Who waters gardens in the rains? BMC does, pays Rs 45 lakh for it

What makes it worse is when the misuse was pointed out with the help of documents obtained through RTI, the civic body refused to acknowledge it.
Updated on May 19, 2015 10:41 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | ByLaxman Singh, Mumbai

In an amenity-starved city like Mumbai, Rs 45 lakh could easily be used to make a road better, repair a pipeline or to clean nullahs in an area. But the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) doesn’t seem to think so, because otherwise it wouldn’t have wasted the amount on watering plants in Colaba and CST area during the monsoon in 2011 and 2012.

What makes it worse is when the misuse was pointed out with the help of documents obtained through RTI, the civic body refused to acknowledge it.

The misuse of money in the A ward was brought to light by alert citizens Jayesh Jani and advocate Manoj Kondekar. There are 17 major gardens in the ward, of which 15 were given to a private contractor for maintenance and two are with the BMC. The documents obtained in response to an RTI query revealed that A-ward officials had awarded contracts collectively worth Rs 45 lakh to water small gardens, central medians and traffic islands of the area with the help of tankers in June to September 2011 and June to September 2012. When questioned about it, the BMC officials justified their act on grounds that they expected the monsoon to be delayed.

Irked, Jani and Kondekar then collected the data of the rain received in these two years. “Contrary to the BMC’s claims, the Met department’s data clearly shows the monsoon was normal and timely in 2011 and 2012,” said Jani.

The duo made several complaints regarding the unexplained expenditure to the BMC’s garden department, A ward officials, municipal commissioner and chief minister. With no action being taken, they filed a public interest litigation in the Bombay high court on August 1, 2014.

“There are very few central medians, traffic islands and small garden strips in A ward. There are several repetitions in the bills paid to tanker contractors. So the possibility of fake bills can’t be ruled out,” said Kondekar.

“The documents produced by us are enough to show the irregularities. In the last hearing, the BMC filed an affidavit in reply to the case. The next hearing will be held in June. We are hoping for the best, as the civic body has spent public money on watering without any logic,” he said.

An officer from A ward, who is incharge of gardens, said, “The bill may just mention supply of water tankers, but it includes maintenance work.” In its affidavit submitted to the court, superintendent of gardens mentioned the BMC has not watered the plants between June 15 and September 15 in these two years.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Representational image.

    Three members of a family, driver found dead in Mumbai’s Kandivali West

    Three members of a family and their driver were found dead late on Wednesday in Mumbai's Kandivali West, which the police suspect was a deliberate act by the driver who allegedly killed the three before ending his life.

  • Bihar: College asks students to use phone torch to write exam amid power crisis

    Bihar: College asks students to use phone torch to write exam amid power crisis

    Students of a prominent college in Bihar's Munger city were allegedly allowed to write exams using their mobile phone torchlight. The incident was reported from RD & DJ College, Munger on Wednesday when the power had tripped due to inclement weather and the college generator was not functioning either. Another examinee without disclosing his identity said, “The college and university here are playing a cruel joke with students.”

  • According to a Knight Frank report, Bengaluru has been ranked the 14th best city on the APAC Sustainability Index 2021 for sustainable development of commercial real estate. (Source: DSMax)

     Bengaluru in top APAC cities for sustainable commercial real estate: Report

    Bengaluru has been ranked 14 of 20 cities in the Asia Pacific region for sustainable development of commercial real estate by global consultants Knight Frank, news agency PTI said. The top five cities are Singapore, Sydney, Wellington, Perth, and Melbourne. Apart from Bengaluru, three other Indian cities - Delhi, Hyderabad and Mumbai - also made it to the list but were ranked in three of the bottom four places - 17, 18 and 20, respectively.

  • An overcast sky seen on the outskirts of Delhi on Thursday morning. (HT Photo)

    IMD declares onset of monsoon over Delhi; ‘orange’ alert in place for Friday too

    The India Meteorological Department on Thursday announced the onset of the southwest monsoon over Delhi following light spells of rainfall since early hours of the day. “The southwest monsoon has further advanced into entire Uttar Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir; some parts of Rajasthan, entire Delhi and some parts of Punjab and Haryana today, June 30, 2022,” the IMD said in a statement.

  • Bengaluru's COVID cases breached 1000-mark with positivity rate over 4%. The city saw one death on Wednesday.

    Bengaluru daily Covid cases cross 1,000-mark; two deaths reported from Karnataka

    Daily Covid cases in Bengaluru city crossed the 1,000-mark Wednesday, with 1,019 cases reported in 24 hours against the 887 on Tuesday. Daily cases in Karnataka were 1,249, which includes 696 backlog cases, according to data from the health department. Two Covid-related deaths were also reported - one from Bengaluru and the other from Chikkamangaluru. There are now 5,707 active cases in Karnataka, of which Bengaluru has a staggering 5,393.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, June 30, 2022