The budget is about policy while the budget speech is about politics. How did finance minister Arun Jaitley measure up?(PTI)
The budget is about policy while the budget speech is about politics. How did finance minister Arun Jaitley measure up?(PTI)

Budget 2017: What finance minister Arun Jaitley said versus what the numbers show

Do finance minister Arun Jaitley’s budget pronouncements match up to what the numbers say?
By Samarth Bansal | New Delhi, Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON FEB 02, 2017 01:46 AM IST

The budget is about policy, and the budget speech has to strike a balance with politics. How well do they match?

The allocation for MGNREGA is up 1%

What Jaitley said: “Honourable Members would be happy to note that the budget provision of Rs. 38,500 crores under MGNREGA in 2016-17 has been increased to Rs. 48,000 crores in 2017-18. This is the highest ever allocation for MGNREGA.”

What the numbers say: Yes, this is the highest ever allocation for the MGNREGA. But it didn’t go up by much. The demand for unskilled manual work surpassed expectations, leading to a revised estimate: MGNREGA 2016-17 received Rs 47,499 crores, up from the Rs 38,000 crore budgeted last year. So the allocation was hiked by Rs 501 crore — just about 1%.

Jaitley also said that in the last two years, the money spent on MGNREGA has been higher than the amount allocated, while the opposite was true under the UPA government. He’s right.

Allocation to the University Grants Commission (UGC) is still low

Read| Union Budget 2017: Social sector funding up, but not up to scratch

What he said: “In higher education, we will undertake reforms in the UGC. Good quality institutions would be enabled to have greater administrative and academic autonomy. Colleges will be identified based on accreditation and ranking, and given autonomous status. A revised framework will be put in place for outcome based accreditation and credit based programmes.”

What the numbers say: While the finance minister talked about reforming the UGC, which funds and regulates higher education, that is not reflected in the budgetary allocations. In the 2015-16 budget, the UGC’s funds were cut by 53% — from Rs 8,906 crore to Rs 4,185 crore. This year, Rs 4,691 crore has been allocated, a 7% increase but still much lower than the 2014-15 figure.

Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana targets not met

What he said: “The Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana has contributed significantly to funding the unfunded and the underfunded. Last year, the target of Rs. 1.22 lakh crores was exceeded. For 2017-18, I propose to double the lending target of 2015-16 and set it at Rs. 2.44 lakh crores.”

What the numbers say: The government did exceed the target in 2015-16: Rs 1.37 lakh crore was sanctioned. This fiscal year, Rs 1,80,000 crore was the target. But, as of January 27, official data show that the disbursed amount is Rs 97,574 crore, around Rs 80,000 crore short of the target, with just two months to go in the financial year.

Allocation to Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) stays intact

What he said: “We have committed to complete the current target under PMGSY by 2019. I have provided a sum of Rs. 19,000 crores in 2017-18 for this scheme. Together with the contribution of States, an amount of Rs. 27,000 crores will be spent on PMGSY in 2017-18.”

What the numbers say: There was no change in the allocation for PMGSY by the government. The same amount, Rs. 19,000 crore, was allocated last year. In 2016-17, as of January 25, projects worth Rs. 23,201 crore were approved by the Ministry of Rural Development—122% higher than the budgeted amount—a report by the Accountability Initiative found. This scheme got its highest ever allocation — Rs. 19,886 crore — in 2010-11.

Direct Benefit Transfers have slowed

Read| What has the government done with the most important budget schemes?

What he said: “We have made a strong beginning with regard to Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) to LPG and kerosene consumers. Chandigarh and eight districts of Haryana have become kerosene free. 84 Government schemes have also boarded on the DBT platform.”

What the numbers say: These 84 schemes account for 16% of the 536 targeted schemes. Since its inception, Rs. 1.57 lakh crore has been transferred through DBT. In 2016-17, the pace of these transfers has slowed, a report by Accountability Initiative says. As of December 2016, only 45% of the government’s allocations for LPG subsidies; 58% of those for MGNREGS; and 62% of those for NSAP had been transferred through DBT.

Growth in tax collection is up by was highest in 2010-11

What he said: “The net tax revenue of 2013-14 was Rs. 11.38 lakh crores. This grew by 9.4% in 2014-15 and 17% in 2015-16. As per the RE of 2016-17, we will end the year with a high growth rate of 17% for the second year in a row.”

What the numbers say: A 17% increase in tax revenue is not unprecedented. It was much higher in 2010-11: 27%. That was because subsidies given to corporates in the wake of financial crisis of 2008-09 were rolled back in 2010-11. Even in 2012-13, the growth rate was comparable to the previous two years. This year, the growth rate of tax revenues is expected to slump by five percentage points to around 12 per cent.

Income tax collections back to earlier growth trajectory

Read| Union Budget 2017 was a status quo budget for the social sector

What he said: “Because of the serious efforts made by the Government, the rate of growth of advance tax in personal income tax in the first three quarters of the current financial is 34.8%.”

What the numbers say: The growth rate of income tax receipts had been increasing since 2010-11, before falling in the year 2014-15 and 2015-16. The rate has bounced back in the past year.

Gurman Bhatia and Harry Stevens contributed to this story

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Venkatesh and Kumaaravelan fear a severe financial shortfall this year and want the government to make three promises in the Union budget.(HT Photo)
Venkatesh and Kumaaravelan fear a severe financial shortfall this year and want the government to make three promises in the Union budget.(HT Photo)

‘Hope for simplified tax structures, govt support’

By Divya Chandrababu
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 05:30 AM IST
Identifying an opportunity to encash the city’s love for authentic coffee, two friends, Prasanna Venkatesh and M Kumaaravelan, set up an enterprise called Madras Coffee House in 2010.
Close
Whether or not the forthcoming budget can deliver on this depends on how the government deals with an impossible trinity.(PTI file photo)
Whether or not the forthcoming budget can deliver on this depends on how the government deals with an impossible trinity.(PTI file photo)

The impossible trinity facing Budget 2021-22

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 04:44 AM IST
The first shock, similar to many other contraction phases, reflects a sharp reduction in investment and exports, leading to a drastic decline in output and employment. However, the second shock is unique to the pandemic and involves a drastic change in the pattern of aggregate demand due to the technological-cum-structural changes unleashed by the pandemic.
Close
For a decade, Rishab Mitra successfully competed with big stores by focusing on quality, and relying on word-of-mouth recommendations and a loyal customer base.(Deepak Gupta/HT Photo)
For a decade, Rishab Mitra successfully competed with big stores by focusing on quality, and relying on word-of-mouth recommendations and a loyal customer base.(Deepak Gupta/HT Photo)

‘Hope govt helps small businessmen like me’

By Pawan Dixit, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 04:50 AM IST
During the pandemic, the Centre and Uttar Pradesh government provided loans on easy instalments for small shopkeepers, said Lucknow mayor Sanyukta Bhatia. “Large number of shopkeepers and vendors in Lucknow and across the state benefitted,” Bhatia said.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks to the media inside the parliament premises on the first day of the winter session in New Delhi.(Reuters/ File photo)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks to the media inside the parliament premises on the first day of the winter session in New Delhi.(Reuters/ File photo)

Opposition to decide on boycotting meet with PM Modi ahead of Budget session

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 03:56 PM IST
The parties supporting the ongoing farmers' agitation will decide if they want to attend or boycott the meet called by PM Modi over the ongoing protest against farm laws, said senior Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) leader and former MP Prem Singh Chandumajra.
Close
Covid-19 taught Monami Basu that virtual classes cannot replace physical classes.
Covid-19 taught Monami Basu that virtual classes cannot replace physical classes.

‘Hope govt spends more on education sector to bridge digital divide’

By Fareeha Iftikhar, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 20, 2021 02:17 AM IST
Last year’s budget had some allocation for virtual classes and mass online degree courses. “But in spite of that, when this year forced virtual classes and online degree courses on us, we did not see any great improvement in facilities and infrastructure,” said Monami Basu, an assistant professor.
Close
Parliament authorities will ensure maximum protection for members and officials, including a blanket ban on visitors, strict social distancing and the use of masks and other measures.(HT PHOTO.)
Parliament authorities will ensure maximum protection for members and officials, including a blanket ban on visitors, strict social distancing and the use of masks and other measures.(HT PHOTO.)

RT-PCR tests for MPs; Zero, Question hours back in Budget session

By Saubhadra Chatterji, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 20, 2021 02:08 AM IST
The Rajya Sabha will sit from 9 am to 2 pm followed by the Lok Sabha, from 4 pm to 9 pm, Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla announced on Tuesday. As MPs don’t have priority access to Covid-19 vaccines before the session, RT-PCR tests will be done for all MPs, their families, and their assistants.
Close
The Parliament building reflected in a puddle after heavy rain during the monsoon session of the Indian Parliament in New Delhi.(AP)
The Parliament building reflected in a puddle after heavy rain during the monsoon session of the Indian Parliament in New Delhi.(AP)

Budget session of Parliament from January 29: 10 points

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 06:28 PM IST
Here’s everything you need to know about the Budget session this year
Close
Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman.(PTI)
Union finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman.(PTI)

Nirmala Sitharaman holds pre-budget consultation with state finance ministers

ANI
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 05:59 AM IST
The meeting, held through video conference, was attended by chief ministers, deputy chief ministers, finance ministers and senior officers from the states.
Close
The upcoming budget or the first session of this year will take place after 2020 saw two sessions being cut short and the winter session entirely skipped due to the pandemic.(ANI)
The upcoming budget or the first session of this year will take place after 2020 saw two sessions being cut short and the winter session entirely skipped due to the pandemic.(ANI)

Budget session: New seating plan, security rejig likely

By Saubhadra Chatterji, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 05:37 AM IST
Instead of the usually packed Lok Sabha, the proceedings will play out with MPs spaced out in the galleries and chamber of both Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha during the budget speech. They will also be distributed between the Central Hall, Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha for the President’s speech.
Close
App-based cab driver Vijay N says fuel prices should be brought down.( Satish Bate/HT )
App-based cab driver Vijay N says fuel prices should be brought down.( Satish Bate/HT )

‘Want emergency fund, insurance for cabbies’: Vijay N

By Aroosa Ahmed, Mumbai
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 07:18 AM IST
For the 2021 Union budget, Vijay N wants the government to create an emergency fund for drivers and provide insurance to cab drivers. “Drivers who have been operating for six months and do not have any accident on record should be provided with an emergency fund facility,” he said.
Close
BJP Parliamentary party office secretary Balasubrahmanyam Kamarsu has written a letter to members saying that apart from legislative work, important topics are likely to be discussed during the session.(Burhaan Kinu/ Hindustan Times)
BJP Parliamentary party office secretary Balasubrahmanyam Kamarsu has written a letter to members saying that apart from legislative work, important topics are likely to be discussed during the session.(Burhaan Kinu/ Hindustan Times)

BJP tells MPs to ensure their presence in Parliament during budget session

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 08:56 PM IST
It called upon members not to make programmes outside Delhi during the Parliament session and ensure their presence in the House.
Close
The Primary Agriculture Cooperative Society (Pacs) — the official agency to procure paddy on behalf of the state government— has not bought harvested crop yet because the pandemic delayed the process. And local merchants are offering him <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>1,000-1,200 for a quintal of paddy against the minimum support price (MSP) of <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>1,868. (Representative Image)(HT_PRINT)
The Primary Agriculture Cooperative Society (Pacs) — the official agency to procure paddy on behalf of the state government— has not bought harvested crop yet because the pandemic delayed the process. And local merchants are offering him 1,000-1,200 for a quintal of paddy against the minimum support price (MSP) of 1,868. (Representative Image)(HT_PRINT)

‘Want assured income, better deal for farmers’

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 12:40 AM IST
A 49-year-old Dalit landless labourer, Paswan sows paddy on small patches of land adding up to roughly 1.15 acres, belonging to a local landlord, Ras Bihari Singh.
Close
Villagers spray pesticides in a field on the outskirts of Sanand, around 30 km from Ahmedabad on September 1. The five states cited previously have also reported the maximum number of patients that have been cured and discharged, cumulatively accounting for 58.04% of the total 65,081 people who have recovered till September 1. (Sam Panthaky / AFP)
Villagers spray pesticides in a field on the outskirts of Sanand, around 30 km from Ahmedabad on September 1. The five states cited previously have also reported the maximum number of patients that have been cured and discharged, cumulatively accounting for 58.04% of the total 65,081 people who have recovered till September 1. (Sam Panthaky / AFP)

Budget 2021: PMFAI demands GST reduction on pesticides to 5% from 18%

PTI
UPDATED ON JAN 14, 2021 11:22 AM IST
The Union Budget will be presented by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on February 1.
Close
Overall spending levels need to increase significantly and there is also a need to correct the growing sectoral imbalance with a bias in favour of tertiary facilities together with increasing neglect of primary health-care facilities.(PTI File Photo)
Overall spending levels need to increase significantly and there is also a need to correct the growing sectoral imbalance with a bias in favour of tertiary facilities together with increasing neglect of primary health-care facilities.(PTI File Photo)

Health Budget must look beyond Covid mitigation

By Sourindra Mohan Ghosh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 14, 2021 01:54 AM IST
This entails addressing prevailing systemic deficiencies along with managing the added burden of Covid-19. India’s health sector requires a two-fold intervention by the government.
Close

ESOP tax breather among start-up incentives

By Salman SH | Livemint, Bengaluru
UPDATED ON FEB 02, 2020 02:05 PM IST
At present, employees typically pay tax when they exercise their options and when they finally sell their shares. ESOPs serve as an important compensation tool for them, particularly in fast-growing startups, whose valuations multiply at a fast rate
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP