‘No need for fatwa to say India friend of Islam’

Noted Islamic scholar and Law Commission member Tahir Mahmood has joined issue with the VHP for demanding an edict (fatwa) from Darul Uloom Deoband declaring India a Muslim-friendly country (Dar-ul-Amn), reports Satya Prakash.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Feb 26, 2009 11:34 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | BySatya Prakash, New Delhi

Noted Islamic scholar and Law Commission member Tahir Mahmood has joined issue with the Vishwa Hindu Parishad for demanding an edict (fatwa) from Darul Uloom Deoband declaring India a Muslim-friendly country (Dar-ul-Amn), saying the whole idea was based on wrong premises.

“The proposition that Muslim seminaries issue a religious edict declaring India to be Dar-ul-Amn is, to say the least, based on wrong premises. It indicates both imaginary fears and lack of adequate knowledge about Islamic law,” Mahmood, a former National Commission for Minorities chairman, told HT. “The Muslims of India have in the past defended and will always defend the nation against any external aggression irrespective of the aggressor’s religion. For this , they don’t need any fatwa,” he said.

Mahmood also disagreed with Darul Uloom Deoband Vice-Chancellor Abdul Khaleque Madrasi’s view that the term kafir (non-believer) meant a person who did not follow Islam. “The expression kafir means one who denies the existence of God. Who has the cheek to use it for the Hindus who undoubtedly are firm believers?” he asked.

The VHP’s Dharm Raksha Manch had written to the Deoband clergy last week demanding a fatwa, declaring India a “friend of Islam to end religion-inspired violence”. It had also asked the seminary to declare that Hindus were not kafirs and therefore, jihad did not apply to them. Responding to the demand, the seminary said it was ready to issue a fatwa, provided the VHP followed the procedure for obtaining the edict.

“Some Muslim scholars in the past took pains to establish that like Christians and Jews Hindus, too, are covered by Quranic expression ahl-e-kitab (people believing in a scripture),” Mahmood said.

Terming the anxiety about old Arabic expression like kafir as misplaced, he said, “Nobody now uses it anymore for any people.” Mahmood sought to emphasise that the classification of territories as Dar-ul-harb (hostile nation), Dar-ul-amn (friendly nation) and Dar-ul-Islam (Muslim state) was “absolutely irrelevant to the modern world’s political order based on the concepts of political sovereignty and equality of all nation-states”.

“Dar-ul-harb and Dar-ul-amn are relative expressions and were part of an obsolete branch of early Islamic jurisprudence called siyar (international relations),” Mahmood, also a former Dean of Delhi University’s Faculty of Law, said.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Police personnel guard the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi temple in Mathura. (PTI File Photo)

    Mathura court to hear Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi case today

    The court of civil judge (senior division) in Mathura will on Thursday hear the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi matter as the Shahi Eidgah mosque management committee presses for the disposal of the application challenging the maintainability of the case. Those appearing for deity Thakur Keshav Dev Maharaj (petitioner) are pushing for the appointment of court commissioner (ameen) for survey of Shahi Eidgah mosque, the removal of which has been sought by the petitioners.

  • State capital Bengaluru continued to record most of Karnataka's cases on Wednesday. (Representative Photo/Shutterstock)

    Karnataka daily Covid cases jump 34% in 24 hours to 1,127; 1,053 in Bengaluru

    Karnataka logged 1,127 cases of Covid-19 on Wednesday, compared to the 839 cases registered the day before. As many as 1,053 of Wednesday's cases were from Bengaluru. Karnataka's cumulative Covid count is 39.75 lakh, with a positivity rate of 4.26%. Bengaluru's 1,053 cases were a big spike over the 775 reported Tuesday. Active cases in the city are 6,056. There are 29 active clusters in Bengaluru, with 26 reporting less than five cases each.

  • Karnataka landslide; Karnataka rain news; Karnataka monsoon news (Credit: ANI)

    3 dead after landslide in Karnataka's Dakshina Kannada district

    Three people have died after a landslide in Karnataka's Dakshina Kannada district, a senior police official told news agency ANI Thursday morning. A fourth is being treated in hospital, Rishikesh Sonawane, a police superintendent, said. Three people were rescued from amid the debris, Dr KV Rajendra, the deputy commissioner had said late last night. The Udupi district has called a holiday for anganwadi schools and colleges. Heavy showers are expected there till July 9.

  • Firefighting operation going on as fire breaks out inside a Mall at Powai in Mumbai. (HT Photo / Pratik Chorge)

    Fire breaks out in Mumbai supermarket, no injury reported

    A level-2 fire broke out in a supermarket in the Powai area of Mumbai Thursday morning, according to civic officials. The blaze was reported in the Haiko Supermarket on the main street of Hiranandani locality in Powai at around 6.05am. At least eight fire engines and five jumbo tankers were rushed to the site to douse the fire. There was no report of any casualty, the officials said.

  • A family on a motor bike during rains. 

    Karnataka rain: Amid red alert, holiday for schools, colleges in these districts

    Owing to continuous rain, educational institutions in several parts of Karnataka will remain shut on Thursday. Top officials in the 4 districts of Karnataka - namely Udupi, Kodagu, Hassan and Uttara Kannada -- have declared holiday for Anganwadi schools and colleges amid the 'red alert' issued by the weather department. The Indian Meteorological Department has predicted extremely heavy rain, ranging above 204.5 mm for these 4 cities.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, July 07, 2022