SC to get more judges, but will it help?

Updated on Feb 22, 2008 01:05 AM IST
The government decides to raise the strength of Supreme Court judges from the existing 25 to 30, to prevent cases from piling up, report Aloke Tikku and Satya Prakash.
HT Image
HT Image
Hindustan Times | ByAloke Tikku and Satya Prakash, New Delhi

To bring justice on the fast track, the government on Thursday decided to raise the strength of Supreme Court judges from the existing 25 to 30, to prevent cases from piling up.

“The Union Cabinet has approved a proposal for introduction a Bill in Parliament to amend the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 1956 to augment the strength of the judges,” Deepak Sandhu, Director General, Media and Communications, announced after the Cabinet meeting chaired by the Prime Minister.

“The increase in the number of judges will now allow the Supreme Court to function more efficiently and effectively towards attaining the ultimate goal of rendering speedy justice to the litigant public,” Sandhu said. Officials said one important reason for the cases piling up in the highest judicial forum had to do with the expansion of the strength of the high courts, from where a significant chunk of the cases land up in appeals.

Meanwhile, legal experts said merely increasing the number of judges will not help the cause of justice and the court should also concentrate on consistently dispensing quality justice.

Senior advocates Rajeev Dhavan and Colin Gonsalves said the Supreme Court should organize itself in a better manner and have specialized benches to deal with civil, criminal, commercial etc. cases. They mooted the idea of a larger bench of nine judges, which would only deal with constitutional matters, like the one in South Africa.

Welcoming the decision to increase the judges’ strength, Gonsalves said Indian Supreme Court judges work more than the judges of any Supreme Court in the world. He, however, said: “Ideology of judges – pro-rich or pro-poor – is important. In the age of globalisation and economic liberalization it is difficult to find many pro-poor judges. If a judge is not concerned about fundamental rights of citizens and merely interested in commercial litigation then such judges should not be brought to the apex court.”

Dhavan said originally the apex court was designed as a compact court but the problem was that at present it does not organize its own work well. Arrear of cases alone should not be a reason to increase the number of judges.

Agreeing that pendency is a problem and the number of judges should be increased, Supreme Court advocate Prashant Bhushan said “quality of justice is equally important.” He said the main problem was that the present system of selection of judges was not transparent. “We need a procedure for selection of judges which is not nepotistic.”

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • They have also organised a two km march, and over a thousand residents are expected to take par (HT Photo)

    Over 200 housing societies collect 20L for Independence Day festivities

    Mumbai Over 200 housing societies of Thakur Village in Kandivali (East) have come together and collected ₹20 lakh for the occasion of Independence Day. What is even more interesting is that they have refrained from calling politicians or celebrities to hoist the national flag on Monday. Rather, they have decided that the flag will be unfurled by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation sweepers and conservancy workers from Thakur village.

  • Students helped to cross the river in Shahapur. Students from tribal hamlets in Shahapur miss school due to overflowing river. (HT PHOTO)

    Students from tribal hamlets in Shahapur miss school due to overflowing river

    The World Tribal Day is observed on August 9. However, for the tribals of Shahapur, the day was nothing more than a sham. The school children of three tribal hamlets of Shahapur in Thane district cannot attend school during monsoon as the only way to reach it is by crossing a river. Over 25 children from Bhitarwadi and Kothewadi hamlets of Shahapur lose connectivity to the other villages and the main road during the monsoon.

  • Six lakh traffic violators have not paid fines totalling <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>91Cr in Thane in the last two months. (HT FILE PHOTO FOR REPRESENTATIONAL PURPOSE ONLY)

    6 lakh traffic violators not paid fine totalling 91Cr in Thane

    Over six lakh traffic violators who failed to pay the fine for flouting traffic rules have been served notice by the Thane Traffic Police. The police have asked these rule violators to pay the fine before August 15 or they would be called to the Lok Adalat to be held on August 16. The six lakh violators are from Thane, Kalyan, Dombivli, Ulhasnagar, Bhiwandi and Mumbra.

  • Traffic towards Pune on the Sion-Panvel Highway on Friday evening. Those travelling to Pune and Goa have been told to take an alternate route via Uran Phata, according to Navi Mumbai Traffic Police. (BACHCHAN KUMAR/HT PHOTO)

    Travelling to Pune or Goa? Take alternate route via Uran Phata, say Navi Traffic Police

    The residents travelling to Pune or Goa will have to take an alternate route that passes via Uran Phata instead of the usual Mumbai–Pune Expressway, as per the directives of the Navi Mumbai Traffic Police. Motorists travelling to Pune as well as Goa are therefore asked to plan their travel by going through the alternate route via Uran Phata – Killa Junction – Gavan Phata – Palspe.

  • Kabir Rachure, a Kharghar advocate, completed the 5,000km cycling challenge of Race Across America in 11 days, 11 hours and 25 minutes. (HT PHOTO)

    Kharghar advocate completes tough cycling challenge of 5,000km in 12 days

    Cycling for passion or for keeping oneself fit is very common. But there is an extreme form of this sport, which is cycling for days together through rough terrains, unforeseen climatic conditions and weather. Kharghar-based an advocate by profession, Kabir Rachure, has finished third in the Race Across America – world's toughest cycling competition that tests the riders' endurance level by cycling for 5,000 km in a span of 12 days.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, August 13, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now