TB patient who is resistant to 12 out of 13 drugs could spread disease

The girl from Govandi is resistant to 12 of the 13 anti-TB drugs that are available, which according to doctors, makes her a public hazard
However, nowhere in the national TB policy is it stated that severe drug-resistant patients need to be isolated.(HT File)
However, nowhere in the national TB policy is it stated that severe drug-resistant patients need to be isolated.(HT File)
Published on Jan 25, 2017 12:11 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | ByAayushi Pratap, Mumbai

The girl from Govandi is resistant to 12 of the 13 anti-TB drugs that are available, which according to doctors, makes her a public hazard.

Despite contracting TB, she lives at home and frequently uses public transport.

“She travels in buses and local trains, just like most of us. Knowing that she possibly harbours a bacterial strain that is resistant to all other drugs, including Bedaquiline, she could be spreading the infection,” said Dr Oswal who is of the opinion that she could be placed in quarantine so that chances of her spreading the infection is diminished.

However, nowhere in the national TB policy is it stated that severe drug-resistant patients need to be isolated. “Doctors have to be cautious and make patients aware about spreading the infection in the community. We can’t stop patients from travelling,” said Dr Sunil Khaparde, deputy director general of the TB control programme

Delamanid, the drug that works in the girl’s case, may not help.“Delamanid is a highly advanced anti-TB drug, but its efficiency is questionable in her case as it has to be given in combination with other drugs, which she has already developed a resistance to,” said Dr Oswal.

He added, “If she doesn’t respond to it, there is nothing else that we can try.”

Her case, according to doctors, is a big public health concern as she could be spreading the infection to other people.

Her aunt, who takes care of her, has never been screened for the infection.

The aunt works as a helper in a local school that requires her to take care of children as young as four years old. “Doctors have asked me to get tested but I never seem to find the time,” she said, adding that her parents had contracted TB and succumbed to it.

She lost her mother to TB when she was nine and her father eight years later.

Her case comes in the backdrop of the recent case of an 18-year old from Patna, who was refused Bedaquline at Lala Ram Sarup TB Hospital in Delhi, on the grounds that she was not a resident of Delhi.

While hearing her case, the Delhi high court court stated that the ‘domicile’ of the patient is not a criterion for eligibility to Bedaquiline.

While this decision could mean that more TB patients could take Bedaquiline, the screening of these patients will have to be done very carefully, doctors said.

Doctors have also expressed concerns about calling Bedaquiline a ‘miracle drug’.

“When treating TB, there cannot be a single ‘miracle drug’. Any drug has to be given in combination with other drugs that are known to work,” said Dr Yatin Dholakia, technical advisor to Maharashtra State Anti-TB Association.

What is Bedaquiline?

Bedaquiline is an anti-TB drug used specifically to treat TB patients who are resistant to most powerful anti-TB drugs- rifampicin, isoniazid, any other core anti-TB drug and have developed multidrug-resistant tuberculosis

-It was the first anti-TB drug to be rolled out in the last 40 years

-It is an expensive anti-TB drug, manufactured by the Belgian company Janssen.

- While private doctors in India used it for patients on ‘compassionate-use-basis’, its access is now restricted.

Bedaquiline in Mumbai

- 56 patients in Mumbai are on the on-going Bedaquiline clinical trial, out of which, two patients had to be put off the treatment as they have developed side effects.

“At our centre, the patients who are on Bedaquiline are tolerating the drug very well,” said a senior doctor from the Group Of T B Hospital, Sewri, Mumbai, one of the six government run centres in India to provide the drug.

According to the World Health Organisation,

What is Multi Drug Resistance?

TB cases in which bacteria that cause tuberculosis develop resistance to at least isoniazid and rifampicin, the two most powerful anti-TB drugs.

Why does drug resistance emerge?

- Incomplete treatment

- Incorrect doses of the medicines

- Getting infected by a bacterial strain which is already resistant many drugs

Drug resistant TB cases are difficult to treat as medicines to treat them are limited. Severe forms of drug resistance result in increased mortalities.


‘Miracle’ TB drug has no effect on Mumbai teenager: Doctors

SC asks government to provide daily drug doses to TB patients

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • HT Image

    160 liquor shops auctioned in Gurugram east, 568 crore collected

    The Haryana government on Tuesday auctioned 160 liquor vends in Gurugram east through e-tenders and earned 568 crore, an increase of 31.51% on the reserve price, said officials of the excise department. The reserve price is the lowest price at which the department is willing to auction the liquor shop. That's the minimum price the bid starts from. According to officials, the reserve price was 432 crore.

  • The Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation (PCMC) has issued a <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>312 crore tender for the new administrative building, (REPRESENTATIVE IMAGE)

    PCMC issues 312 crore tender for new administrative building

    PUNE The Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal Corporation has issued a 312 crore tender for the new administrative building, which will be constructed on the seven acre land at the auto cluster in Chinchwad. The civic body has invited bids for the new building which are to be submitted in the next 45 days. The building will also have a 300-seater general body meeting hall for corporators. The expenses are expected to be around 400 crore.

  • For representation only (HT File Photo)

    Dust storm in UP puts paid hopes of mango growers

    Mangoes will be in short supply this year, so be prepared to shell out more for fewer mangoes. The dust storm which hit the city with 70km-per-hour wind speeds on Monday may have provided respite from the heat but it left the mango crop severely damaged. Mango growers here in Malihabad said that the high-intensity wind hit the crop that was almost ready to hit the market, hard. The farmers called it a double whammy.

  • HT Image

    DTCP asks buyers to refrain from investing in 15 projects in Gurugram with cancelled licenses

    The department of town and country planning (DTCP), which has cancelled at least 15 real estate project licences in the last five years in Gurugram, on Tuesday prepared an advisory asking home buyers and investors not to invest their money in these projects. DTCP officials refused to share the name of the projects, and said that they will issue the list next week.

  • Lucknow University (File photo)

    Attack on dalit prof: LUTA approaches CM for action

    In a letter to chief minister Yogi Adityanath on Tuesday, the Lucknow University Teachers' Association has requested him to ensure that action is taken against the culprits involved in the “unfortunate” attacks on dalit professor Ravi Kant Chandan on the campus on May 10 and 18. The association's chief Vineet Kumar Verma said a group of students and others gheraoed Ravi Kant on the campus and raised objectionable slogans against him, using indecent language.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, May 25, 2022