‘Truth shall prevail’: Eman Ahmed’s surgeon Lakdawala on negligence charges

Amidst the controversy surrounding the actual weight loss of Egyptian national Eman Ahmed, Dr Muffazal Lakdawala, who is treating her, said “truth shall eventually prevail.”
Eman Ahmed with her doctor.(HT Photo)
Eman Ahmed with her doctor.(HT Photo)
Updated on Apr 26, 2017 08:46 AM IST
Copy Link
Mumbai | ByPress Trust of India

Amidst the controversy surrounding the actual weight loss of Egyptian national Eman Ahmed, Dr Muffazal Lakdawala, who is treating her, said “truth shall eventually prevail.”

Eman weighed around 500 kg when she was brought to Saifee Hospital in Mumbai for treatment in February.

Dr Lakdawala, in a veiled reference to the claim made by Eman’s sister Shaimaa Selim, tweeted:

Shaima alleged that the doctors treating Eman have made “false claims” about her actual weight loss and “complete recovery” in a video released recently.

Dr Lakdawala also confirmed that Eman’s current weight is 171 kg and not 200 kg as per the claims made by her sister.

Dr Lakdawala also tweeted:

Meanwhile, the hospital authorities released the CT scan report of Eman this evening. Her CT scan procedure was pending for long as the scan machine can take the maximum weight up to 204 kg.

“Eman today finally fit into a CT scan machine, for the much awaited scan of her brain. No imaging has ever been done before either in Egypt or in India as her size did not allow her to fit onto the table and the gantry of the CT table,” mentioned an official communication released.

It further said the CT report suggests an old vascular insult in the left middle cerebral artery (MCA) territory of her brain. There is no appreciable area of fresh infarct or intracranial haemorrhage as reported by Dr Rajiv Mehta, chief consultant and head of Department of Imaging Sciences at Saifee Hospital.

Dr Arun Shah, head of department of neurology at Saifee and Reliance Hospitals and Eman’s neurologist said, “This CT scan proves that no fresh stroke has happened after her arrival at Saifee Hospital. The cause of her repeated seizures is due to scar epilepsy.”

“In terms of further management medications and neurological rehabilitation therapy will need to be continued as before,” the communication stated.

Earlier, addressing a press conference at Saifee Hospital in the afternoon, Dr Aparna Bhaskar, who is part of the team of specialists treating Eman, said her sister is criticising doctors because her family doesn’t want to get Eman discharged and wanted to extend her stay at the hospital in south Mumbai.

“I believe that Eman’s family does not want to take responsibility of her further treatment. And they probably do not want to take her back for a long time. I do not think they have confidence that Eman will get good care in Egypt. Obviously, the treatment here is good. By hook or by crook, they (family) want to keep her here,” she said.

Eman has been treated by Dr Lakdawala and a team of around 15 doctors from various disciplines since she was brought here from Alexandria on February 11 this year.

Dr Lakdawala had said on April 11 that Eman has so far lost 262 kgs during treatment.

Stung by Shaimaa’s claims, Dr Bhaskar announced that she was withdrawing from the team treating the Egyptian.

When asked about Shaimaa’s claims that Eman was not fully recovered, Dr Bhaskar said, “I am her doctor and I am saying it on record that she is 75% better than what she was.”

“She will never be able to walk because she has deformed legs. Otherwise, her kidney and liver parameters are fine. Her heart beats are fine,” Dr Bhaskar said.

Saifee Hospital Chief Operating Officer Huzaifa Shehabi said: “There must be some over-expectations (by Eman’s family). There is a language and culture barrier while communicating with Eman’s family. Her health is good and the decision to discharge her in a period less than six months was unanimously taken by the team of doctors treating her.”

“If we can perform her CT scan it means her weight is less than 204 kg. It also means that her sister’s claim that Eman’s current weight is more than 200 kg is misleading,” the COO said.

According to sources, the doctors had told Eman’s family that they would let them know about the future course of treatment after getting her CT scan report.

However, it is not known whether they had specified the exact date for Eman’s discharge from the hospital.

In March, Eman underwent her first bariatric surgery in which doctors reduced her stomach size by two-third. Her genetic tests show she has a rare gene mutation that cannot be cured through surgery.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • An Ola cabs journey went bad when agents stopped a cab to recover loans and left customers stranded in a highway.

    How a Bengaluru man and his family were 'abandoned' by an Ola cab on a highway

    A Bengaluru resident's journey to Mysore with Vikas Gowda's family ended in a nightmare after they were stranded on the highway in the middle of a trip. In a Twitter thread which has gone viral, Vikas Gowda has narrated his ordeal on what he described as a 'one of the worst, traumatising experiences'. In a series of tweets, Gowda recalled he booked an outstation Ola trip with his family to travel back to Mysuru.

  • According to the advisory, no pilgrim will be allowed to go beyond Rishikesh without registration.

    Chardham Yatra: Uttarakhand govt mandates registration for devotees 

    The Uttarakhand government on Tuesday, issued an advisory for the Chardham yatra pilgrims to mandatorily register themselves before commencing their journey. The government has urged the devotees to start their journey only after checking the registration slots available on the portal of the Uttarakhand Tourism Department. The tourism department has also set a certain limit for the registration of pilgrims in the state.

  • A damaged bus that overturned after driver lost control on Lucknow-Agra Expressway, in Unnao district, Tuesday. (PTI)

    Three killed, 25 injured as double-decker bus overturns in U.P.’s Unnao

    Three people were killed and 25 people were severely injured when double-decker bus carrying 50 passengers overturned on Agra-Lucknow Expressway near Bangarmau area of Unnao on Tuesday morning, police said. The bus went out of control and flipped near Sidharpur village of Unnao district, SDM Bangarmau Ankit Shukla said. While one person died on the spot two others succumbed during treatment in hospital. Police were trying to establish the identity of two others.

  • Hasan Ali Khan HT File Photo

    11 years later, PMLA court frames charges against Hasan Ali Khan

    Over 11 years after Khan's arrest on money-laundering charges, a special PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act) court on Tuesday framed charges against Pune-based stud farm owner Hasan Ali Khan and set the stage for starting his trial, at a time when the 70-year-old is critically ill and hospitalised. Special PMLA judge M G Deshpande framed charges against Khan through videoconferencing, in the presence of his counsel, advocate Prashant Patil.

  • Five members of inter-state gang arrested in Prayagraj. (HT Photo)

    Five members of inter-state gang arrested for theft at Prayagraj hotel

    Joint teams of Civil Lines police and Special Operation Group arrested five members of inter-state Jackie Gang involved in sensational theft of cash and jewellery during an engagement function of the nephew of high court Judge at Hotel Kanha Shyam in Civil Lines area on May 12. Some members of the gang are still at large, police said. To note, Chandra Prakash Kesarwani of Ashok Nagar area is brother of a high court judge.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, May 17, 2022