-based description.

"There was serious opposition to broadening the concept of torture, especially from law and order authorities. The question raised was, will we shackle them down," the official said.

The UN treaty asserts that there cannot be any "exceptional circumstances" to justify torture, whether "a state of war or a threat of war, internal political instability or any other public emergency".

Then, there was also the question of how to implement the required changes - by amending existing legislation or introducing a new one.

With the anti-torture convention not a high priority, it also became a casualty of bureaucratic transfers.

"The issue always went into the bottom pile and at the end of every bureaucrat's tenure, his successor dusted the file, restarted the cycle and raised the same objections," said an official.

Ministry of External Affairs officials realised that if India wanted to ratify the instrument, it needed a new strategy, which could circumvent the Ministry of Home affairs. They zeroed in on the Ministry of Law and Justice.

"Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon wrote to Law Secretary TK Viswanathan to take up the matter and provide leadership," the official said.

On January 28, the law secretary held an inter-ministerial meeting attended by representatives of the external affairs and home ministries as well as the defence services.

"It was decided that the law ministry will prepare a draft stand-alone legislation that will be applicable to all organisations, including the military, and present it within one or two months," the official told IANS.

The legislation will go into issues of compensation - whether the state should pay or not if a state actor is the offender.

Separate domestic administrative machinery as per the convention was considered redundant, with officials pointing out that the National Human Rights Commission and its state-level offices have a similar mandate to stop violation of civil rights.

Once both house of parliament pass the legislation, the union cabinet will approve the ratification of the 1984 international convention.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The arrested persons are both residents of Karimganj district. (HT photo)

    Assam: Two arrested for impersonating CBI officers and allegedly extorting money

    Two persons were arrested on Friday in Assam's Karimganj district for allegedly extorting money by impersonating as CBI officers. Police arrested one of them based on an audio recording they received from a complainant and the other person was held after the officials laid a trap. The arrested persons, Rashid Ahmed (35) and Dilowar Hussain (30) are both residents of Karimganj district. A case has been registered at Ratabari police station.

  • A woman and her illicit partner were arrested in Gurugram for allegedly threatening and assaulting 13-year-old son. (Pic for representation)

    Mother with her paramour assaults 13-year-old son, arrested in Gurugram

    A woman and her paramour were arrested for assaulting and threatening her minor son after he saw them in an objectionable position here, police said on Thursday. The woman's paramour, Vishal, allegedly burnt the 13-year-old's face and feet with a hot sieve and also threatened to chop his legs after the boy threatened to complain against him.

  • Rohtas Police said they are yet to identify the Bihar girl who was presumed to have been abducted by the two men on the motorcycle (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

    Bihar teen abducted on bike tries to escape, crushed by truck behind them

    The incident took place in Dehri-on-Sone, an industrial township in western Bihar's Rohtas district. Police said they were yet to identify the girl. Witnesses said they saw two men on the bike with the young girl. She landed in front of a container truck that was behind the motorcycle and was crushed to death. The two men on the bike escaped. Dehri station house officer Rajiv Kumar said they were trying to identify the girl and the two men.

  • A team of biologists working along a stretch of a beach in East Midnapore found the carcasses. (File image)

    Porpoises with fins allegedly chopped off found in West Bengal; probe ordered

    Carcasses of at least four Indo-Pacific Finless Porpoises with fins allegedly chopped off were found in the coastal district of East Midnapore in West Bengal on Friday. A team of biologists working along a stretch of a beach in East Midnapore found the carcasses. The most distinct feature of the finless porpoise is that it lacks a dorsal fin. Instead, it has large flippers on their sides.

  • Krishna Janmashtami celebrations in Bengaluru. (Putthige Mutt/Twitter)

    Janmashtami celebrations in Bengaluru | In pics

    This year's Krishna Janmashtami was celebrated with great fervour across Bengaluru, with many sharing photos and videos of the decorations and the pooja online. The Radio City Twitter handle also shared a video of the Iskcon's Akshaya Patra sewa, writing, “Iskcon's Akshaya Patra Taste of Bengaluru Check out this video as RJ Rajas introduces you to Iskcon's Akshaya Patra- Megha Kitchen, On this Krishna Janmashtami the temple makes it really special.”

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, August 19, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now