Homosexuality is considered a taboo in a largely conservative Indian society which appears to be divided on the controversial issue.(PTI Photo)
Homosexuality is considered a taboo in a largely conservative Indian society which appears to be divided on the controversial issue.(PTI Photo)

SC hearing on gay sex: All you need to know about Section 377

Homosexuality is considered a taboo in a largely conservative Indian society which appears to be divided on the controversial issue.
By Satya Prakash | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 02, 2016 03:21 PM IST

The Supreme Court’s decision to hear in open court curative petitions – the last legal recourse available to litigants – on Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) is an opportunity for it to rectify the mistake of re-criminalising homosexuality in the country.

Typically, judges decide a curative petition after discussing it among themselves through a procedure called “hearing by circulation”. The fact that the top court has departed from established practice of not hearing oral submissions on curative petitions is perhaps a judicial acknowledgement of changing social realities on the contentious issue.

The law

Section 377 of IPC -- which came into force in 1862 -- defines unnatural offences. It says, “Whoever voluntarily has carnal inter­course against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to 10 years, and shall also be liable to fine.”

Delhi HC legalises homosexuality

The Delhi High Court had in July 2009 de-criminalised consensual homosexual acts in private by declaring as unconstitutional a part of Section 377 of IPC that criminalises unnatural sex, saying “the section denies a gay person a right to full personhood…”

Read more: LGBT community pins hope on SC hearing Section 377 plea

SC re-criminalises homosexuality

The Supreme Court chose to reverse the verdict in December 2013. Upholding the constitutional validity of Section 377 IPC, an SC bench headed by Justice GS Singhvi (since retired), put the ball in the Parliament’s court, saying it was for the legislature to take a call on the desirability of the controversial provision.

Homosexuality a taboo

Homosexuality is considered a taboo in a largely conservative Indian society which appears to be divided on the controversial issue. Freedom loving people (not necessarily belonging to Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender or LGBT community) want homosexuality de-criminalised but many still consider it a “deviant behaviour” and not merely a question of one’s sexual orientation or preference.

Implications for heterosexuals

The case has implications for heterosexuals also, as consensual sexual acts of adults such as oral and anal sex in private are currently treated as unnatural and punishable under Section 377 IPC.

Emerging political consensus

Successive governments have defended the archaic Section 377 IPC which is based on 19th century Victorian morality. But the intense debate in the society and the media appears to have forced the political class to change its stance.

After eluding it for years, political consensus is building on the issue. The BJP which had supported the Supreme Court’s verdict upholding Section 377 IPC now appears to support the Delhi High Court de-criminalising consensual homosexual acts in private.

“When millions of people world over are having alternative sexual preferences, it is too late in the day to propound a view that they should be jailed. The Delhi high court’s view appears more acceptable,” senior BJP leader and finance minister Arun Jaitley had said in November last year, expressing his personal opinion.

Jaitley’s view was supported by senior Congress leader P Chidambaram. Even otherwise, Congress has openly supported legalising homosexuality. Aam Admi Party and Communist Party of India-Marxist are also said to be in support of declaring Section 377 unconstitutional.

SC verdict on transgenders

In its landmark April 2014, verdict hailed by gender rights activists, the top court directed the government to declare transgenders a ‘third gender’ and include them in the OBC quota. Underlining the need to bring them into the mainstream, it said they should have all rights under law, including marriage, adoption, divorce, succession and inheritance.

PM Narendra Modi on transgenders

In November 2015, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had regretted the deplorable condition of transgenders in Indian society and said governments needed to change their outlook.? “We need to amend and make new laws for transgenders,” he had said at the foundation day celebration of National Legal Services Authority (NALSA). The NDA government has prepared a draft law recognising the rights of transgenders with a view to ensure they are not discriminated against. All these developments allude to the change in the mindset of the top court and the government.

International developments

There have been many positive developments in favour of LGBT community on the international front. In May 2015, Ireland legalised same-sex marriage. The country which had decriminalized homosexuality in 1993 became the first country to allow same sex marriage a national level by popular vote.

In June 2015, the US Supreme Court ruled that same sex marriages were legal. Near home, Nepal legalized homosexuality in 2007 and the new Constitution of the country too gives many rights to the LGBT community.

France, UK, Canada, United States, Australia and Brazil have de-criminalised homosexuality. Other countries like Belgium, Brazil, Canada,France, Iceland, Ireland, Luxembourg, Norway, Portugal,South Africa, Spain, Sweden and Uruguay allow either same sex marriage or a civil union.

India currently stands with a host of countries such as Nigeria, Ghana, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Mauritania, Qatar and Pakistan which criminalizes homosexuality.

Child abuse and Section 377

Many child rights activists had criticised the Delhi HC verdict de-criminalising homosexuality on the ground that Section 377 was needed to be on the statute book to tackle cases of child abuse. But after the enactment of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act 2012, there is need to use Section 377 in child sexual abuse cases. POCSO is more child-friendly and much more stringent.

Law and morality

Those against legalising homosexuality argue that it is against the moral values of the society. What is forbidden in religion need not be prohibited in law. Morality cannot be a ground to restrict the fundamental rights of citizens. A legal wrong is necessarily a moral wrong but vice versa is not correct. A moral wrong becomes a legal wrong only when its consequences are for society and not just the person/s committing it.

Real questions

But the real question relates to the constitutional rights of LGBT community. The 2013 SC verdict criminalising homosexual acts goes against established constitutional principles of personal liberty, equality before law and non-discrimination on the basis of sex or sexual preferences.

Presuming that homosexuality is against the prevailing social morality, a perceived larger interest of the society be given precedence over individual liberty and right to privacy guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution? Can the State or society regulate the sexual preference and behaviour of consenting adults in private?

SC must draw ‘Lakshman Rekha’ for State

The Supreme Court will have to find the right answers to these questions.

The role of the State and society is to provide congenial atmosphere to individuals to make them realise their potential so as to give their best to the society. Obstructing individual freedom and criminalising their intimate moments cannot help to achieve this objective.

The SC must draw a ‘Lakshman Rekha’ for the State, which cannot be allowed to peep into the bedroom of consenting adults on the ground of their preference for “unnatural sex”.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Covid-19 vaccines will be administered on all working days by trained healthcare workers inside the Parliament complex. (REUTERS PHOTO).
Covid-19 vaccines will be administered on all working days by trained healthcare workers inside the Parliament complex. (REUTERS PHOTO).

Vaccination centre for eligible MPs set up inside Parliament complex

PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 08:03 PM IST
  • Nearly half or 366 out of 777 MPs are eligible for Covid-19 vaccines in the category of elderly people. 47% of MPs are above sixty years of age and meet the criteria for elderly people who can get vaccinated in the current phase.
Close
A nurse prepares to administer a shot of the Covishield COVID-19 vaccine at Sola Civil hospital in Ahmedabad, India, Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The COVID-19 vaccination drive for senior citizens and those above 45 years of age with comorbidities began in government and designated private hospitals in Gujarat on Monday along with the rest of the country. (AP Photo/Ajit Solanki)(AP)
A nurse prepares to administer a shot of the Covishield COVID-19 vaccine at Sola Civil hospital in Ahmedabad, India, Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The COVID-19 vaccination drive for senior citizens and those above 45 years of age with comorbidities began in government and designated private hospitals in Gujarat on Monday along with the rest of the country. (AP Photo/Ajit Solanki)(AP)

Covid-19 vaccination for veterans to begin at service hospitals next week: Army

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:49 PM IST
  • There are more than 3.2 million ex-servicemen (ESM) in the country, and many of them have been waiting to get vaccinated at service hospitals.
Close
A nurse prepares to administer a shot of the Covishield COVID-19 vaccine at Sola Civil hospital in Ahmedabad, India, Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The COVID-19 vaccination drive for senior citizens and those above 45 years of age with comorbidities began in government and designated private hospitals in Gujarat on Monday along with the rest of the country. (AP Photo/Ajit Solanki)(AP)
A nurse prepares to administer a shot of the Covishield COVID-19 vaccine at Sola Civil hospital in Ahmedabad, India, Wednesday, March 3, 2021. The COVID-19 vaccination drive for senior citizens and those above 45 years of age with comorbidities began in government and designated private hospitals in Gujarat on Monday along with the rest of the country. (AP Photo/Ajit Solanki)(AP)

Gujarat health official tests positive for Covid-19 after two doses of vaccine

PTI, Ahmedabad
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:27 PM IST
The health officer in Gandhinagar's Dehgam taluk, had taken the first dose on January 16 and the second one on February 15.
Close
Farmers sitting near their tractor as they take part in a road blockade to mark the 100th day of the protest against the new farm laws on a highway near Kundli Border on Saturday. (ANI Photo)
Farmers sitting near their tractor as they take part in a road blockade to mark the 100th day of the protest against the new farm laws on a highway near Kundli Border on Saturday. (ANI Photo)

Protesting farmers block expressway in Haryana as agitation completes 100th day

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:20 PM IST
The road blockade began at 11 am and continued till 4 pm. Farmers holding black flags and wearing black armbands and some women protesters with black 'dupattas' shouted slogans against the BJP-led government for not acceding to their demands.
Close
Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur presents the budget of the state for the year 2021-22 in the assembly in Shimla on March 6, 2021. (ANI Photo)
Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur presents the budget of the state for the year 2021-22 in the assembly in Shimla on March 6, 2021. (ANI Photo)

Himachal Pradesh budget 'directionless', says Congress

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 07:10 PM IST
Leader of Opposition Mukesh Agnihotri said the budget presented in the state Assembly was a "half-baked document" in which false promises had been made to the people of the state.
Close
Shortly before midnight, the Senate began to take up a variety of amendments in rapid-fire fashion.(AP)
Shortly before midnight, the Senate began to take up a variety of amendments in rapid-fire fashion.(AP)

Senate works through night with virus aid on path to passage

AP, Washington
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:44 PM IST
The bill then would return to the House, which was expected to give it final congressional approval and send it to Biden to sign.
Close
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath.

Adityanath meets farmers from western UP, says laws will double their income

ANI, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:31 PM IST
According to a statement by the state government, the members of the delegation said the agricultural laws implemented by the central government are farmer-friendly.
Close
In all, 3,500 people were accused by the CBI in different cases.(AFP File)
In all, 3,500 people were accused by the CBI in different cases.(AFP File)

CBI launches probe into smuggling of rotten betel nuts to India

By Neeraj Chauhan
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:25 PM IST
  • The agency has registered a First Information Report (FIR) naming unknown officials of Central Excise and Customs and unknown private persons for causing huge losses adding up to several hundred crores to the government exchequer.
Close
High security outside Antilia at Altamont road after a car laden with gelatin sticks has been found abandoned near billionaire Mukesh Ambani's Antilia residence in Mumbai on Friday. (ANI Photo)
High security outside Antilia at Altamont road after a car laden with gelatin sticks has been found abandoned near billionaire Mukesh Ambani's Antilia residence in Mumbai on Friday. (ANI Photo)

Oppn questions probe into death of 'owner' of vehicle found near Ambani's house

Posted by Shivani | PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 06:18 PM IST
Shiv Sena leader and Rajya Sabha member Sanjay Raut said the Sena-led Maharashtra government should not be put in the dock over the death of a prime witness, but finding out the truth was imporant for the coalition government's image.
Close
Union minister Smriti Irani addresses a press conference, in New Delhi.(PTI)
Union minister Smriti Irani addresses a press conference, in New Delhi.(PTI)

Smriti Irani attacks Rahul Gandhi, accuses him of 'insulting' people of Amethi

PTI, Amethi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:59 PM IST
Smriti Irani attacks Rahul Gandhi, accuses him of 'insulting' people of Amethi
Close
Aurangabad has added 1,737 fresh cases to the overall tally since March 1 and a total of 17 patients have succumbed to the disease in the same period.(HT file photo)
Aurangabad has added 1,737 fresh cases to the overall tally since March 1 and a total of 17 patients have succumbed to the disease in the same period.(HT file photo)

Aurangabad officials mull lockdown as Covid-19 cases continue to rise

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Shivani, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:52 PM IST
  • Aurangabad has a total caseload of 52,103 infections while the death toll stands at 1,284. On Friday, the district added 459 cases to the overall state tally.
Close
"Accelerate vaccination for priority population groups in districts reporting higher cases," the ministry said.(Reuters)
"Accelerate vaccination for priority population groups in districts reporting higher cases," the ministry said.(Reuters)

Centre asks states witnessing spike in Covid-19 cases to accelerate vaccination

PTI, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:30 PM IST
In a meeting held on Saturday, they have been asked to collaborate with private hospitals to open up vaccination time-table for a minimum of 15 days and maximum of 28 days at a time.
Close
The SP said the victim's brother-in-law got her married to a man in Ghazipur district, but after 10 years, when her husband came to know that she was raped, he divorced her and she returned to Udhampur.(Representational )
The SP said the victim's brother-in-law got her married to a man in Ghazipur district, but after 10 years, when her husband came to know that she was raped, he divorced her and she returned to Udhampur.(Representational )

Raped 27 yrs ago, woman lodges complaint after son asks father's name

PTI, Shahjahanpur
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:20 PM IST
One Naki Hasan of her locality had entered the house when she was alone and allegedly raped her, Superintendent of Police (City) Sanjay Kumar told PTI on Saturday.
Close
A top official of the state's home department had said on Friday that 16 people from Myanmar have crossed over to India over the last few days, of which 11 have claimed that they were police personnel. (Representative Image)(REUTERS)
A top official of the state's home department had said on Friday that 16 people from Myanmar have crossed over to India over the last few days, of which 11 have claimed that they were police personnel. (Representative Image)(REUTERS)

Myanmar asks Mizoram govt to handover eight cops who fled country

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 06, 2021 05:10 PM IST
Mizoram shares a 510-km-long porous border with Myanmar, where mass demonstrations are being held in protest against the declaration of a year-long emergency by the country's armed forces.
Close
Due to an improvement in the overall situation, authorities allowed for the reopening of colleges, universities and schools for Classes 9 to 12 in January this year with all Covid-related norms in place. (Representative Image) (Raj K Raj/ Hindustan Times)
Due to an improvement in the overall situation, authorities allowed for the reopening of colleges, universities and schools for Classes 9 to 12 in January this year with all Covid-related norms in place. (Representative Image) (Raj K Raj/ Hindustan Times)

News updates from HT: Rajasthan schools, colleges to close due to Covid surge

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 06, 2021 04:54 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP