HT Image
HT Image

For filmmakers, the risk is worth taking

When it is not offering emotional sustenance to this country’s millions of captive audience, or making them sing and dance, then Bollywood must be stirring big controversies. Zia Haq finds out.
By Zia Haq | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON FEB 23, 2008 10:44 PM IST

When it is not offering emotional sustenance to this country’s millions of captive audience, or making them sing and dance, then Bollywood must be stirring big controversies. Historical sword-and-scandal spectacles more so.

Directors have often ended up with bloody noses. Film-maker Mahesh Bhatt, now known more for his speaking mind, says: “In our country, as elsewhere, creative freedom comes with a heavy price tag and the controversies are more engineered than a natural fallout.”

“This is not just because of increasing sensitivity to issues like caste and lineage because of political fragmentation, but also because of ‘tabloidisation’ of a 24X7 media,” he says. The dispute over Ashutosh Gowariker’s Jodhaa Akbar, for example, would not have spread like wildfire had it not been for the hourly updates on theatres backing out, adds Bhatt.

Bollywood’s brush with controversy has been fairly episodic and film-makers have touched a raw nerve from time to time. Director Rajkumar Santoshi found his effigies being burnt after right-wingers objected to dialogues on Ramayana in Lajja, a story about three women and their struggle, with Madhuri Dikshit in the lead role.

“I think film-makers do take in account enough checks and balances and do not just ride rough shod over public sentiments for a creative high,” says Shriram Raghavan, the director of Ek Hasina Thi and more recently Johnny Gaddar. The Indian audience, he says, normally has evolved to accept a wide range of subjects. “The real controversy is not whipped up by the cynical common man but by people with vested interests,” Raghavan adds.

In Hollywood, reactions have been more in the realm of debate than quarrel. Film-maker Sudhir Mishra of Hazaron Khwaishen Aisi says a lot of Hollywood films on Vietnam, especially John Wayne type of films, and those dealing with Biblical subjects have been deeply controversial and offensive too. “300 (a Hollywood production) was offensive to all Iranians, Persians and me. The sensibility of the film offended me, not its technique. But that doesn’t mean I will pull down the screens,” he says. Historical movies are a double-edged sword and Jodhaa Akbar was a risk worth taking, says Ram Mirchandani, the vice-president of UTV Motion Pictures, the company that produced Jodhaa Akbar. Controversial Hollywood movies, though crtiticised, are not only widely viewed but these go on to garner awards.

Martin Scorsese’s The Last Temptation Of Christ, a controversial and challenging adaptation of Nikos Kazantzakis’s 1955 best-selling novel of the same name was nominated Best Director by the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences. The film was objected to for a non-explicit scene of Jesus procreating with his wife. The film did state in a pre-credits disclaimer: “This film is not based on the Gospels.”

The Time magazine review of Elia Kazan’s Baby Doll, a film even more scandalous than Lolita, declared: “possibly the dirtiest American-made motion picture that has ever been legally exhibited.” It went on to garner the Golden Globe award for Best Director; was nominated for four other Golden Globes, four Academy awards and one British Academy award.

Historical cinema will remain the hotbed of controversy and disagreement, because, in Bhatt’s words: “It essentially has to do with highly individualised assertion of memory on the part of the audience.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Parineeti Chopra will be seen next in The Girl on the Train.
Parineeti Chopra will be seen next in The Girl on the Train.

Parineeti Chopra wants to erase the time she was 'hugely overweight'

UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 10:03 PM IST
  • Parineeti Chopra, on being asked about a time in her life she would like to forget, said that she would like to erase her college days as she was 'hugely overweight' at the time.
Close
Kajol and Ajay Devgn celebrate their 22nd wedding anniversary on Wedesday.(Twitter)
Kajol and Ajay Devgn celebrate their 22nd wedding anniversary on Wedesday.(Twitter)

Tanishaa Mukherji wishes sister Kajol, Ajay Devgn on their wedding anniversary

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 09:23 PM IST
  • Tanishaa Mukherji wished her sister Kajol and brother-in-law Ajay Devgn on their 2nd wedding anniversary.
Close
Nakuul Mehta and Jankee Parekh became parents to Sufi earlier this month.
Nakuul Mehta and Jankee Parekh became parents to Sufi earlier this month.

Nakuul Mehta’s wife Jankee Parekh reveals 'new mom problems' after son’s birth

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 08:42 PM IST
  • Nakuul Mehta’s wife Jankee Parekh revealed how her life has changed after the birth of their son, Sufi. She said that she is busy with mommy duties, leaving her little time for social media activities.
Close
Taimur Ali Khan clicked in Bandra.(Varinder Chawla)
Taimur Ali Khan clicked in Bandra.(Varinder Chawla)

Taimur steps out in Bandra, a day after Kareena's discharge from hospital

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 08:06 PM IST
Saif Ali Khan and Kareena Kapoor Khan's elder son, Taimur, was clicked on an outing on Wednesday. See photos here.
Close
Alia Bhatt as Gangubai Kathiawadi.
Alia Bhatt as Gangubai Kathiawadi.

Gangubai Kathiawadi teaser: SRK and Akshay praise Alia, call her 'gangsta'

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 07:43 PM IST
A number of Bollywood celebrities, including Akshay Kumar and Shah Rukh Khan, have showered praises on Alia Bhatt and said that they are looking forward to her movie, Gangubai Kathiawadi.
Close
Kangana Ranaut as J Jayalalithaa in Thalaivi.
Kangana Ranaut as J Jayalalithaa in Thalaivi.

Thalaivi teaser out: Kangana Ranaut to show how Jayalalithaa made history

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 07:09 PM IST
  • Kangana Ranaut announced the release date of her upcoming Jayalalithaa biopic, Thalaivi, with a short teaser. The film, directed by AL Vijay, will release on April 23.
Close
Rubina Dilaik won Bigg Boss 14 on Sunday.
Rubina Dilaik won Bigg Boss 14 on Sunday.

Bigg Boss 14: Rubina Dilaik answers if Rahul Vaidya is a ‘friend or enemy'

UPDATED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:35 PM IST
Bigg Boss 14 winner Rubina Dilaik conducted an Ask Me Anything session on Twitter on Wednesday evening. She talked about what she misses about the show and the first thing she did with her phone after getting it back, among other things.
Close
BTS singer Jungkook flaunts his blue hair colour.
BTS singer Jungkook flaunts his blue hair colour.

BTS: Jungkook dyes his hair blue and ARMY is convinced his mixtape is on its way

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:10 PM IST
  • BTS singer Jungkook took to Twitter and shared a selfie flaunting his blue hair. The singer caused a frenzy among fans and left a few wondering if the hair colour change has something to do with his mixtape.
Close
Rakhi Sawant poses with Salman Khan.
Rakhi Sawant poses with Salman Khan.

Rakhi shares photos from Bigg Boss 14 after-party, featuring 'brother' Salman

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:07 PM IST
Sharing pictures from the Bigg Boss 14 after-party, Rakhi Sawant gave a shout-out to her 'brother' Salman Khan and hoped for all his wishes to come true. She was a finalist on the show, while he was the host.
Close
Priyanka Chopra Jonas reacts after a social media user criticises her ball-shaped dress.
Priyanka Chopra Jonas reacts after a social media user criticises her ball-shaped dress.

Priyanka Chopra slams troll who asked 'what's the point of having a figure?'

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 06:00 PM IST
  • Priyanka Chopra Jonas reacted to a social media user criticised her now-viral ball-shaped outfit. Earlier, Priyanka shared a bunch of memes inspired by her dress.
Close
Gauahar Khan lauds her in-laws for their constant support.
Gauahar Khan lauds her in-laws for their constant support.

Gauahar Khan praises in-laws for support after her father gets hospitalised

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:59 PM IST
  • Gauahar Khan revealed her father has been admitted to a hospital. The actor took to Instagram and shared pictures of how her husband Zaid Darbar and in-laws are supporting her.
Close
Actor Sanya Malhotra began her career in Hindi films with Dangal in 2016.
Actor Sanya Malhotra began her career in Hindi films with Dangal in 2016.

Birthday girl Sanya Malhotra: In my fifth year in Bollywood, it’s surreal, can’t believe I am living my dream

By Rishabh Suri
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:50 PM IST
Actor Sanya Malhotra, who turns year older on February 25, talks about returning to her home town to celebrate the day, and entering the fifth year of her stint in Bollywood.
Close
Actor Shahid Kapoor celebrates his 40th birthday on February 25.
Actor Shahid Kapoor celebrates his 40th birthday on February 25.

Happy Birthday Shahid Kapoor: The evolution, the many facets of his career

By Juhi Chakraborty
PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:45 PM IST
On Shahid Kapoor’s 40th birthday (February 25), we take a look at how his career panned over the past 18 years, the highs, the lows and the new phase.
Close
Ayushmann Khurrana with his fans in Shillong.
Ayushmann Khurrana with his fans in Shillong.

Ayushmann's fans gatecrash Shillong hotel, actor makes sure to meet them. Watch

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:26 PM IST
  • Ayushmann Khurrana made sure to interact with his fans in Shillong by promptly coming down to meet them after they gathered at his Shillong hotel. Watch here
Close
Though Preetika works intermittently, she admits to being in a content space.
Though Preetika works intermittently, she admits to being in a content space.

People are often surprised that I gave Bollywood a skip for television: Preetika Rao

PUBLISHED ON FEB 24, 2021 05:07 PM IST
She reveals that though she had plum offers like Aashiqui 2, and Pradeep Sarkar, Vashu Bhagnani, Kumar Taurani offered her films, she chose to do TV as bikini and kissing had become mandatory in most films and she wasn’t comfortable with that.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP