Donald Trump’s thumbs-up photo with orphaned baby in El Paso sparks controversy

The optics of the picture of Donald Trump giving a thumbs-up as his wife, Melania, cradles a baby orphaned in the El Paso, Texas mass shooting struck many on social media as demonstrating a lack of empathy or respect for the gravity of the occasion by the president.
The image was taken on Wednesday at the University Medical Center of El Paso during Donald Trump’s visit to the West Texas border city.(Melania Trump/Twitter)
The image was taken on Wednesday at the University Medical Center of El Paso during Donald Trump’s visit to the West Texas border city.(Melania Trump/Twitter)
Updated on Aug 10, 2019 09:32 AM IST
Copy Link
Reuters | ByReuters

A photo of US President Donald Trump smiling broadly and giving a thumbs-up as his wife, Melania, cradles a baby orphaned in the El Paso, Texas mass shooting has become a social media talking point days after the first lady posted it on Twitter.

The image was taken on Wednesday at the University Medical Center of El Paso during Trump’s visit to the West Texas border city to meet with first responders, medical personnel and surviving victims from Saturday’s gun violence at a Walmart store.

The president and his wife had travelled earlier in the day to Dayton, Ohio, for a similar hospital condolence call in the wake of a deadly shooting rampage that rocked that city just 13 hours after the bloodshed in El Paso.

The two shootings together claimed 32 lives, including that of the gunman who committed the Dayton massacre.

Trump avoided the press during both hospital visits, which were closed to media coverage, but the White House later released a brief video montage of the visits.

 

The first lady also tweeted several photos from the visit, including one that shows her standing in front of a University Medical Center of El Paso backdrop cradling a 2-month-old infant whose parents, Andre and Jordon Anchondo, were both slain in the Walmart attack, reportedly as they shielded him from gunfire.

Standing beside the first lady is the smiling president giving a thumbs-up sign. They are flanked by the baby’s aunt and an uncle, Tito Anchondo, who is also smiling and has his arm stretched around Trump’s shoulders as the four pose together.

The optics of the picture struck many on social media as demonstrating a lack of empathy or respect for the gravity of the occasion by the president.

 

“A baby who was taken from home and forced to serve as a prop for the very monster whose hate killed her/his parents,” Democratic strategist Greg Pinelo wrote on Twitter in response to the photo.

But Tito Anchondo, who described himself and his slain brother as Trump supporters, told the Washington Post in an interview published on Friday that he felt consoled by the president’s visit and denied that Trump was there “pushing any kind of political agenda.”

Anchondo said he chose to take his orphaned nephew, baby Paul, to the hospital to meet the president, and said others were politicizing his family’s tragedy. The infant suffered two broken fingers in the shooting, but had since been discharged by doctors.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • An agreement signed in August 2021 enabled the building of the virtual constellation of specified remote sensing satellites of Brics space agencies. (Representative Image)

    2 Indian satellites to be part of Brics ‘virtual constellation’: Report

    India and China are a step closer to working together in space after a joint commission on space cooperation for the Brics bloc was established at a meeting of the top space agencies of Brazil, Russia, India and China, on Wednesday, according to a report by official Chinese media. Two orbiting Indian satellites Resourcesat-2 and 2A will be part of the “virtual constellation of remote sensing satellites”, a data sharing mechanism among the BRICS countries.

  • Canada's Prime Minister Justin Trudeau shakes hands with a participant in front of Vaccine and Infectious Disease Organization- International Vaccine Centre in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. (REUTERS)

    Trudeau cancels in-person appearance at BC fundraiser over security concerns

    Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was on Tuesday forced to cancel an in-person event with Indo-Canadian supporters of the Liberal Party in the province of British Columbia over security concerns after protesters gathered outside the event venue. Nearly a hundred protesters gathered outside the Aria Banquet Hall in Surrey, a town in the metro Vancouver area, with a large population of Indo-Canadians, where the ruling Party had scheduled a fundraiser.

  • Salvador Ramos, the accused of the Texas elementary school shooting.

    Texas shooting: Accused Salvador had argument with grandmom whom he later shot

    Salvador Ramos, the accused of the horrific Texas elementary school shooting which killed 22, including 19 children, had a minor argument with his grandmother over the payment of a phone bill, Ramdos's grandfather Rolando Reyes said, expressing shock at how his grandson is at the centre of one of the most tragic mass shootings in the United States. Rolando Reyes said he had no idea that his grandson had bought rifles.

  • Representational image

    11 babies killed in Senegal hospital fire

    Eleven newborn babies died in a hospital fire in the western Senegalese city of Tivaouane, the president of the country said late Wednesday. Just before midnight in Senegal, Macky Sall announced on Twitter that 11 infants had died in the blaze. "To their mothers and their families, I express my deepest sympathy," Sall added. "The fire spread very quickly," Sy said. The city's mayor Demba Diop said "three babies were saved".

  • FILE - In this July 20, 2012, photo, a row of different AR-15 style rifles are displayed for sale in Aurora, Colorado. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File)

    AR-15 assault rifle used by Salvador Ramos in Texas shooting: 5 things to know

    List of shootings this year Why is it so dangerous? AR-15 rifles are feared because they fire high-velocity bullets at triple the speed of a handgun, are accurate over long distances, and cause devastating wounds. Over 140 children and adults killed in America's 8 deadliest school shootings The NRA claims the rifles are used for recreational target practice and home defense, but critics say their lethality means they do not belong in civilian hands.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 26, 2022