Is Pakistan PM Nawaz Sharif's disqualification forever?

Updated on Jul 29, 2017 12:35 PM IST
Pakistan SC disqualified Nawaz Sharif after stating that he wasn’t “truthful and honest” about his assets based on the findings of a Joint Investigation Team.
Former Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.(Reuters File Photo)
Former Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.(Reuters File Photo)
Hindustan Times, New Delhi | ByRezaul Hasan Laskar

A key question doing the rounds in Pakistani political circles since the Supreme Court disqualified Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on Friday is whether the verdict amounts to a lifelong ban on contesting for public office.

The answer: The jury seems to be out on that one.

The top court resorted to Articles 62 and 63 of the Constitution – which were inserted by military dictator Zia-ul-Haq and state that a lawmaker can be disqualified if he is not ‘sadiq’ (truthful) and ‘ameen’ (honest) – to unseat Sharif.

The order issued by the Supreme Court stated that since Sharif had not declared his purported income from UAE-based firm Capital FZE in his nomination papers for the 2013 election, “he is disqualified to be a Member of the Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament)” under Article 62. The order did not specify the duration of the disqualification.

If one were to go solely by precedent – the dismissal of prime minister Yousaf Raza Gilani in June 2012 by the Supreme Court under Article 63 following his conviction of contempt of court – the period of disqualification lasted five years. Last month, Pakistan’s state-run APP news agency reported Gilani had again become eligible to contest polls.

But the open-ended nature of the court’s order in Sharif’s case led some to assume the disqualification amounted to a lifelong ban on his political career.

Even seasoned lawyers appeared “to be confused” but some said the issue needed determination since the question had long been pending before a larger bench of the Supreme Court, the Dawn newspaper reported on Saturday.

Tariq Mehmood, a former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association, said the larger bench was dealing with a number of cases in which the “moot point was to determine whether disqualification under Article 62(1)(f) of the Constitution was perpetual or not”.

Former chief justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali, while hearing one such case, had wondered how anyone could be disqualified from participating in elections forever on the basis of Articles 62 and 63 and said people could reform themselves to be qualified under the provisions after being disqualified at some point of time, the report said.

Senior lawyer Raheel Kamran Sheikh indicated the confusion originated from ambiguous nature of Articles 62 and 63.

While Article 63 states the disqualification is for five years, Article 62 does not specify the period of disqualification. He too noted some cases were pending to determine whether disqualification under Article 62 should be restricted to the current election or to should be forever.

Sheikh said the Supreme Court was “in a Catch-22 situation” since, by citing the reasons for disqualifying Sharif, it had “lowered the threshold for ineligibility of elected members to such an extent that too many heads might start rolling in future”.

Through the verdict, the balance of power had been tilted in favour of the Supreme Court and the qualification of parliamentarians had been threatened, he added.

The vice chairman of the Pakistan Bar Council, Ahsan Bhoon, however, contended Sharif’s disqualification was forever. To substantiate his view, he cited a 2013 case in which former chief justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry had said that under Article 63, there were certain disqualifications which were temporary whereas disqualification under Article 62 was permanent.

Former additional attorney general Tariq Khokhar too said Sharif had been disqualified for life since ineligibility for not being ‘sadiq’ and ‘ameen’ was forever.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • US Representative John Garamendi (L) shaking hands with Taiwanese diplomat Douglas Yu-tien Hsu upon his arrival at Sungshan Airport in Taipei. (Photo by Handout/MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS/AFP)

    US lawmakers arrive in Taiwan amid China tensions

    The de facto US embassy in Taipei said the delegation is being led by Senator Ed Markey, who is being accompanied by four other lawmakers on what it described as part of a larger visit to the Indo-Pacific region.

  • Taliban fighters fire in air to disperse Afghan women protesters in Kabul.

    EU scolds Taliban after crackdown on women's rally

    The EU on Sunday said it was "particularly concerned" about worsening conditions for women and girls in Afghanistan after the country's ruling Taliban violently broke up a women's rally. Taliban fighters on Saturday fired in the air and beat up protesters taking part in a women's "bread, work and freedom" march in Kabul. It also stressed that "Afghanistan must also not pose a security threat to any country" per UN Security Council resolutions.

  • Security members stand at the scene where a deadly fire broke out at the Abu Sifin church in Giza, Egypt.

    41 killed in fire at Cairo Coptic church: Officials

    A fire that broke out Sunday in a Coptic Christian church in Egypt's capital Cairo killed 41 people, church officials said. President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi declared on his Facebook page that "I have mobilised all state services to ensure that all measures are taken". Copts are the largest Christian community in the Middle East, making up at least 10 million of Egypt's 103 million people. Egypt has suffered several deadly fires in recent years.

  • Smoke rises from Surmalu market about two kilometers (1.2 miles) south of the center Yerevan, Armenia.

    One dead, 20 injured in explosion at Armenian market

    An explosion at a retail market in the Armenian capital Yerevan on Sunday sparked a fire, killing one person and injuring 20, the emergency situations ministry said. Photos and videos posted on social media showed a thick column of black smoke over the market and successive detonations could be heard. The ministry said there were 10 firefighting trucks on the spot and another 10 were on their way.

  • Chinese President Xi Jinping (Centre) and former presidents Hu Jintao (Left) and Jiang Zemin (Right).

    Xi’s Saudi visit will signal his confidence in getting re-elected as party boss

    Chinese President Xi Jinping's expected visit to oil rich Saudi Arabia could well be an indication of Xi's' confidence in his re-election as the general secretary of the Communist Party of China, which will establish his further grip on power and make him the eternal leader. When asked for confirmation, a Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson said on Thursday that he had no information to offer, according to Reuters.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Sunday, August 14, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now