HT Image
HT Image

Home is where our heart is

Taslima Nasreen, whose resident permit expires this week and who still does not know whether it will be extended or not, must be allowed to stay in India, writes Mahmood Farooqui.
By Mahmood Farooqui | None
UPDATED ON FEB 11, 2008 10:16 PM IST

It is said that after he announced his Prophethood, Hazrat Mohammed suffered severe persecution in Mecca. The vitriol and calumny extended from the verbal to the physical. There was one woman who would always throw filth on him whenever he passed by her house. He would unfailingly take the same route every day and she would invariably throw filth on him. He never protested. One day as he passed her house, she was missing. He inquired after her and learning that she was sick he went up to her room, and finding her bed-ridden, tended to her.

I grew up listening to a lot of stories from my grandmother about the Prophet Mohammed. Told in an anecdotal form, the stories largely avoided his image as a conqueror and concentrated instead on his personality, especially his grace under hardship. I narrate this story especially to remind my compatriots about what they might do when faced with hostility or criticism.

I write this particularly in the context of Taslima Nasreen, whose resident permit expires this week and who still does not know whether it will be extended or not. Nasreen must be given an opportunity to stay on in India and must be provided that opportunity not as grace or favour but because she is, as a South Asian, as a fellow human, fully entitled to it. My appeal rests not merely on a liberal idea of freedom of expression, or on making this a litmus test for India’s pluralism. India’s pluralism, where it exists in practice, is not dependent on appeals or testimonials from intellectuals. Our pluralism does not — and has not — precluded violent confrontations between different social groups. However, we also have countervailing traditions of coming to a working adjustment with each other, which, as an aside, partly explains why the word ‘adjust’ is so popular in all Indian languages.

Denying her asylum is not, suddenly, going to make India less pluralistic or more intolerant than it currently is. It would not, anyway, be unprecedented. We have banned books enough, books which continue to circulate anyway, and have gagged and arrested authors and artists too. It is also not — for me — a case for harking back to the first principles of freedom of expression. I could question the value of freedom of expression in a society where large minorities do not have the freedom to be, but I will let that pass for the moment. We all know what Voltaire said about difference of opinions, and, of course, we know much less about how much he himself deviated from that maxim. But it is more important for us to find ways of understanding that maxim that makes sense to our traditions of treating certain matters with reverence and veneration.

I can’t say whether Nasreen erred in writing what she did, which we, of course, do not know much about. She grew up in a society dominated by an Islam which, unlike in India, is, in many ways, an ‘establishment religion’. In such circumstances, questioning authority can easily lead to questioning traditions that are sanctified in the name of religion and in patriarchal societies, authority needs to be questioned. There are, of course, ways of questioning patriarchal religions and we may find some ways less appealing than ours; in fact, some ways may arouse our just wrath. But in civilised societies, the sort of society the Islamic Prophet wanted to build, wrath should not — cannot — lead to mob judgments about a person’s right to live.

It would be easy to dismiss demonstrations against Nasreen in Calcutta and elsewhere. Especially after the recent events in Bombay, we know how easily demonstrations can be mounted and how transient passions can be manufactured. The thousands of young men roaming the streets of Calcutta were probably ‘good Muslims’, in some ways, but who would, perhaps, flout many Islamic injunctions and taboos in their everyday lives. Like watching films, at one time regarded (at least in my family) as an absolute kufr (act of infidelity), or ogling at women. Nevertheless, they have the right as Muslims to be upset about somebody’s attitude. However, I also know that feelings about Nasreen run wider than the Calcuttan community. Not all that strong feeling, however, will translate into stone-throwing or demanding her death or banishment.

To those who are upset about what Nasreen has said and done, I would say that she has already suffered enough. She has spent 12 years in Europe in exile and had she simply hated Bangladesh and loved the West — as some believe to be the case — she could have gone on living there. She has been buffeted around from Calcutta to Jaipur to Delhi, where she lives almost as a pariah, unable to move, unable to do things she would like to do, to go to places she would like to go to. She is deprived, currently, of normal human freedoms.

But even if she hadn’t suffered, even if she was merrily partying every night with the swish set of Delhi, she still has the right to demand and receive asylum in this country. Besides she has already been gagged; she will dare not say the things she has already said, she has already agreed to delete pages from her forthcoming books; she has already lost. And so have we.

I understand an emasculated community’s need for symbolic sops such as exiling Nasreen or banning Rushdie. But to the community or (it not being a monolith) to those among them who feel passionately about this, and to our political class, I would urge the avoidance of false pursuits. Freedom of expression is not absolute. When free from coercion of our rulers we may become victims of ideological fetters. But Nasreen is a dissenter and in spite of Voltaire, we must protect dissenters. She must stay in India because we must be free to criticise and not unfree to criticise in return. In the name of Islamic values, we must protect her and listen to her specially.

Mahmood Farooqui is a Delhi-based dastango and writer.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
A health worker collects a swab sample for a Covid-19 test at Anand Vihar Bus Terminal, in New Delhi, India,( Photo by Raj K Raj/ Hindustan Times)
A health worker collects a swab sample for a Covid-19 test at Anand Vihar Bus Terminal, in New Delhi, India,( Photo by Raj K Raj/ Hindustan Times)

6 states contributed to 86.37% of new Covid-19 cases, says govt

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:14 PM IST
The states have been advised to increase Covid-19 testing and develop strategies with respect to potential super spreading events.
Close
Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) launches the Brazilian satellite Amazonia-1 from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota.(PTI)
Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) launches the Brazilian satellite Amazonia-1 from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota.(PTI)

PM Modi congratulates Bolsonaro on successful launch of Amazonia-1 satellite

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:15 PM IST
  • The launch took place from Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota in Andhra Pradesh.
Close
IPS officer Sanjeeb Panda tweeted about the fire this morning.(Courtesy- Twitter)
IPS officer Sanjeeb Panda tweeted about the fire this morning.(Courtesy- Twitter)

Narrow escape for Odisha IPS officers as 3 Satkosia eco retreat tents catch fire

By Debabrata Mohanty, Bhubaneswar
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:05 PM IST
  • Transport commissioner Sanjeeb Panda and his IPS officer wife Santosh Bala (Home department special secretary), were in one of the three tents that caught fire.
Close
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee. (File photo)(HT_PRINT)
West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee. (File photo)(HT_PRINT)

News updates from HT: ABP-C-Voter opinion poll predicts edge for TMC in Bengal

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:01 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
The Bombay high court. (HT File Photo)
The Bombay high court. (HT File Photo)

Bombay HC refuses to interfere in physical criteria for medical admission

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:56 PM IST
  • The petitioner had moved the high court in January this year after she was declared ineligible for admission to an undergraduate medical course as her left hand was amputated.
Close
The victim’s daughter discovered her mother lying in the house in a pool of blood on Saturday night.(Representational Photo/Getty Images)
The victim’s daughter discovered her mother lying in the house in a pool of blood on Saturday night.(Representational Photo/Getty Images)

70-year-old woman murdered in her house in Kalyan, police hunt for clues

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:52 PM IST
  • Police said the killer slit the elderly woman's throat with a sharp weapon.
Close
PM Modi addressed the 74th episode of his monthly program Mann Ki Baat., which was broadcast live on various government channels and his YouTube channel.(PTI)
PM Modi addressed the 74th episode of his monthly program Mann Ki Baat., which was broadcast live on various government channels and his YouTube channel.(PTI)

'Regret not learning Tamil' over the years, says PM Modi on Mann Ki Baat

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shivani, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:57 PM IST
  • "I did not learn Tamil. It is such a beautiful language, which is popular all over the world," the prime minister said.
Close
The Prime Minister also shared two video clips of a guided tour of the Statue of Unity in Gujarat’s Kevadia and another of a commentary at a cricket match in Varanasi in Sanskrit.
The Prime Minister also shared two video clips of a guided tour of the Statue of Unity in Gujarat’s Kevadia and another of a commentary at a cricket match in Varanasi in Sanskrit.

On Mann Ki Baat, PM Modi shares his ‘regret of sorts’

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Meenakshi Ray, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:50 PM IST
On his monthly radio programme Mann Ki Baat, PM Modi said he regrets that he could not learn the world's oldest language Tamil.
Close
Congress' 'war' room in Delhi will be without Ahmed Patel this time.
Congress' 'war' room in Delhi will be without Ahmed Patel this time.

Congress 'war' room abuzz with activity as battle for 4 states, 1 UT draws near

By Saubhadra Chatterji, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 12:30 PM IST
  • The rising demand for the ‘war room’ also coincides with the shrinking real estate space for the Congress in the national capital.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi said students must apply the techniques of revision and smart ways of memorisation during their exams.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi said students must apply the techniques of revision and smart ways of memorisation during their exams.

Be warriors not worriers: PM Modi tells students set to appear in exams

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Meenakshi Ray, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:58 AM IST
The Prime Minister also said on Mann Ki Baat that just like every year he will interact with students and teachers during his ‘Pariksha Pe Charcha’ programme.
Close
The guidelines also make it mandatory for platforms such as Twitter and WhatsApp to identify the originator of a message that authorities consider to be anti-national and against the security and sovereignty of the country.(REUTERS)
The guidelines also make it mandatory for platforms such as Twitter and WhatsApp to identify the originator of a message that authorities consider to be anti-national and against the security and sovereignty of the country.(REUTERS)

Links for virtual court hearings can't be shared on WhatsApp groups, says SC

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:58 AM IST
The step was taken in the wake of the newly notified Information Technology (Guidelines for intermediaries and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 (IT Rules, 2021).
Close
The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), that frames policy for the tax department, meanwhile, said it was fully prepared to check and monitor the role of money in influencing voters.(MINT File photo )
The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT), that frames policy for the tax department, meanwhile, said it was fully prepared to check and monitor the role of money in influencing voters.(MINT File photo )

Income Tax raids ceramic tiles magnate in Chennai

PTI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:03 PM IST
The CBDT said in a statement that 8.30 crore cash was seized during the raids on the group engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of tiles and sanitaryware.
Close
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi speaks during his election campaign ahead of Tamil Nadu assembly polls, in Tirunelveli district. (PTI Photo)
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi speaks during his election campaign ahead of Tamil Nadu assembly polls, in Tirunelveli district. (PTI Photo)

'If you dare...': Rahul's latest challenge to PM Modi ahead of Mann Ki Baat

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:46 AM IST
  • Gandhi has on several occasions attacked the government over the three farm laws, alleging that they are intended to benefit "handful of PM Modi’s friends".
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday outlined that the country now has to step out from an import-dependent status and fast track its defence manufacturing capabilities. (PTI Photo)(PTI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday outlined that the country now has to step out from an import-dependent status and fast track its defence manufacturing capabilities. (PTI Photo)(PTI)

On Mann Ki Baat, PM Modi pushes for 'lab to land' mantra

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Kanishka Sarkar, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:44 AM IST
Prime Minister Narendra Modi also remembered scientist Dr CV Raman on National Science Day that marks the discovery of the 'Raman Effect.'
Close
Security personnel launch a Cordon and Search Operation (CASO), in Srinagar on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)
Security personnel launch a Cordon and Search Operation (CASO), in Srinagar on Wednesday. (ANI Photo)

Eatery owner's son, injured in Srinagar militant attack, succumbs 11 day later

By Ashiq Hussain
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 11:47 AM IST
  • The victims was being treated at Shri Maharaja Hari Singh hospital in Srinagar where he was on ventilator.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP