For Patels living in US, reservation is not the solution

They own a fifth of US motels, many convenient stores called 7-elevens and an ubiquitous chain of grocery shops called Patel Brothers. And they are proud of what they have achieved.
The convenor of the 'Patidar Anamat Andolan Samiti' Hardik Patel, 22, raises his fist near the statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel during the Patel Patidar community's Kranti Rally in Ahmedabad. (AFP File Photo)
The convenor of the 'Patidar Anamat Andolan Samiti' Hardik Patel, 22, raises his fist near the statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel during the Patel Patidar community's Kranti Rally in Ahmedabad. (AFP File Photo)
Updated on Aug 29, 2015 01:46 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | ByYashwant Raj, Washington

They own a fifth of US motels, many convenience stores called 7-elevens and an ubiquitous chain of grocery shops called Patel Brothers. And they are proud of what they have achieved.

Hardik Patel’s agitation in Gujarat has left them cold and angry, though he is not without supporters, some of whom want to show solidarity though a Times Square rally.

A Chicago businessman, who didn’t want to be identified, said he was aghast at the idea of being included in the category of other-backward classes for the purpose of reservation.

“Patidars are a high-caste people, we are landlords,” he said, using the caste name, Patel is a surname. “The community is facing problems indeed because of shrinking landholdings, and paucity of city jobs.”

“But is reservation the answer? Certainly not.”

Read: Give quota or face consequences: Hardik Patel warns BJP in Gujarat

There are an estimated 145,000 Patels in the US, though some tend to peg the number higher — 60% of the 700,000 Americans of Gujarati descent, according to one claim.

It’s a prosperous community known for their highway motels. In a 2012 book “Life behind the lobby”, sociologist Pawan Dhingra said one out of two motels in the US is owned by Indian Americans; 70% of them are owned by Gujaratis—and among them, three-fourths share the last name Patel.

Dhingra told Hindustan Times in an email he is not surprised why some Patels don’t relish the idea of reservation for their community. “They are a proud community of entrepreneurs and have had meaningful success in the United States and other parts of the world. Such a designation can rub some the wrong way.”

Ramesh Patel, a retired Connecticut businessman who heads a body that organizes the traditional India Day parade in New York every year, said he, like Hardik Patel, wants to end reservation, as something that has outlived its lifespan.

“But if it’s not politically possible to withdraw it,” he said, “benefits such as free tuition, travel etc must be extended to all those economically distressed — the poor essentially — irrespective of their caste.”

Hardik Patel too has called for an end to reservation, but, unlike Ramesh Patel, he has argued that if it should continue, Patels must be included in the category of those covered by it.

But the 22-year-old leader of the Gujarat stir has supporters in the US too. Some of them approached Ramesh Patel — because of his India Day experience — to organize a rally at New York’s iconic Times Square. “I refused,” he said, adding he wasn’t sure if that was the end of it.

Read: ‘Dabang’ politics needed for change, says Hardik Patel

Hardik who? He's the man keeping Gujarat on its toes

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • British Prime Minister Boris Johnson makes a statement at Downing Street in London, Britain, July 7, 2022. (REUTERS/Henry Nicholls)

    British Conservative leaders who were toppled by their party

    Duncan Smith, one of a cabal of right-wing eurosceptics dubbed "bastards" by Major, won the Conservative leadership in 2001, replacing William Hague after the party suffered another election defeat to Labour. He lost a confidence vote, becoming the first Tory leader not to fight a general election since Neville Chamberlain, who was accused of appeasing Adolf Hitler in the late 1930s.

  • Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson makes a statement outside 10 Downing Street in central London. Johnson quit as Conservative party leader, after three tumultuous years in charge marked by Brexit, Covid and mounting scandals. 

    Johnson resigns as conservative party leader. Read full text of his speech here

    Boris Johnson said on Thursday that he would resign as Britain's prime minister, bowing to calls from ministerial colleagues and lawmakers in his Conservative Party. Because if I have one insight into human beings, it is that genius and talent and enthusiasm and imagination are evenly distributed throughout the population but opportunity is not. And that's why we must keep levelling up, keep unleashing the potential in every part of the United Kingdom.

  • Boris Johnson, UK Prime Minister, makes a resignation speech outside 10 Downing Street in London, UK, on Thursday, July 7, 2022. (Photographer: Chris J. Ratcliffe/Bloomberg)

    Boris Johnson quits as UK PM, says 'Immensely proud...' | Top quotes

    "In the last few days, I tried persuade my colleagues that it would be eccentric to change governments when we're delivering so much and we have such a vast mandate and when we're actually only a handful of votes behind in the polls even in mid-term after quite a few months of pretty relentless sledging," Boris Johnson said during his address.

  • British Prime Minister Boris Johnson makes a statement at Downing Street in London, Britain.

    What's next for UK economy as Boris Johnson quits?

    The resignation of Prime Minister Boris Johnson deepens the uncertainty hanging over Britain's economy, already under strain from an inflation rate heading for double digits, the risk of a recession and Brexit. Theresa May needed less than three weeks to win after David Cameron quit in 2016 as other contenders dropped out. But it took Johnson two months to become the new leader after May announced her intention to resign in 2019.

  • Outgoing British Prime Minister Boris Johnson

    Boris Johnson resigns as UK PM, says 'sad to give up world's best job'

    British Prime Minister Boris Johnson finally succumbed to political reality Thursday and resigned after the latest ethics scandal around his leadership led some 50 senior lawmakers to quit the government. He said he will continue in office until a new Conservative leader is in place. "It is clearly the will of the parliamentary Conservative party that there should be a new leader of that party, and therefore a new prime minister," Johnson said.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, July 07, 2022