Maintenance plea: Court refuses to give relief to HIV+ man

Updated on Nov 30, 2019 08:13 PM IST
HT Image
HT Image
By, Mumbai

A sessions court refused to entertain a plea filed by a man who sought relief from paying maintenance to his wife on the grounds that he is HIV positive and cannot work.

The husband had filed an appeal in the sessions court against a magistrate court order directing him to pay 20,000 a month to his wife.

Additional sessions judge Sunil T Soor, while rejecting the plea last week, observed, “The only contention of the appellant’s advocate is that as the appellant is suffering from HIV disease, he cannot work. But the contention is not sustainable as HIV patient cannot be debarred from working and earning.”

The husband, who used to work at a leading auditing firm, had approached the court against the magistrate court’s order to pay interim alimony to his wife, who accused him of domestic violence. The wife had filed a case under the Protection of Woman from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, alleging that her husband and in-laws deliberately suppressed the fact that he was suffering from HIV. She also claimed that he subjected her to domestic violence.

She alleged the husband indulged in sexual activities with others, and filed a case of cheating against him. During the probe, the police found he had sent vulgar messages to several women.

She demanded interim maintenance of 50,000, along with 35,000 for rent, from her husband and 1 crore from her in-laws to buy a flat in Mumbai.

Following the magistrate court’s order in the case, the husband filed an appeal in the sessions court. He pleaded that while he used to earn 75,000 a month before, he was now unemployed owing to his medical condition.

The wife contested his claim and pointed out that he was still earning 70,000 a month. She also mentioned that now she has to undergo regular medical examination for STD and HIV.

The court, after considering the arguments from both sides and their standard of living, observed, “Under the circumstances, granting interim maintenance of 20,000 per month to the applicant is not excessive.”


    Charul Shah is senior reporter covering the legal beat for Hindustan Times. She has spent over a decade in the industry covering criminal investigations and judiciary from Mumbai, Ahmedabad and Bengaluru.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Concerns have increased recently over theft of two-wheelers and multiple accused have been taken into custody over this matter. (Image source: @SPBelagavi/Twitter)

    Bengaluru crime watch: Three more bike thieves held

    Police in Karnataka have succeeded in catching three more bike thieves who were involved in two separate cases. Bike theft: Chickpete traffic police, Bengaluru. August 10 A two-wheeler thief was caught by traffic police after he was stopped for not wearing a helmet. Bike theft: Belagavi. August 10 Meanwhile, in Belagavi, Kudachi police have arrested two persons for stealing bikes in various police stations limits. As many as 26 bikes have been recovered and seized.

  • The maiden Olympic games of the region were held in Manipur in October 2018. (HT photo)

    Meghalaya to host upcoming North East Olympics Games from October 30

    Meghalaya will be hosting the upcoming North East Olympics Games beginning October 30 till November 6, 2022 in Shillong. Soon after chairing a high-level meeting between the North East Organising Committee, Directorate of Sports & Youth Affairs and the North East Olympic Association, sports & youth affairs minister Banteidor Lyngdoh stated that the sports selected were decided based on the availability of infrastructure and on the advice of the Meghalaya State Olympic Association.

  • The ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’ campaign saw support coming in from Bengaluru and elsewhere in Karnataka. (DEEPAK GUPTA/HT PHOTO/For Representation)

    ‘Har Ghar Tiranga’ campaign gains momentum in Karnataka

    The Bharatiya Janata Party's Karnataka unit on Tuesday took out a rally in Bengaluru in support of the central leadership's 'Har Ghar Tiranga' campaign in the run up to of India's 75th Independence Day. BJP National General Secretary C T Ravi along with several party workers participated in the 'Tiranga Yatra' by walking the streets with the tricolour. Not all were happy with the quality of flags.

  • The plea has challenged a March 1998 government resolution. (File image)

    Petition in Gujarat HC for SC status to Mahar community

    A petition has been filed in the Gujarat High Court by Ahmedabad based Lord Buddha Foundation seeking inclusion of the Mahar community in SC (Scheduled Caste) category. Architect of the Indian Constitution, Dr Bhim Rao Ambedkar belonged to this community and they are recognised in most states of country barring Gujarat. The word Mahar is derived from the words 'Maha' which means great and 'Rashtra' means country or “people from the great country”.

  • The mercury was expected to drop to around 35°C. (HT PHOTO)

    Overcast weather, drizzle likely in Delhi today

    Delhi's air quality was in the satisfactory category on Thursday morning as overcast weather and drizzle were likely on Thursday while the mercury was expected to drop to around 35C. On Wednesday, the average 24-hour AQI was 102 in the moderate category. An AQI between zero and 50 is considered 'good', 51 and 100 'satisfactory', 101 and 200 'moderate', 201 and 300 'poor', 301 and 400 'very poor', and 401 and 500 'severe'.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now