The 'argumentative' American

Economics may not seem to many a compelling argument to do away with the death penalty. Lalita Panicker reports.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Jan 29, 2011 11:45 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, New Delhi

Economics may not seem to many a compelling argument to do away with the death penalty. Eminent legal activist and senior lecturer at the Northwestern University School of Law, Leigh Buchanan Bienen, however, argues her case that capital punishment cases are far more economically wasteful than life cases with great clarity. In the Capital recently, she was modest about her untiring efforts to have the death penalty repealed in the state of Illinois.

She is no bleeding-heart activist even though she has seen up close how the murder of a loved one tears the families of both the victim and perpetrator apart. In many cases, she feels that the impulse for vengeance is justified. She just feels that the criminal justice system is far from perfect and that any ambiguity in the death penalty is unacceptable. "Illinois had a capital litigation fund to finance the legal process in homicide cases. In the course of my research, I found that money was taken from the fund for 507 cases on the plea that these were capital cases. Many of them did not go to capital case trial and the money was never paid back." In other words, litigators were able to get their hands on public money for cases, which never went to trial eventually as capital cases.

Life imprisonment, she feels, serves the purpose of deterrence. In the case of many on death row, she says that reviews often threw up evidence proving innocence. This meant millions of dollars in damages to the state.

As a result of efforts by people like her, public support for the death penalty is much lower in the US than before. The system is so arbitrary that the death sentence can rarely be justified. But she says litigators like nothing more than capital cases with their publicity and drama.

In reply to a ghoulish question on which is the best method to implement the death penalty, she says it is hanging if properly done. Nothing grips public attention quite so much as an execution but the state cannot pander to these baser instincts. But she says it is an endlessly seductive subject and one in which she feels that she has many more milestones to cross.


    Lalita Panicker leads the opinion section at Hindustan Times. Over a 33-year career, she has specialised in gender issues, reproductive health, child rights, politics and social engineering.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • JNU vice-chancellor (VC) Santishree Dhulipudi Pandit

    10% of students are 'troublemakers': JNU VC on campus politics, violence

    Ninety per cent of students at the Jawaharlal Nehru University are apolitical and only 10 per cent are "troublemakers" who think they can build their political careers at the varsity, Vice Chancellor Santishree Dhulipudi Pandit said on Wednesday. The JNU is the graveyard of political careers. You know last time what happened, all who did (such) politics are in jail," Pandit said. Kanhaiya Kumar is now in the Congress party.

  • Police swung into action after a video of the incident went viral on social media. (File image)

    MP: Tribal woman assaulted, forced to carry her husband on shoulder

    A 42-year-old woman was allegedly beaten up and forced to carry her husband on shoulders in Khargone district for allegedly leaving her husband and staying with her uncle, police said on Wednesday. This is the second such incident reported from Madhya Pradesh in the past two days when a tribal woman was harassed for leaving her husband's house. He came to the village in Khargone and beat up her uncle.

  • The woman’s parents had posted her wedding invitation on social media and also sent soft copies of the invitation to their relatives through WhatsApp on June 10 (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

    Man arrested for hacking woman’s Instagram account in a bid to defame her

    Mumbai A man from Uttar Pradesh has been arrested for allegedly hacking a city woman's Instagram account days before her wedding and announcing that she was going to run away before the wedding. The woman, a resident of Goregaon east, was engaged in May and got married last month. The police officers then learnt that the number from which the woman's Instagram page was hacked was being used in Uttar Pradesh.

  • The company said on its website that it was engaged in the making and marketing pharmaceutical products and APIs (Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients) and has 17 manufacturing units across the country.  (Representational image)

    I-T raids Dolo-650 manufacturer Micro Lab's office in Bengaluru

    The Income Tax department Wednesday conducted searches at the premises of Bengaluru-based pharmaceutical company Micro Labs Ltd, the manufacturers of Dolo-650 tablet that was widely used by Covid-19 patients during the last over two years, on charges of alleged tax evasion. Officials said the department is looking at financial documents, balance sheets and business distributor networks of the company as part of the searches.

  • Trinaool Congress MP Mahua Moitra courted a controversy after she made a statement that Kaali is a ‘meat eating and alcohol accepting Goddess’ to her. (File Photo)

    Offerings to Kaali vary from place to place, say priests after Moitra’s remarks

    A day after the Trinamool Congress condemned its Lok Sabha MP Mahua Moitra's statement that Kaali is a “meat eating and alcohol accepting Goddess” to her and the Bharatiya Janata Party demanded her arrest on charges of hurting Hindu religious sentiments, many priests and believers on Wednesday echoed Moitra's line and said that offerings to Kaali do vary from place to place.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, July 06, 2022