Medical workers in protective suits attend to novel coronavirus (Covid) patients at the intensive care unit (ICU) of a designated hospital in Wuhan, China.(Reuters file photo)
Medical workers in protective suits attend to novel coronavirus (Covid) patients at the intensive care unit (ICU) of a designated hospital in Wuhan, China.(Reuters file photo)

China testing blunders stemmed from secret deals with firms

The testing problems, along with other mistakes and delays, allowed the virus to rip through Wuhan undetected and spread across the world in a pandemic that has now sickened 64 million people and killed almost 1.5 million.
By Associated Press | Posted by Deepali Sharma | Wuhan
UPDATED ON DEC 03, 2020 06:08 PM IST

Secrecy and cronyism at China’s top disease control agency led to widespread test shortages and flaws that hampered the early response to the coronavirus outbreak, an Associated Press investigation has found.

Click here for complete coverage of Covid-19

China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention gave test kit designs and distribution rights exclusively to three then-obscure Shanghai companies with which officials had personal ties, according to the investigation. It was based on interviews with more than 40 doctors, CDC employees, health experts, and industry insiders, as well as hundreds of internal documents, contracts, messages and emails.

The Shanghai companies — GeneoDx Biotech, Huirui Biotechnology, and BioGerm Medical Technology -- paid the China CDC for the information and the distribution rights, according to two sources with knowledge of the transaction who asked to remain anonymous to avoid retribution. The price: One million RMB ($146,600) each, the sources said. It’s unclear whether the money went to specific individuals.

In the meantime, the CDC and its parent agency, the National Health Commission, tried to prevent other scientists and organizations from testing for the virus with their own homemade kits. They took control of patient samples and made testing requirements to confirm coronavirus cases much more complicated.

The flawed testing system — at a time when the virus could have been slowed — stopped scientists and officials from seeing how fast it was spreading. Chinese authorities failed to report a single new case between Jan. 5 and 17, even as hundreds were infected in Wuhan, the city where the virus was first detected.

The apparent lull in cases meant officials were slow to take early actions such as warning the public or barring large gatherings. It also caused critical shortages of testing kits, barring access to care for many who were infected.

The testing problems, along with other mistakes and delays, allowed the virus to rip through Wuhan undetected and spread across the world in a pandemic that has now sickened 64 million people and killed almost 1.5 million.

China was hardly the only country to grapple with testing. In in the U.S., the CDC declined to use a WHO design and insisted on developing its own kits, which turned out to be faulty and led to even longer delays than in China. Still, the hiccups in China were especially consequential because it was the first country to detect the virus.

“Because you have only three companies providing testing kits, it kept the capacity of testing very limited,” said Yanzhong Huang, a senior fellow for global health at the Council on Foreign Relations. “It was a major problem that led to the rapid increase in cases and deaths.”

China’s foreign ministry and China’s top medical agency, the National Health Commission, did not respond to requests for comment.

But interviews and documents suggest that a culture of backdoor connections quietly flourished in a top-down, underfunded public health system. Though none of the first three diagnostics companies tapped to make test kits were well-known in the industry, there were extensive ties between the companies and top China CDC researchers.

The founder of BioGerm, Zhao Baihui, was the former chief technician of the Shanghai CDC’s microbiology lab. Emails and financial records obtained by the AP show that Zhao first started BioGerm’s predecessor through an intermediary in 2012, while she was still at the Shanghai CDC. In the next five years, she sold thousands of dollars’ worth of test kits to her own workplace through the intermediary. After quitting the CDC in 2017, Zhao went on to spearhead lucrative contracts with Shanghai officials.

Zhao did not respond to requests for comment from the AP.

Another of the three companies, GeneoDx, enjoyed special access because it is a subsidiary of the state-run firm SinoPharm, which is managed directly by China’s cabinet. In October 2019, GeneoDx co-organized an internal CDC training conference on emerging respiratory diseases in Shanghai. Tan Wenjie, the CDC official who ran the training, was later put in charge of developing test kits.

GeneoDx did not respond to requests for comment or interviews. The National Health Commission did not respond to a request for a comment or an interview with Tan.

The last company, Huirui, is a longtime partner with Tan, the CDC official in charge of test kits. In an interview, CEO Li Hui said the CDC routinely contracted his company to make emergency testing chemicals. He denied any personal relationship with Tan or any payments to the CDC.

“We’ve been working with the CDC to respond to emerging new diseases for about ten years, not just for a day or two, it’s normal,” Li said.

It’s unclear whether the agreements between the China CDC and the three test kit companies violated Chinese law.

They raise questions around potential violations of bribery laws, along with rules against abuse of authority, self-dealing and conflicts of interest, said James Zimmerman, a Beijing-based corporate attorney and former chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in China.

But other experts caution that the state may have designated the three companies to make test kits under special laws on the procurement of emergency goods during natural disasters.

“Things will be different in the middle of a crisis,” said Lesli Ligorner, a Beijing-based attorney specializing in anti-corruption law. “I wouldn’t be so quick to rush to judgement.”

The first step in making test kits is to get samples of the virus and decode its genetic sequence. This leads to test designs, essentially a recipe for the tests.

In past outbreaks, the China CDC sent test designs and testing compounds to laboratories across the country just days after identifying the pathogen. But this time, they held back the genome and test designs. Instead, they finalized “technology transfer” agreements to give the test designs to the Shanghai companies, according to three people familiar with the matter. The selection process was kept secret.

At the same time, central CDC authorities stymied others from testing. Provincial CDC staff were told that instead of testing and reporting cases themselves, they had to send patient samples to designated labs in Beijing for full sequencing, a complicated and time-consuming procedure. As a result, for weeks, local CDC staff were unable to confirm new cases.

After a Jan. 14 internal teleconference to order secret preparations for a pandemic, China’s health authorities relaxed the requirements to confirm cases and started distributing the CDC-sanctioned test kits. A day after the first test kits finally arrived in Wuhan on Jan. 16, the case count began to rise again.

But the test kits from GeneoDx and Huirui had quality issues, turning out inconclusive results or false negatives. And technicians were hesitant to use test kits that would later prove more accurate from more established companies, because the CDC did not endorse them.

As a result, in the early days, getting a Covid test was so difficult that Wuhan residents compared it to winning the lottery.

Among the victims was Peng Yi, a 39-year-old schoolteacher who started coughing on Jan. 23. When he went to the hospital, he waited for eight hours, only to be turned away for a lack of test kits. Then, when he finally got tested on Jan. 30, it turned out negative, even as the virus ravaged his lungs.

His second test, on Feb. 4, turned out positive. It was too late. Weeks later, Peng passed away.

“There were very, very few tests, basically none….if you couldn’t prove you were positive, you couldn’t get admitted to a hospital,” his mother, Zhong Hanneng, said in a tearful interview in October. “The doctor said there was nothing that could be done.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Concerns are that the ambiguous six doses will soon be factored in delivery numbers.(REUTERS)
Concerns are that the ambiguous six doses will soon be factored in delivery numbers.(REUTERS)

Spain discarding thousands of Pfizer vaccine doses for lack of right syringes

ANI, Madrid
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 12:14 AM IST
The EU medicines regulator said in a guidance update on January 8 that low dead-volume syringes and needles with more effective space than standards ones must be used to get full six doses.
Close
The explosion of Covid-19 has not only overwhelmed staff and facilities but pushed more hospitals into financial distress(AP)
The explosion of Covid-19 has not only overwhelmed staff and facilities but pushed more hospitals into financial distress(AP)

Number of US hospitals and beds dwindled before ‘catastrophic’ pandemic

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 11:09 PM IST
Research issued late Thursday by the American Hospital Association shows the number of facilities dropped to 6,090 in 2019 -- the most recent year data were available -- from 6,146 the previous year.
Close
Janet Yellen's Republican predecessor, Steven Mnuchin, was not confirmed until three weeks after Trump's 2017 inauguration, and then by a 53-47 nearly party-line vote in a Republican-controlled Senate.(AP File Photo)
Janet Yellen's Republican predecessor, Steven Mnuchin, was not confirmed until three weeks after Trump's 2017 inauguration, and then by a 53-47 nearly party-line vote in a Republican-controlled Senate.(AP File Photo)

Janet Yellen wins unanimous Senate panel vote for US Treasury

Reuters, Washington
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 11:08 PM IST
  • A full confirmation vote just days after Biden took office would put the 74-year-old PhD economist quickly to work on a deep economic crisis sparked by the coronavirus pandemic. She broke a similar gender barrier when she became Fed chair in 2014, a role she held until 2018.
Close
Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson said all the current evidence showed both vaccines remain effective against old and new variants(AP)
Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson said all the current evidence showed both vaccines remain effective against old and new variants(AP)

New Covid-19 variant found in UK causes higher mortality, says Boris Johnson

Reuters, London
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:58 PM IST
Johnson said however that all the current evidence showed both vaccines remained effective against old and new variants.
Close
A vendor wearing a mask to protect from the coronavirus walks through her store of Chinese New Year decorations in Wuhan in central China's Hubei province on Friday, Jan. 22, 2021. Life appears to be back to normal on the eve of the anniversary of the 76-day lockdown in the central Chinese city where the coronavirus was first detected. (AP)
A vendor wearing a mask to protect from the coronavirus walks through her store of Chinese New Year decorations in Wuhan in central China's Hubei province on Friday, Jan. 22, 2021. Life appears to be back to normal on the eve of the anniversary of the 76-day lockdown in the central Chinese city where the coronavirus was first detected. (AP)

A timeline: Wuhan, one year after coronavirus lockdown

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:54 PM IST
Following is a timeline of key events since the first cases of the virus were detected in the city of 11 million residents in Hubei province.
Close
FILE - In this July 3, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump stands at Mount Rushmore National Memorial, near Keystone, S.D. South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem says she gave former president Donald Trump a $1,100 bust depicting the president on Mount Rushmore last year because she knew it was something he wanted to receive. The gift was presented to Trump when he visited South Dakota on Friday, July 3, 2020 for an Independence Day fireworks celebration. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File) (AP)
FILE - In this July 3, 2020, file photo, President Donald Trump stands at Mount Rushmore National Memorial, near Keystone, S.D. South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem says she gave former president Donald Trump a $1,100 bust depicting the president on Mount Rushmore last year because she knew it was something he wanted to receive. The gift was presented to Trump when he visited South Dakota on Friday, July 3, 2020 for an Independence Day fireworks celebration. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File) (AP)

House to trigger Trump’s impeachment trial in Senate on Monday

By Yashwant Raj I Edited by Vinod Janardhanan
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:54 PM IST
“There will be a trial. It will be a full trial; it will be a fair trial,” said Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer.
Close
Parler’s domain name is now registered with Epik Inc., a website services company based in Sammamish, Washington.(AFP)
Parler’s domain name is now registered with Epik Inc., a website services company based in Sammamish, Washington.(AFP)

Parler’s new partner has ties to the Russian government

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:45 PM IST
Cybersecurity researchers said Parler’s relationship with DDoS-Guard -- which has fulfilled contracts with several government entities, raises concerns that its millions of users could be susceptible to surveillance if the platform returns online.
Close
A number of the 25,000 troops standing guard around the US Capitol in recent days in the wake of the January 6 insurrection had been allowed to take breaks and naps in between long shifts on the floors of the building housing the US Congress.(AFP)
A number of the 25,000 troops standing guard around the US Capitol in recent days in the wake of the January 6 insurrection had been allowed to take breaks and naps in between long shifts on the floors of the building housing the US Congress.(AFP)

Outrage after troops protecting US Capitol forced to sleep in parking garage

AFP, Washington
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:28 PM IST
Many members of Congress, noting that many of the troops came from their constituencies, voiced outrage.
Close
Now that we are all agreed that Tik Tok is A Bad Thing, where do we go next? (Representational Image)(Unsplash)
Now that we are all agreed that Tik Tok is A Bad Thing, where do we go next? (Representational Image)(Unsplash)

Italy probes TikTok 'blackout challenge' death of 10-year-old girl

AFP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:22 PM IST
The girl died in a Palermo hospital after being discovered Wednesday by her five-year-old sister in her family bathroom with her cellphone, which was seized by police.
Close
Retired Army Gen. Lloyd Austin answers questions during his confirmation before the Senate Armed Services Committee on January 19, 2021.(REUTERS)
Retired Army Gen. Lloyd Austin answers questions during his confirmation before the Senate Armed Services Committee on January 19, 2021.(REUTERS)

US Senate approves Biden nominee Lloyd Austin as 1st Black Pentagon chief

AP
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:05 PM IST
Biden is expected to win approval for others on his national security team in coming days, including Antony Blinken as secretary of state.
Close
U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he arrives at Palm Beach International Airport in West Palm Beach, Florida, U.S., January 20, 2021.(REUTERS)
U.S. President Donald Trump waves as he arrives at Palm Beach International Airport in West Palm Beach, Florida, U.S., January 20, 2021.(REUTERS)

US House to deliver Trump impeachment to Senate on Monday, say Democrats

Reuters
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 10:00 PM IST
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said that the Senate will conduct a full and fair trial of the impeachment of Donald Trump.
Close
A Lockheed Martin F-35 aircraft is seen at the ILA Air Show in Berlin, Germany, April 25, 2018.(File Photo / REUTERS)
A Lockheed Martin F-35 aircraft is seen at the ILA Air Show in Berlin, Germany, April 25, 2018.(File Photo / REUTERS)

Purchase of F-35 jets, drones from US finalised, says UAE

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:59 PM IST
Letters of Agreement were finalized on Tuesday, according to an emailed statement from the UAE’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Close
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei delivers a televised speech, in Tehran, Iran. (Reuters)
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei delivers a televised speech, in Tehran, Iran. (Reuters)

Not suspended Iran's top leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei's account, says Twitter

Reuters
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 09:35 PM IST
A Twitter spokeswoman said the @khamenei_site account was suspended for violating the company's platform manipulation and spam policy, specifically the creation of fake accounts.
Close
The affected doses which have not been administered are accounted for and will not be used(AFP)
The affected doses which have not been administered are accounted for and will not be used(AFP)

Sweden gives 1,000 people Covid-19 shots kept at wrong temperature

Reuters, Stockholm
PUBLISHED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:19 PM IST
  • All of the people given doses from the faulty delivery are healthcare professionals. In total 2,100 vaccine doses - around 20% of what Sweden has so far received from Moderna - were kept at too low a temperature.
Close
Representative Andy Harris, a Republican from Maryland, speaks during a news conference outside the US Capitol, December 3, 2020.(Bloomberg)
Representative Andy Harris, a Republican from Maryland, speaks during a news conference outside the US Capitol, December 3, 2020.(Bloomberg)

Republican Andy Harris tried to enter US House chamber with gun, stopped

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Kunal Gaurav
UPDATED ON JAN 22, 2021 08:05 PM IST
Democratic representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez had earlier raised doubts over the intention of some of her Republican colleagues in the aftermath of Capitol riots.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP