Society can’t decide members’ food habits: legal fraternity

Updated on Jul 18, 2015 11:28 PM IST
The legal fraternity has reacted sharply to the Dahisar incident, where a family was allegedly assaulted by its neighbours for eating meat.
Hindustan Times | By, Mumbai

The legal fraternity has reacted sharply to the Dahisar incident, where a family was allegedly assaulted by its neighbours for eating meat.

Lawyers said there is no legal provision that allows majority members in a cooperative housing society to compel their food habits on others.

Advocate Uday Warunjikar said a co-operative housing society cannot frame bye-laws contrary to the constitutional mandate and the provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.

“There is no legal provision that empowers a society to frame bye-laws restraining a member from eating non-vegetarian food in his flat, and therefore, the action of the [Dahisar housing society] members is unjustifiable,” he said.

If some members try to force others to change their eating habits, it amounts to a violation of the fundamental right to choose one’s own food, Warunjikar said.

Advocate Vijay Kulkarni, who handles matters involving co-operative housing societies, said a housing society cannot have by-laws restricting its members’ food habits. “A society is formed for serving administrative purposes, not to regulate the eating habits of individual members,” said Kulkarni. People doing this will be liable to give a legal explanation [face legal action] for their actions, he added.

Consumer lawyer Uday Wavikar said no by-laws can restrict activities of members within the confines of their flats, unless they are against morality or against public interest.

“A by-law that is against the personal liberty and freedom of a person cannot be adopted. Any action, if it is done inside the house in a personal capacity without disturbing the society infrastructure, cannot be restricted,” he said.

“The society can make a law to restrict activities conducted in public, or on the premises in view of factors such as hygiene or cleanliness, but not inside the house unless they are illegal,” Wavikar added.

“There is no legal provision regulating food habits of individual members of a co-operative housing society,” said advocate Ashish Gaikwad.

Therefore, food habits of members of a co-operative housing society cannot be regulated by other members, he said, adding that members definitely can’t take law in their own hands and manhandle other member of a society for their food choices.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The victim reportedly climbed the terrace wall to raise the flag but slipped while tying it to the pole.

    Bengaluru techie dies while trying to raise national flag: Report

    A 33-year-old software engineer fell to Vishwas Kumar's death Sunday while hoisting the national flat at his home in Bengaluru's Hennur area, according to a report by The Times of India. According to the media report, Vishwas Kumar and his parents are from Karnataka's Dakshina Kannada. Kumar worked at a private IT firm in the city. Kumar died a few hours later. Vishwas Kumar is survived by his wife and a two-year-old daughter.

  • Vidhana Soudha of Bengaluru.

    Independence Day: 5 iconic places in Bengaluru that are illuminated in tricolour

    The country is celebrating the 75th Independence Day and many iconic places across the nation have been decorated with tri-coloured lights. Vidhana Soudha Vidhana Soudha is illuminated in tri colour from August 15 as part of 'Azadi Ka Amrut Mahotsav' celebrations and thousands of people have been visiting the place at night to experience the lighting.2.

  • Maharashtra minister Sudhir Mungantiwar

    No ‘hello’, only 'Vande Mataram' for calls, Maharashtra officials told: Report

    “We are entering the 76th year of Independence. We are celebrating Amrit Mahotsav (of Independence). Hence, I want officials to say 'Vande Mataram' over the phone instead of hellonewly-appointed Maharashtra cultural affairs minister Sudhir Mungantiwarwar announced, news agency PTI reported. He said a formal government order on the same will be out by August 18. The minister made the announcement in one of his first decisions, shortly after chief minister Eknath Shinde handed out portfolios in the state cabinet.

  • HP chief minister Jai Ram Thakur flagging off a Tiranga rally to commemorate 75 years of Independence from Shimla Railway Station on Sunday. (HT Photo)

    HP cabinet gives nod for setting up 76 model wellness centres

    Himachal Pradesh cabinet has given the nod for setting up 76 model health wellness centres. The state cabinet met on Saturday evening wherein it decided to open patwar circle Spilo in Pooh tehsil of Kinnaur district to facilitate the people of the area. It also decided to create patwar circle Shikroha under Sadar Bilaspur tehsil. It gave its approval to create Kanungo circle Kelodhar under Chachiot tehsil of Mandi district.

  • Farmers in Himachal, where apples account for 13.5% of the state gross domestic product, fear that the opening prices offered by Adani Agri Fresh Limited may impact the fruit’s prices in the local market. (Aqil Khan /Hindustan Times)

    HP apple growers dissatisfied with opening prices announced by Adani

    Sanyukt Kisan Manch, an umbrella organisation of different farmers' unions, have rejected the prices announced by Adani Agri Fresh – a company that imports fruit. Sourced from farmers in Himachal Pradesh and Kashmir. The fruit supply chains in Himachal have announced a marginal increase in the opening price for A-grade premium apples for Rs 76 per kilogram against Rs 72 it offered last year.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now